The flâneuse represents a distinct cultural phenomenon of determined, resourceful women who are keenly attuned to the creative potential of cities and the liberating possibilities of walking, emerging as an entity unto herself rather than merely a female counterpart to the historically male-dominated figure of the flâneur; this practice allows women to engage with urban spaces as agents of their own experience, navigating the complexities of public space while celebrating the ways cities have provided opportunities for creativity, independence, and self-actualization despite historical and ongoing challenges.
Lauren Elkin Discusses Flâneuse: Women Walk the City in Paris
Added:Lauren Elkins essays have appeared in many publications including the New York Times Book Review freeze and The Times Literary Supplement and she is contributing editor at the white review a native New Yorker she moved to Paris in 2004 currently living on the right bank after years on the Left she can generally be found ambling around Belleville which is where we are right now to talk about planners women walk the city in Paris New York Tokyo Venice and London welcome to the bibliophile thank you for having me thanks for coming to my house to do it pleasure planners has been described as a memoir history of biography social commentary travel writing literary criticism that gives the bookseller a bit of a challenge it's the where to put it yeah why did you choose to incorporate all these different types of writing yeah that's a good question I mean it just sort of came out that way it was less of a conscious choice and more just sort of giving myself permission to follow the narrative where it went so I guess that it might be related to the fact that it's a book about wandering in cities I mean that's the sort of you know obvious answer is like well if the book is about wandering aimlessly perhaps the narrative should sort of digress it whistling which is not entirely accurate reflection of the the writing process and the revision process there was a real sense of every chapter having its own kind of focus so there was a city and a major figure in most cases and then a kind of key that I would cast it in so like the idea of being stuck inside in Tokyo or the idea of obedience in Venice or Revolution in the second George Sand chapter so there is a sense that it could because I gave myself permission to just meander just turn into a collection of like things that Lauren thinks are interesting but I had to be really careful in the writing and the revising to kind of give it attention give it a shape make it feel as if it were sort of accumulating into something in addition to being you know a sort of meander through a topic the term Flener has been defined as an idler of a dawdling observer usually found in cities mm-hmm perhaps you could expand on that a bit and also talk to us about what are the benefits of being a winner oh gosh okay so the term Flener is one that I think is kind of a power trope in the way that we talk about the city I mean if you just look on Twitter at a kind of random sampling of urban Twitter accounts you'll find a lot of the time people sort of self identifying as a fan Oh Donna likes cupcakes like that that's sort of you know very millennial relationship to the city and to what we do in this city I think it captures a way that we like to think about being curious about the city and maybe maybe there's a sort of intellectual like anti-capitalist idea behind our taking up of the flat no this idea that we're not going to be subject to the clock or two appointments we're just going to sort of take the day as it comes so I think there is something very attractive about the idea of the Flener there's at the same time this might speak to the second half of your question the benefits of being a fun node there is this sense that some people have access to that kind of mode of being in the city that other people don't and for the purposes of my book I was drawing the line between men and women or men sort of historically having more access to the city in a kind of casual way than women have historically had rustic got more money so I think that that's the you know I I drew this split male/female because of this historic figure of the Flener but I think you could there are all sorts of other sort of intersectional ways in which you could say like it's a question of money is a question of ability it's a question of you know race there are all sorts of ways in which the way that we present in the city allows us to navigate it more or less unhampered or allows us to kind of disappear into the crowd so that's a benefit of being a fun no I think as you can sort of disappear into the crowd be you know the the agent of the gaze or the object of the gaze to sort of take it all in go wherever you want have mostly on harassed experience of the city and that's not what sort of the the female experience of the city has always been which is a kind of a charged term right now harassment yes yes it is and and in writing the book I I actually began with this whole sort of treatise about street harassment in the introduction that included a sort of Prout proto me to lists of all the times when me or my friends had been attacked in the city it was like a you know like a diatribe and I ended up cutting it because it felt like I don't know that's not really what the book was going to be about after all like I wanted it to be a kind of celebration of the ways in which cities have been really creative places for women to engage with not free from risk and I think that's clear throughout the various chapters that there are women you know taking certain risks and engaging with the cities the way they do on foot but yeah I'm not feeling like I wanted to have a big chapter about street harassment and and how horrible cities are for women because that's very mean you just go on the internet and google street harassment and you'll see a lot about that but maybe there's this untold story or now I've started trying to tell the story of ways in which cities have been places of you know I don't know creativity and like independence and and self-actualization for women in spite of the fact that there are also these sort of ways in which where the city doesn't open itself up to us the way it does for a male for now you talked about I just quote you here a determined resourceful woman the keenly attuned to the creative potential of the city and the liberating possibilities of a good wall and so that begs the question what first of all what is the creative potential of a city and what are liberating possibilities hmm I think the creative potential of a city probably depends on who you are and what kind of city you like I am a native New Yorker and an adopted Parisian and so for me a city is really defined by you know as Jane Jacobs said in her sort of wonderful ode to the West Village you need to have like the ballet of the sidewalk lots of people and going and a sort of I don't know improvised choreography the sense that there's there's drama on the street and and we're all sort of taking part in it or we're keeping eyes on the street and so there's there's a sense in which we're looking out for each other so for Mia I need to be in a city that has that kind of feeling to where people walking around there's lots of like shops and I don't know people I bling people on the sidewalk it's hard to it's hard to describe what that kind of essential thing is that that makes a city creatively potent for me there are cities where I feel that less and I didn't write about those in the book but they're you know they're cities that's you know like Los Angeles I went to a really long time ago I haven't been back in adulthood but I'm really curious to get back to it because I remember feeling like it's just a car culture and it didn't interest me very much but I have a lot of friends who live out there and say like you know there there is a way in which it's so so atmospheric there is this sense of like you do need a car in certain places and other places you don't but even in the places where you have a car like will self was telling me how much he loves to walk in LA even though it's not a walking culture it still has like something to it you talk about the creative potential attunes to the creative potential of the city or is that does that make you more creative or what what does it do I think that so cities in in this sense of like potentiality as being like a power contained in the city that you can tap into and I think that it's not like I as I was saying like I could go to LA and not like tap into the creative potential of the city I think that I don't want to be really snobbish about you know cities that I don't like because lots of other people do like like Tokyo I write about really hating it at the beginning and not seeing a way to tap into the creative potential of the city not seeing a way to sort of connect up what makes me really excited to walk around or to read about the city's history or to write about the city or engage with it in some kind of creative way as a writer and a reader that's how I engage creatively yeah but other people do so it's a question of yeah whether or not cities can awaken that desire to create in us or whether or not we can understand how that city is powerful or yeah I mean the Tokyo chapter really it's it's in the middle of the book and I wanted to include it because it seemed important to write about a city that was challenging for me to walk in not that I think it's challenging for everyone to walk in but that when I got there it was very surprising and disappointing and made a stark contrast with Paris where which is a place that I love and where I would have preferred to stay but for various reasons I ended up going to Tokyo and so I felt it was important to include the sort of narrative of how when I got there I loved it and I couldn't figure out a way to like enjoy it and it seemed like all around me all these other people were you know singing its praises like if this great world capital and I was like it just seems so ugly and confining how personal yeah exactly but then by the end of the time that I spent there I I sort of came to understand the ways in which the relationship I was in which was providing the framework both the reason for my being there and the frame through which I was seeing the city was really the thing that was holding me back and it was trying to see the world through my ex's eyes or through his sort of frames of reference that meant I couldn't sort of understand Tokyo or you know get to grips with Tokyo and as I drifted away from him and sort of focused on my relationship with the city I was a lot happier there and got more into it so now I can't wait to go back to Tokyo it was almost like if you just breaking away from your ex here able to fall in love with the city the next the the next guy yeah exactly yeah I definitely have a that kind of relationship to cities or there was a period of time when it felt like I was married to Paris but I was cheating on Paris with London because I'm go to London you know every so often and now I've just renewed my commitment to Paris and yeah I've left lots of guys because they didn't want to live here left here yeah it's always been Paris over over a guy for a long time the flan era was born in 19th century Paris on the boulevards and our caves of Haussmann's newly-redesigned City so what about Samuel Johnson and the poets I think it's Richard Savage they used to ghost all night long all around yeah all the time yeah I think that there's a specific history of fennely in Paris that you know you can trace back to the arcades even before the arcades it really sort of gets codified at that moment in the mid 19th century but that has to do a lot with the modernizing city and with the invention of spaces in which to walk where you'd be safe from like horses and carriages and horse dung and people tipping feces out their window but yeah that that doesn't that doesn't mean that it hasn't existed in other cities but that kind of strolling I think has its own flavor in London I mean I might it's not my field I don't know enough about London like before the 20th century so it feels like the way that Paris is modernizing and creating these spaces for people to walk seems to coincide with the usage of the term flour and the term Flannery in in really specific ways but I don't know what what the history of strolling is in London yeah this is another interesting point with the Flannery the crowd is his domain the man of means and leisure not involved he's not involved he's detached and perceptive has a perceptive eye so if the crowd is his domain and yet he's not involved and he's detached so how do you read those two yeah this is this is going back to like this sort of paradox of modernity and what it is to be an individual in the city you see this in georg simmel you see it in Baudelaire this sense of being being threatened by the anonymity of the city you know it's like this ocean that threatens to swallow you up but then that also the same feeling that the city invites you to be very much yourself to be very much an individual similar writes elsewhere about fashion and the paradox of fashion being about having to fit in and you know be wearing what's what's fashionable what's stylish but also at the same time the obligation to be like to have your own style that's distinct from anyone else's so I think that's sort of what similan Baudelaire and all these sort of 19th century or early 20th century observers of the city are picking up on this sense that you can feel very alone in the city and also be surrounded by people it's it's less a question of reconciling these two ideas and more a question of I don't know accepting that that's that's just what it means to live in a city to always be alone but to always be surrounded or to feel part as I've read about in the George Sam chapter of this like these amazing moments of collective whatever a collective revolt or collective rejoicing that you're sort of irrevocably linked to other people in a way that you sort of aren't aware of when you're not in the in the sort of urban throng you grew up in the suburbs yes exactly and Long Island the suburbs are sort of the opposite of a city in that they're so homogeneous and car oriented and strip malls you basically rebelled against that but you just wanted to get the hell away from that yeah yeah yeah I think that that is what sensitized me to the importance of the collective the fact that I grew up in a place where everyone was atomized in their own little house and you know you just take the car from your house to school or while you take the bus from the house to school but your car to go shopping or your car to go wherever everyone's in their own little bubble with their own music playing or their own conversation no one takes public transport there's much less of a sense of accidental encounters you might run into someone you know like at the butcher and I don't want to detract from the fact that like to the people who live in them these do feel like communities they're just different sorry they're differently formed communities than what I have in the city but it still felt to me like living in the suburbs was ultimately about living for yourself and your family and not really caring that much about people around you I think that's why in America you see because most people live in suburban communities you see to build your own castle yeah exactly that that that sense of individualism that like pioneering sense of like I'm gonna look after me and my family you know fuck the other guy this and why people throw themselves into the church because the church is like where they have their community and they remember oh right communities are great we might be living in our most houses with our little cars taking us protecting us from from the world but actually it's really nice to come together in in these ways so I think that the way that people have have pattern to their lives in America I find like really just wasn't it wasn't my cup of tea and I think that it does lead to very questionable Republican style individualism and a rejection of the idea that we need to look out for each other there has you know the idea of the social safety net I think is important to people on the left because people on the Left send time to live in cities and are you know faced with people's lives that are not like their own and their ex right in their face on the doorstep so I think we feel we feel responsible for each other in a way that you can just forget about when you're coming and going between you know your home in your office in your car father is an architect yeah did you absorb some of his appreciation for manmade surroundings I think so yeah I mean I just have always been aware of the fact that the environment around me is built was built by someone like my dad so I think when you come into the world or when your view of the world is shaped by that idea that things are constructed it gives you a kind of obvious affinity for the built environment and then interest in the way that things are put together but also a kind of built-in sense that like there are people who determined that we should live this way and they're fallible and perhaps we can question them and think about other ways we might want to live let's get back to masculine privilege this is probably the most quoted line from the book as if a penis I'm sure I've seen it folded I'm almost every really okay as if a penis were a requisite walking privilege like a cane you say that most French dictionaries don't even include Flemish women were oppressed in cities and one of the definitions of a flaner is connected to invisibility and the fact that it was difficult for women to be invisible due to societal surveillance and street harassment so when did all of that change then I think you start to see a really key moment of transformation towards the end of the 19th century with the rise of the department store for instance which is a key flashpoint in talking about access to the city or visibility within the city because for instance the sort of classical idea of the Sun who would have that he is distinct from the city and not uninvested but that he's not taking part in it he's an observer he's definitely not shopping he's not like out to acquire or to have sort of financial transactions he's not a dandy he's not you know interested and having people be impressed by what he's wearing he's like the epitome of almost the ghost in the city who slips by unnoticed and then women as they are sort of invited into the public sphere through the the rise of the department store of the cinema of sort of cafes where you could go like tea houses you know that we're sort of you know they're always been in cafes in Paris but you know only a certain kind of woman would go and sit in one alone or with a man and drink or smoke but so as as that becomes more socially acceptable you start to see just a variety of different ways to engage with the city that are that to my mind are still I still kind of growing out of that the gaze of the flower oh the interest in what's happening what I'm trying to say is that there's this way in which the Flener we think of as being there but unseen and definitely not like buying and selling and that women once they've entered public space are there because there are these new ways of buying and selling or these ways of consuming culture taking part in culture and they're being invited into that sort of urban spectacle in a way that allows them to be agents of the gaze as well as objects of the gaze for me it comes back to that John Berger quote is it men act and women appear or women watch themselves appearing that the privilege of the Fenna is that he's allowed to sort of be what he wants but women are slotted into one of two categories are you watcher are you being watched or are you watching yourself being watched so it just becomes a lot more complicated I guess and fraught for a woman in in public space than it is for a man but I should say mean sort of the thing that has me like bracketing in my mind everything that I'm saying is that the the Flener himself as I say in the book is how to say it like he's he's a cipher he he's a figure who arises out of 19th century like newspapers columns and newspapers cartoons novels and he means something different to different writers at different moments so there's I think like the the Balzac Flener is like a desperate man as well as an idle one so bears I know it's very often the artists you sort of you know out in the city taking notes and then going home to write his magnum opus there is this sense that Baudelaires Flener who's the you know the artist of Modern Life was you know constant Angus taking all of these these notes and making all of these quickly drawn portraits is not necessarily the same Flener who appears in different accounts over the course of like 100 years so it seemed to me that the Flener himself was an unstable figure we couldn't really agree on what he was there for we couldn't say there could be no female version of a flat now because we didn't even know what we were negated anyway or feminizing anyway so it seemed much more useful to me to just cut the whole conversation about the fun is free from the idea of the fathanah and invent her as as you know her own sort of entity like women walking in the city women practicing Sanofi would be a fun is so it is a female version of us I know but it's not a woman doing the things that a man does it's a woman doing the things that she wants to do in the city crew she talks about the the female counterpart as that the pest song yeah that's that's fine and and you know worthwhile and interesting and everything but it's like what is she passing it still feels like it's rooted in Bruce's perspective which is you know of course a masculine perspective even if you know this idea of masculinity is itself on the stable I don't mean to like conjure up proofs just like this staple male watcher but it's still a perspective other than the you know the woman isn't the pass off like what is she passing like she's the she's the subject not the the thing that you observe passing by something else so I guess that's you know and it's kind of rooted in that book in pissant which is very much about you know Butler or that his narrative double like watching this mysterious woman you know come and go in the city and she has no he doesn't speak to her she's just she's just this like woman who mystifies him she doesn't have any specific life of her own or or interior mind or whatever it's funny we're hearing so much about this New Yorker short story cat person have you read it mm-hmm it's worth looking at it's it's kind of like written with incredible precision but it's it's about sex from the perspective of this 20 or 20 year old girl and how confused she is and she's sort of you know I don't know figuring things out for herself over the course of this encounter that she has with this guy and a lot of people have have been outraged for the fact that the guy has no we don't know she sort of mean about him she's has some nice things about his body and how like he's kind of a loser in certain ways and people have said like this she's so mean to this guy this poor guy and the BBC went and had like commissioned someone to write a satire from the guys perspective and it's like but the whole point was that for once we had a perspective from a young woman's point of view you just don't hear about that young women are they're like kind of an homage expected to yeah it was the brutally honest yeah exactly so we really didn't need the guys perspective because we could just look at the history of Western literature for the guys perspective for once we had you know the women's perspective so anyway it's worth looking at that short story I think on this question hmm almost every conversation on the face of the planet these days includes Donald Trump and so why don't we just look at the group's reaction to Trump being elected and that huge woman's March hmm they weren't really being planners though they had a objective yes definitely so in my sort of reading of the funnies I'm trying to push this idea or not push it but sort of explore all of the different implications for what it means to be a woman walking in the city and I think a pretty far-out interpretation of it is political walking or walking in a group so that the sort of idea behind the political march is visibility this idea we are going to manifest ourselves publicly and say we are not Russian BOTS pretending to be Nebraskan housewives we are people this is any idea that we're marching in favor of or we're protesting this other idea about the way that we should live our lives so it seems like with the political March we're very far from the idea of the Flener going for a stroll with nothing particular to do but we are in the realm of misery which is women making themselves visible on the city streets Thank You Zack the streets yeah exactly yeah exactly reclaiming them so I think that that's that falls under the heading of the Sun is is not just a female version of fun sometimes when women walk in the city it is with great purpose there's a chapter on earth Martha Gellhorn towards the end of the book where she's walking around to the streets of Madrid during the Spanish Civil War interviewing people to say like you know what she has in mind that she will write an article on the basis of what they tell her but she's sort of getting a sense of what people are living through in wartime through that that sort of active Sun is really or you know to say she had an objective there that's not really flynn azure it it's it is because it's a woman out on the city streets like you know tapping the creative potential of the city so it's not that it's not what the flower does in that sort of classical sense but I guess my argument is that if we can't agree on what the Flener I was doing because flow bares artistic fun out is like taking notes and then going home and writing his novel then I think it gives us not that we need permission but you know it gives us permission to open up the idea of what it can be to walk in the city sometimes walking aimlessly in the city can turn into something else or can give you the material that you want to go and do something much more political or more artistic so yeah I loved the women's March that was very exciting yeah that's that was Hoffy osis of my book from you it's like look at these millions of women walking in the city streets telling this man you know we are watching you and we are here and one one misstep and we'll be out here again and I mean I don't know I wrote an article about it for the pool where I recalled the women's march on Versailles which was a real turning point in the French Revolution I mean the story the best deal was fine but they only saved like or freed like four or five people or something storming the the woman's marshalling beside they ended up getting the Queen and the King to come back to Paris with them so you can just sign yeah exactly yeah exactly so yeah like let us not underestimate that is a quote from Flo banner that I use as the epigraph to one of the chapters it's like 40,000 citizen s's could make the hotel-de-ville tremble so yeah Trump should reread reread his flow bear quote-unquote reread well they say black women mm-hmm beat Roy Moore yeah exactly thank you to them mm-hmm I guess Alabama thanks them and then and then the country that won't remove from that you intersperse opinion and experience the opinion and experience of a sorority of planet flan oozes with portraits of among others Jean Rhys Virginia Woolf Martha Gellhorn as you mentioned in George Sand and with George Sand she took to cross-dressing to aid mobility and invisibility even though it was illegal mm-hmm that's pretty impressive commitment walking yeah yeah exactly she's amazing in the George ten in that George Sanchez there are two of them um I was trying to yeah get to grips with with sand as crossdresser and city Walker in a way that didn't fall yet again into the trap of like Oh George Sand she liked to dress like a man and smoke cigarettes like the kind of myth of it you know affair with Shobha that we've seen in a bunch of like movies about her life it just felt like because it was a chapter about revolution and I was trying to understand like the spirit of the streets of Paris that can make people just go from one day to the next like doing their job to building a barricade I was trying to understand the way that that a very daily life of the streets can make you do things that you wouldn't normally do or take a risk that might seem outsize to you so it felt important in getting to grips with sand as like a real flesh-and-blood person not just a myth to understand why like what was her physical experience of life in the city that led her to want to wear men's clothes and do all of the other things that she's so famous for doing so it felt like yeah it felt like the the walking and the wearing men's shoes were were really she says it herself there they're tied together and that's what that kind of freedom that she's able to taste is what gives her even more of a taste to take the risks that she takes in her life and in her writing homosexuality was illegal I had no idea that cross-dressing yeah yeah you had to get like permission from the city if you wanted to wear trousers if you were a man that you're a woman yes sorry if you were a woman yeah this bizarre yeah yeah and then of course this lower class women prostitutes who enjoyed a certain kind of invisibility but I think they even they were really circumscribed I mean so to go back just to this idea of how bizarre it was that it was illegal for women to wear trousers this is a culture that has a lot invested in everyone I mean they had France still does and every ones that are performing their own gender role in a really circumscribed and socially approved way so women had to be women and wear skirts and like it's just very confusing if they're wearing trousers like you know it's like threatening to the very fabric of French society so prostitutes again in in the 19th century start to be tracked and registered assigned certain kinds of clothing in certain neighborhoods where they could you know for the ones that walked you could only like walk between here and here and but not like get off your beat so there there's the sense that there are certain parts of the city that are approved for loose women to wonder like this yeah exactly they couldn't just go wherever they wanted and they couldn't wear whatever they wanted and they had to go regularly for their medical check-ups they had to be sort of registered in this book which doesn't mean that there weren't women who were living off the grid there were but you know mostly this this idea of the prostitute is someone who had the run of the city by the 19th century when the Flener is really codified as a figure she's also being codified it's a very specific her her sort of freedom in the city is being freedom quote/unquote such as it was is being corralled in a certain way there are working women as well out on the city streets I mean when when we talk about women not having the right to be alone on the streets we're talking about a certain kind of middle class or upper middle class woman who has a reputation to protect working-class women of course also had reputations to protect but they weren't as under threat from coming and going between work and home as you know a middle-class woman you could look at trying to remember the name of it there's a really wonderful George Sand novel about these low hat they were called lor et te like kind of lower middle class are working-class young women who worked as seamstresses or in factories and and were sort of like these I don't know if you think of like the 1920s in Paris being full of these flappers or young girls who were sitting and smoking and drinking in the cafes the low hats or the media nets or the version of that and you know a hundred years earlier who George Sand writes about in this novel that I'm totally blanking on I think it has like a man's name like Horatio Horace that's it I love them so anyway they do exist they are there and they are worried about their reputations as well but they do have slightly more access to the city streets than women of a higher rank or something mmm there's a lovely incident you talk about referring to Virginia Woolf identifying Tavistock hotel the current Tavistock hotel is the place where Woolf entertained in her garden good flinters must bring a mind furnished with literary and social history with feeling for people in places of the past and obviously a good imagination too and it seems to me that you you have to you have to know the place yeah before you could come up with with that vision over that that observation that describes what a flan is would do yeah exactly I sent so many years reading Virginia Woolf and her Diaries in her essays and and obviously the novels that I had almost a kind of imaginary London in my mind as a result of that so you know spending time in in real London it's like you just go to your point of reference which is Oh to have a stock square of course this is where Wolfe lived and where her building was bombed and she talked about in this letter Darrell's might seem like the kind of outline of her living room where she had so many parties and wrote so many books with like the the facade torn off of it so yeah I think there are these these images that you have just like indelibly marked in your mind and and that becomes almost the way that you see the city look through that lens you know it's hard to go to Venice without a very specific idea of it from like movies and books and poetry that's in Venice yeah exactly yeah we go to many in the book right exactly we just hear Mahler when we you know turn up in Venice and it's very hard to get to the city like behind that or apart from that but actually maybe it's not that important to see I mean this is this is what I've wrote about in my Venice novel the sort of attempt to like get off the beaten path as like ultimately impossible because the whole the whole city is one big beaten path and what does authenticity even mean in a place that's been so trodden and poured over and you know maybe maybe what is so wonderful about living in a city like that or visiting a city like that is enjoying the interplay of all these references and the fact that we hear more when we step off the boat to be a good plan as you need strong legs airy addition and as we said imagination and to be in touch with ghosts hmm yeah definitely I mean the strong likes part that's like it's not necessary but I think you do need an active imagination and and yeah the willingness to see the city as more than just like I think Jonathan ray-ban makes a really nice distinction between the hard city in the soft city the hard city being like the buildings and the BAL ARDS and there's sidewalks and you know the stuff the built environment and then the soft city is what I was just talking about like the fact that you you see have a stock square through the lens of having Redford numerals letters and the sense that it's it's a city built out of experience or or effect like a kind of effective engagement with the face of the city that is both created by the hard environment or the built environment but also kind of goes beyond it and it's changeable for you and different for me than it is for you so yeah I think that that imagination or that kind of willingness to enter into the soft city is something that suddenly not everyone has but I think like if it's suggested to them they might say oh yeah I guess like there have been times when I've been daydreaming about this or that you know place in the city so yeah I think we get stuck into the humdrum of everyday life and it's very understandable that you know people are preoccupied with more more pressing matters than just like what might have happened on this city street but I think that it is something that that enriches your experience of the city and enriches that humdrum daily grind if you can tap into it I'm put in mind of the Woody Allen movie about Paris Jarrell yeah yeah yeah both of them what do you think of that I have mixed feelings about that movie it's definitely a feel-good movie there so in the opening sequence there he shows like different spots in Paris I think like sepia tone with like a jazz soundtrack and he's really he's he's just laying it out there this is gonna be a feel-good movie about like a mythic and engaged with the mythic whatever of Paris but one of those early shots is of a movie theater at Odeon and that's exactly the theater that I saw it in so everyone in the theater went oh my God look we're on the screen with such a weird meta moment um so there's you know I kind of love that movie because I love Paris for a lot of the reasons that you know Owen Wilson's character and the movie loves Paris but it's also just so such a selective irritatingly selective view of Paris and and you know I don't know I have very mixed feelings about Woody Allen in general since we're talking about you know the context of harassment and and I think his he's like I mean worse than like Merchant Ivory ever has been in his like sycophant tree of this is that even though of like the wealthy and I just never met anyone who talks or behaves like that girl's family and in that film soon I don't know I I have I have obviously really really makes feelings about it but I think that you know that like flashbacks to to that imagined Paris of the 1920s or like really sweet and adorable say yeah they're nice moments but on the whole I find it suspect well he got funded by the city of Paris - yeah yeah you've researched women how women used cities as places of self-discovery not the female version of the flan ours we talk about the more subversive appropriation of urban space so how do you use a city to discover yourself it's not so much a choice so much as you just realize you're doing it but how could you use the city to to discover yourself I think it either works for you or it doesn't I think there you know probably people living in cities that they don't really like and if no like way of moving anywhere else and like I don't know hopefully like they can just make the most of it but I I don't I don't know if you're not really inspired by a place I don't know how you could use that place to to discover yourself particularly but if you are inspired and so how does that help you discover who you are I think there's something about the like inherent inherent fragmentation of the city of the experience of the city the way it's it's always different there's always different things happening different people coming and going they can help you sort of confront the fact that we don't have unified selves like we ourselves are fragmented and different everyday and you know we might have certain characteristics that carry us through our lives but I find it very reassuring for example the way that things are always changing in a city I say that I get really like crotchety and like frustrated in a really like reactionary kind of way when I walk around Paris and I see the whole thing's becoming like a hipster fairyland nearly enough with the metro tiles enough with the Scandinavian wood you know I feel kind of nostalgic for the way it was but at the same time I take great solace and the fact that things are changing all the time and and that's true of the city and that's true you know as baudelaire side of the human heart like he was lamenting the fact that that shape the form of the city changes more quickly than the form of the human heart but there's that sense that we're we're all changing together and even if things feel very bad there's always the next day and there's always another version of you interacting with different people or different ideas or different books or a different Street in the city so I'm not sure if that is a kind of guide to self-discovery or if it's just a guide for coping but maybe there's some relationship between coping and self-discovery it's funny listening to you speak there about change it reminds me of the line about how men want women to stay the same and women want men to to change yeah that's true you're both both both are both are wrong life could be meaningful even if it was unhappy oh right yeah that's the receptor I think so how'd this city help you to understand this oh god that's so Paris specific and it's also really specific to being like 20 years old not that I've gotten over that like you know the taste for melancholy but yeah I think Paris is a city that as I write about in that chapter really like I don't know kind of Stokes a kind of melancholic reflection and where was it wasn't like the Guardian a couple of years ago or something there was some sort of study that showed that French people were among the least happy in the world and France saw there saw that and liked shrugged and they're like who says we have to be happy like why is happiness like the great goal and I think you feel that living in Paris that you know happy it sounds like something that like a children the child's worth I can't be be like who wants to be happy well that's what America is about it is not meanness yeah exactly but I think Paris is about the pursuit of like pleasure which you can you and hopefully access even if you're not particularly happy like a good bottle of wine or walking by the Sun has its own kind of melancholic pleasure even if you're feeling heartbroken or bereft obviously there have been times in my life where I've been you know out of my mind with grief and like walking in the street in Paris doesn't fix it so we're not talking about like the outer edges of despair but just a kind of post-breakup kind of melancholy I think it's the kind of thing that Paris is like it cradles and it makes you feel like it's okay and that's just part of what life is life doesn't have to be one long succession of happy moments mm-hmm that's about a change in that yeah exactly what's the difference between a warrior and a flaner ha that's a good question I don't know that there is much of a difference I wrote an essay a couple of years ago on how much I cook in my neighbor's windows and I don't think that there's anything necessarily creepy about that as long as you're not you know doing it in some kind of sick way or like filming them or I don't know I have this wonderful book here I can't really see it but um but it's all these amazing photographs all these really beautiful photographs of looking in creation windows right and she says in her introduction that she's like a happy a happy boy or something like she's not she's not trying to be a deviant or or you know take advantage she's not getting it sexual thrill up yeah exactly she's just like she's curious yeah exactly she's curious and she has a good will towards these people and I think actually they're these are these were what's the word staged like these people know that they're they're being photographed hmm but it does you know it's it's a very Parisian sort of thing this visa vie like we have a visa Vee you see across the courtyard to those people they always watch television on their massive like big-screen TV and so I never see that my own seat but yeah I like that it's about companion ability in the city so I think you know where's I'm it gets it gets a bad rap mm-hmm it reminds me of rear window though just cause right exactly yeah just got a few more questions for you from architecture to literature to art maleness is coded into the urban fabric it's built for the height of men not women and women aren't allowed to make eye contact don't talk back it's not safe that's sort of covers what we were talking about but it's it's still not you're saying that women now sort of taken back the streets based it's still not safe no no that's true we can take back the streets like for a night and then the next day it goes back to being as it was mmhmm yeah a lot of people have asked me since the book came out like well what can what can we do like how can we make the city our own how can we make the streets our own I really don't know what to tell them all I can say is I think it's awful that like women have to bear the responsibility for for making sure they stay safe that we have to like install apps on our phone to learn friends no we've gotten home or carry around mace or or you know clenched our keys in our hand I think that's ridiculous but you know I'm not sure there's anything we can do other than take these measures to protect ourselves I think we all we can do is talk about it and like raise awareness about it in the city so you talk about women being emotionally bound up in everything what do you mean where do I say for fro for women perhaps walking in the city is being emotionally bound up in everything a place to prove independence I'm not sure where that comes from yeah that's you did say that yeah I think probably what I meant is that there's we have something at stake walking in the city and maybe sometimes we take it for granted and you know very quickly if you're just sort of going about your business someone will enter intervene in your in your bubble and make you aware of the fact that the city is not for you the street is not for you that it's for them or for their show of power and yeah I think that it's it's very difficult not to be on some low-level bound up emotionally with the environment when you feel that there are people who want to sort of take your I don't know burst your bubble or threaten your safety or remind you of where you are on the on the in the hierarchy of Street I know we've talked a lot about being a Flener but but how do you flan a city hmm like how would you go about do you know if someone's listening to you excited about the concept so how do you go about doing that well I think there are probably two main schools of thought one would be the kind of wandering at random um school of thought the other would be this kind of situationist style de vivre where you or drift where you you could sort of drift aimlessly or you could set yourself a course where you say I'm going to turn right every every third right and then every second left and go on every shock that has an X in the in the title or something like that you could make it really planned or like Ian Sinclair did this sort of in London orbital he walks around the ring road I can't was at the m25 there's a big ring road around London and he walks it will self sort of directed walk from Heathrow to jail his walk from London to New York City where he walks to Heathrow and then he walks from JFK to Manhattan so I think that that those are more structured experiences of planning in the city but I think they're still like even if you put a shape around it you're still opening yourself up to everything that could happen you know all the things the ways that you could we know what that environment yeah you can structure it to some extent but yeah and then you're leaving the rest up to chance but then then you're filling in that blank with like whatever whatever there is to see or to look at or to notice and I think both Ian Sinclair and will sell for thinking about thisis these these kinds of structured walks as that's like a form of social critique or you know capitalist pratik mm-hmm so what about taking photographs of stuff you see is that part of it yeah I do that um I'm I'm a big fan of photographing the city I have an instrument Instagram account and I think that having Instagram actually and this little camera on my phone has has made me a better Flynn is like it's it's made me that much more attuned to the environment and to interesting like places and people and I don't know just like corners or buildings that have something written on them it's this sense of like that would make an interesting photograph or you know that would be interesting to show people well that's the thing about Instagram it is showing other people isn't it you're not just taking these photographs for yourself yeah you're sharing the other yeah exactly yeah it's just another form I think of being an artist photo or an artist that is what about other contemporary writers you mentioned will sell in Sinclair anyone else that's sort of in the field I'm trying to think there's there's a lot but I'm sort of blanking on them have a good footnote refer to my footnote this is actually meant to be in the introduction and then it was just a list of names and some I adore maybe cut it I said okay but I'm keeping it as a footnote so I'll read it if I counter Giza bow with his ex-wife Michelle Bernstein I counterion Sinclaire with Rachel Lichtenstein she's great will self with Laura Oldfield Ford Nick papadimitriou with Rebecca Solnit taeju Cole with Joanna qivana qivana sorry but Patti Smith Adrian Piper lisa robertson phase again janet cardiff yoko ono laurie anderson vivian Gornick living near Greenlaw Amina cane gloria Regis at EF Phi Z Heather Hartley Wendy MacNaughton Daniel Dutton Jermaine Cruz she's no longer with us but the rest of these people are contemporary Valerio Louie Sully Alexander Horowitz Jessie Fawcett doctor needed Ponce Kate Sam Breen Oh Joanna Walsh Eliza Gregory and young no Sandra Cisneros and you eight goes on to this Rachel Whiteread she's also really wonderful um I think that's it for the living people do and these are mostly writers and artists just finally you are going to Liverpool um I moved part time to Liverpool last year because I took up a post at the University and hated it so I quit no I didn't it's lovely you Liverpool is lovely and the university is is fine but I didn't like having a full-time teaching jug so it left me no time to write but my partner still teaches at Liverpool so we will be back up in the north of England in like late January of next year and what was it like to be a planners in Liverpool what what did you come across um I came across a lot of drunken men at all times of day a lot of really angry people but also I think Liverpool is a city that more because it's smaller and because there's such a striking amount of Georgian architecture it really makes you wonder like what are these buildings how did they get there like who paid for them and Liverpool has kind of a redoubtable history as being one of the major slave trading ports and there's a wonderful slavery Museum in Liverpool that sort of details this history and it's it's one of the like places that children in Liverpool get taken on field trips so that it sensitizes them to their environment that said you know my where I was teaching at the University of Liverpool was in one of these Georgian mansions that was built by someone who got rich off the slave trade and I said to my students one day like for example we're sitting in the mansion of a major slave trader and they're like well like no really and they're sort of looking around going like Oh suddenly all this like lovely Georgian ornamentation starts to feel like a suspect so I think because it's smaller and because it's more unified in its architecture and its history more so than Paris I think Liverpool sort of makes you go like there's like one particular way of enslaving people and and oppressing them that resulted in the city looking the way it does so yeah it's really it's really instructive I mean obviously you can go to Paris and go to London and think about the ways in which these are beautiful cities that were built on the backs of you know the poor and the enslaved but Liverpool is a city that like really makes you think about that and now Liverpool won do you know that Liverpool won its like massive mall in the centre of the city it just yeah it takes this conversation about who's getting rich off the backs of whom in in a totally different direction it's like also troubling thanks very much for taking the time to talk today oh sure thanks thanks for coming over to my house in Belleville I've been speaking with Lauren Elkin who is among other things the author all Flynn is women walk the city in Paris New York Tokyo Venice and London published by Farrar Straus and Giroux in the United States in the UK and what about Canada yeah there wasn't a specific Canadian deal so I think it's just I'm not sure if it's the UK publisher who distributed it there or the American one but yeah okay I don't know why they didn't make a specific deal with Canada this is the story of our our life really anyway thanks again yeah sure okay
Up Next

Walking in the City: Urban Rituals and the Flâneur in Contemporary India
@PSBTIndia
1.9K views•2016-08-02

Build Farcaster Composer Actions: A Technical Code Walkthrough
@dtech_vision
1.3K views•2024-09-04

FastAPI vs Flask vs Django: Choosing the Right Python Web Framework
@TechWithTim
302.5K views•2024-05-26

Game of Thrones Opening Credits: A Cinematic Analysis
@gameofthrones
46.3M views•2011-04-18
Related Study Plans & Knowledge Roadmaps
Structured learning paths in General & Interdisciplinary Studies




