Queering the Natural Family: LGBTQ+ Kinship in Italy

Added:

The Defense of the Constitutional 'Natural Family' and Traditional Kinship in Italy

An influential counter-perspective to the 'queering' of kinship in Italy is the defense of the 'natural family' (famiglia naturale), which remains deeply rooted in Italian jurisprudence, Catholic social teaching, and conservative political discourse. Proponents of this view, often referencing Article 29 of the Italian Constitution, argue that the family is a pre-political, natural society founded specifically on the complementary union of a biological man and woman. From this viewpoint, heteronormative, biological kinship is essential for optimal child socialization, psychological development, and demographic continuity. Critics of alternative kinship models contend that de-centering the traditional family structure threatens social stability and the legal protections historically afforded to the nuclear family. Furthermore, they argue that state welfare systems and societal cohesion in Italy are historically built upon the reciprocal obligations of the traditional biological family, making the institutionalization of non-normative kinship models socio-economically destabilizing.

The sociological concept of heteronormativity and how traditional nuclear family models are structurally prioritized in Western societies.
An introduction to Queer Theory, specifically the intellectual practice of 'queering' established social institutions and norms.
Anthropological definitions of kinship, distinguishing between consanguinity (biological ties), affinity (marriage), and social or chosen kinship.
The historical influence of the Roman Catholic Church and traditional gender roles on Italian social policy and family law.
Comparative analysis of LGBTQ+ legal recognition, civil unions, and adoption rights across Southern European nations.
The political and ethical debates surrounding Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) and gestational surrogacy within Italy's evolving legal framework.
The concept of 'chosen families' and its practical application in organizing care networks for aging LGBTQ+ populations.
The impact of intersectionality, examining how socio-economic class, migration status, and regional divides (North vs. South Italy) affect queer family-making.
110 views0likes1:02:57@uoftitalianOriginal Release: 2023-02-17

This lecture examines how the Italian concept of 'famiglia' (family) is being contested and redefined through various social practices, activism, and cultural representations. The speaker critiques the Italian constitutional definition of family as exclusively cis-heteronormative and explores alternative kinship networks called 'sfamiglia' that exist outside this framework. Through analysis of novels, memoirs, and ethnographic research, the lecture demonstrates how LGBTQ+ individuals and communities create supportive kinship networks of choice, challenging essentialist notions of family. The presentation addresses debates within the LGBTQ+ community about whether same-sex marriage represents assimilation or genuine progress, while highlighting how cultural texts can either reinforce harmful stereotypes or contribute to normalizing diverse family forms.