In criminal law, justification (such as self-defense) is a defense that negates the crime itself and is typically pled at trial, whereas immunity is a separate legal doctrine that allows someone to avoid trial entirely; these are fundamentally different concepts, and a valid justification does not automatically grant immunity from prosecution.
Fulton County DA Challenges Trump Co-Defendant's Immunity Claim
Added:hey everyone Harry here to talk about Bonnie Willis's response to Ken chesbro's motion for immunity in the case based on a really weird theory that essentially uh doesn't get to first base and funny Willis makes clear why not so chesbro has filed a motion saying I have immunity because my actions were Justified under the law so what he's trying to harness is a Doctrine in criminal law that there's an important distinction between an excuse and a justification and an excuse is something where you're guilty but you've got a an excuse for be for criminal liability for example um Insanity certain defenses a justification actually negates the crime an example is self-defense uh in brief you did it for a higher Social reason uh you you know you did the crime so it really actually negates it now um it was a totally cockeyed uh motion of Chess Bros however first because there's you know there's justification as I mentioned for self-defense but there has to be the higher Social good in theory there you know it's pretty well uh defined the three or four situations where you can argue justification and obviously his wasn't one of them what he was saying is I'm a lawyer and I was giving advice and that makes it all Justified that that was already a head scratcher because you know there's no case out there that says that's a justification the only case he even tried to uh proffer was one that says you can have justifications more than just the well-known laundry list but the thing about it is even if it's true that he was a lawyer trying to advise his uh client and that's going to be uh uh pretty dubious I think when the facts come out that's not what's the higher Social good uh exactly as I said I think when we talked about it when he did the motion you know he's saying he had to uh kill the constitution in order to save it there is no sort of proffered higher good that he had to uh do and so uh Bonnie Willis has responded in in short order kind of giving uh telegraphing to the court there's really not much here and she makes the point that I made but an even stronger one as well justification is something you plead at trial you say I'm Justified and you have the perhaps the judge perhaps the jury find it it is not repeat not repeat n-o-t a basis for um immunity that is not even having to face trial at all uh which is what immunity about immunity is a special kind of Doctrine only you know been getting glances of this with Mark Meadows saying hey I'm a federal official and I'm immune from even having to stand in the dock and have the state try to uh discipline me for having done my federal job that's not what a justification is categorically even if uh chesbro had a valid justification which he doesn't but uh the the time to to plea justification is at trial and uh if you're if you win in the eyes of typically the court then then okay you're you're out but it's not a reason for so-called immunity or not going to trial in the first place which is what Chez bro has tried to use it for we've talked about this before but it's the least third time that chesbro a Harvard Law School grad not that that's you know means you have to be smart but also who was in the sort of circle of the anointed of Larry tribe research assistants he's now filed three really cockham Amy motions that make no sense at all and are are legally you know near uh risible so um uh you know just just like huh uh and if you just gotta wonder what you know what where even if he has a terrible lawyer what about Chess bro himself anyway we'll see if that pattern continues but uh I I very much expect that Bonnie Willis's point will carry the day namely this is not a justification and by the way justification is different from immunity there's actually even a law in Georgia that says makes it clear you don't get immunity unless the statute says clearly you do that is you don't have a right even with a valid justification to escape the the standing trial unless the Georgia legislature has expressly provided this is something that gives you immunity so this is going nowhere fast and as I say it's uh really kind of uh you know way out there and just not legally sophisticated in the least so we'll see now chess bro remember he um and Sydney power due to um have their jury selection begin in less you know in four weeks so this is really um you know hurtling toward uh trial for him which is one reason that he's you know throwing everything against the wall to to see you know make any um possible you know lucky um ruling from a judge or or try to preserve things for appeal and you know even if they're lousy maybe they look better in the light of day on the other side so that's one reason people do um not very strong emotions but chess Bros seem to be of a whole nother category of just crazy uh you know not not from the um you know normal know legal Planet almost um okay so um look for his immunity motion to be struck down quickly we'll see what else he has up his sleeve but pretty soon it's trial selection jury selection time for uh the first um you know to defendants of the 19 chess bro and Sydney Powell so stay tuned it's coming fast talk to you later thanks for tuning in if you enjoyed this video and other talking feds content please take a second to like And subscribe talk to you later
Up Next

Chud the Builder Shooting: Legal Analysis of Self-Defense
@RyanCMullally
2.5K views•2026-06-18

US Secondary Sanctions Impact on EU Businesses and Blocking Legislation
@Bureauvandijk
1.6K views•2019-03-20

Forensic Phonetics: Speaker Identification in Legal Cases
@nptel-nociitm9240
539 views•2025-03-19

Police Interrogation Tactics: False Confessions & Legal Reform
@LastWeekTonight
7M views•2022-04-18
Related Study Plans & Knowledge Roadmaps
Structured learning paths in Law
![[FULL ROSI] Vonis Polisi 'Taat' Sambo](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/_oEeyIMhcYE/maxresdefault.jpg)






































