Solar Geoengineering as a Climate Solution | Gernot Wagner | TEDx Talk

Added:

The Moral Hazard and Governance Opposition to Solar Geoengineering

Critics of solar geoengineering, including proponents of the 'Solar Geoengineering Non-Use Agreement,' argue that treating it as a viable climate solution creates a dangerous 'moral hazard.' By offering a perceived quick fix, it threatens to distract from and delay the urgent, systemic decarbonization needed to address the root cause of climate change. Furthermore, opponents highlight profound governance and geopolitical risks: unilateral deployment by a single nation or wealthy actor could trigger international conflict, and the sudden cessation of solar radiation management could cause 'termination shock'—a rapid, catastrophic spike in global temperatures. Critics also argue that the technology is inherently undemocratic, as its deployment would globally alter weather patterns, potentially devastating agriculture in the Global South without consensus or recourse. Therefore, they advocate for an outright ban on the development and deployment of these technologies, championing immediate, equitable emission reductions instead.

The Greenhouse Effect and Global Warming: Understanding the basic mechanisms of how greenhouse gases trap heat and drive global climate change.
Climate Economics and Market Failures: Familiarity with how economists view climate change as a global negative externality and the challenges of pricing carbon.
Mitigation vs. Adaptation: Knowing the difference between reducing greenhouse gas emissions (mitigation) and adjusting to life in a changing climate (adaptation).
The Concept of Albedo: Understanding surface and atmospheric reflectivity, which is the physical principle that solar geoengineering seeks to manipulate.
Global Governance and International Law: Exploring how solar geoengineering could be regulated internationally, including the risk of unilateral deployment.
Specific Solar Radiation Management (SRM) Technologies: Researching the technical feasibility, costs, and localized impacts of methods like stratospheric aerosol injection and marine cloud brightening.
The 'Moral Hazard' in Climate Policy: Analyzing the socioeconomic theory that geoengineering development might reduce the political and public will to reduce carbon emissions.
Termination Shock: Studying the catastrophic climate risks and rapid warming that would occur if a deployed solar geoengineering system were suddenly halted.
4.7K views46likes18:00@TEDxOriginal Release: 2019-07-15

Climate economists analyze that while we know enough about climate change to act, the unknown uncertainties (known unknowns and unknown unknowns) create significant economic costs, making carbon pricing essential; however, given the persistent uncertainty and the free rider problem in global emissions, solar geoengineering may become an inevitable solution to manage climate risk.