Understanding New Criticism: A Literary Theory Guide

Added:

Reader-Response Criticism

Reader-Response Criticism emerged as a direct reaction against New Criticism's insistence that a text's meaning is self-contained and objective. While New Criticism warns against the "affective fallacy"—the mistake of judging a work by its emotional effect on the reader—Reader-Response theorists argue that a text has no real existence or meaning until it is read. Proponents like Louise Rosenblatt and Stanley Fish suggest that literature is a transactional process between the page and the mind of the reader. Meaning is not passively discovered within the text, but actively constructed by the reader based on their personal experiences, cultural background, and interpretive community. This perspective broadens literary study by shifting the focus from a rigid, isolated analysis of "the text itself" to an exploration of the diverse, subjective ways audiences interpret and breathe life into literature.

The definition of literary criticism and the fundamental purpose of analyzing written works.
The distinction between a text's formal elements (structure, tone, imagery) and its external context (author biography, historical period).
Familiarity with basic literary devices such as irony, paradox, metaphor, and tension.
An understanding of traditional 19th-century literary analysis, which relied heavily on authorial intent and historical background.
The concepts of the 'Intentional Fallacy' and 'Affective Fallacy' as defined by key New Critics like Wimsatt and Beardsley.
Reader-Response Theory, which emerged as a direct reaction against New Criticism by focusing on the reader's active role in creating meaning.
Post-Structuralism and Deconstruction, which challenge the New Critical belief that a text possesses a single, stable, and unified meaning.
Applying New Critical 'close reading' methodology to conduct a formalist analysis of a complex poem or short story.
19.3K views313likes5:39@PHILOnotesOriginal Release: 2021-02-14

New Criticism is a literary theory movement that emerged in American universities during the 1930s and 1940s, primarily associated with scholars like John Crowe Ransom, Cleanth Brooks, and I.A. Richards. It represents a reaction against historical and biographical approaches to literature, instead treating the poem as a self-contained, self-sustaining unit of meaning that should be analyzed through close reading without reference to the author's intentions, historical context, or social factors. The movement emphasizes the importance of paradox, metaphor, and the unification of tensions within the text, viewing poetry as possessing an iconic solidity where meaning resides entirely within the formal structure of the work itself.