Rethinking Maize Domestication: Assemblage Theory Applications

Added:

Empirical Evolutionary Ecology and Genetic Selection Models

While assemblage theory offers a post-humanist, relational framework that decentralizes human agency, mainstream archaeological and biological sciences favor empirical evolutionary ecology and genetic selection models. Critics of post-structuralist approaches like assemblage theory argue that they rely on abstract, non-falsifiable philosophical concepts that obscure concrete causal mechanisms. Instead, dominant models utilize frameworks such as Optimal Foraging Theory (OFT) and niche construction, paired with high-resolution archaeogenomics. These empirical approaches focus on quantifiable variables—such as human dietary choices driven by caloric efficiency, specific genetic selective sweeps (e.g., the mutation of the tb1 gene in teosinte), and localized environmental pressures. From this perspective, maize domestication is best explained through testable, directional evolutionary processes and selective pressures rather than open-ended, decentralized socio-material assemblages. This empirical lens ensures that hypotheses can be rigorously tested and validated against the physical archaeological and genetic record.

The biological and genetic history of maize domestication, specifically the transformation from the wild grass teosinte (Zea mays ssp. parviglumis) to modern maize.
Fundamental concepts of Assemblage Theory as formulated in social philosophy (e.g., Gilles Deleuze, Félix Guattari, and Manuel DeLanda), particularly the ideas of emergent properties and heterogeneous relations.
Traditional archaeological and anthropological models of agricultural origins, such as environmental determinism and human-agentic push models in Mesoamerica.
The basic principles of 'new materialism' and post-humanist archaeology, which critique human-centered histories and emphasize the agency of non-human entities.
Applying assemblage theory to analyze the domestication and spread of other key domesticates, such as wheat in the Fertile Crescent or rice in East Asia.
Advanced study of Manuel DeLanda's 'A New Philosophy of Society' to master concepts of territorialization, deterritorialization, and coding within material assemblages.
Methodological approaches in archaeology that align with relational theories, such as micro-botanical analysis (phytoliths and starch grains) and multi-species ethnography.
Synthesizing assemblage theory with Indigenous ontologies and Traditional Ecological Knowledge (TEK) to explore alternative narratives of human-plant reciprocity.
113 views1likes47:21@assemblagethinkingsymposiu6935Original Release: 2017-06-21

Maize domestication in Mexico represents a unique case where humans developed non-genetic relationships with plants, challenging traditional linear narratives of domestication that assume independent regional developments; instead, domestication emerges from complex, interconnected assemblages of human-plant-animal relationships spanning millions of years, driven by factors beyond mere food production including religious and spiritual significance, rather than simple demographic or ecological pressures.