Constructing Homosexuality in British Press, 1835–1954 | Discourse Analysis

Added:

Audience Reception Theory and Queer Agency

While Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) focuses on how the dominant British press 'constructed' homosexuality from the top down, a significant counterpoint comes from Audience Reception Theory and histories of queer agency. Critics argue that text-centric discourse analysis overemphasizes the power of media framing and treats historical audiences as passive consumers. In contrast, reception theory suggests that queer individuals did not passively accept mainstream press pathologization. Instead, they actively resisted, negotiated, and subverted media narratives, reading between the lines to find coded signals and foster community. Furthermore, historians emphasizing subcultural agency argue that homosexual identities and networks existed independently of, and often in defiance of, the medicalized or criminalized frameworks imposed by the nineteenth- and twentieth-century press. Relying solely on media metaphors risks erasing the lived experiences, active resistance, and self-definition of the historical subjects themselves.

Understanding of Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) and Critical Metaphor Analysis (CMA) as linguistic methodologies used to uncover power dynamics in text.
The concept of Social Constructionism, particularly how social categories like sexuality and gender are constructed through language and culture over time.
A basic timeline of British legal history regarding homosexuality, specifically the significance of the 1885 Labouchere Amendment and the era leading up to the 1957 Wolfenden Report.
Familiarity with Media Framing Theory, which explains how media outlets select and emphasize certain aspects of reality to promote a particular interpretation or moral evaluation.
Exploring Michel Foucault's 'The History of Sexuality' (Volume 1) to understand the medicalization, categorization, and institutionalization of sexual identities in the West.
Analyzing post-1954 British media discourses, focusing on the media representation of the Sexual Offences Act 1967 (decriminalization) and the controversial Section 28 in 1988.
Applying Critical Metaphor Analysis to contemporary media coverage of transgender and gender-nonconforming individuals to map current linguistic battles and moral panics.
Investigating how British colonial laws exported specific legal and media constructions of homosexuality to colonized territories, and the lasting discursive legacy in those regions today.
538 views8likes7:16@nocanglistowOriginal Release: 2023-11-24

This research by Anna Góral from Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań examines how British press coverage of three sodomy scandals (1835, 1895, 1954) reveals a trajectory of changing homophobic discourse, using Critical Metaphor Analysis to show how conceptual metaphors evolved from religious condemnation to medical pathologization, reflecting broader societal shifts in understanding homosexuality over 120 years.