Kinship as Social Practice in Contemporary Family-Making

Added:

Biogenetic Essentialism and the Primacy of Genetic Kinship

While contemporary sociology emphasizes kinship as a social practice, an opposing perspective—rooted in biogenetic essentialism, evolutionary psychology, and certain advocacy frameworks—argues that genetic connections remain foundational to human family-making. This viewpoint posits that biological relatedness is not merely a social construct but a biological reality that drives psychological bonding, evolutionary altruism, and identity formation. In the context of adoption, donor conception, and surrogacy, critics of purely social kinship point to the concept of 'genealogical bewilderment,' arguing that knowledge of and connection to one’s biological origins are vital for psychological well-being and a coherent sense of self. Furthermore, some critics argue that completely decoupling kinship from biology can commodify human reproduction and obscure the rights of children to know their genetic heritage. Thus, this perspective asserts that biology remains an irreplaceable anchor for defining family and identity.

Traditional sociological and anthropological definitions of kinship, particularly the concepts of consanguinity (blood ties) and affinity (marriage ties).
The concept of social constructionism, specifically how social institutions and roles are shaped by cultural norms rather than biological imperatives.
Basic tenets of queer theory and feminist theory, particularly the critique of heteronormativity and the nuclear family model.
A foundational understanding of how Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ART) and legal adoption function structurally in modern society.
Advanced anthropological theories of 'relatedness' (e.g., Janet Carsten's concepts) that explore how kinship is dynamically performed through daily practice and care.
The political economy and ethics of transnational surrogacy, examining how global stratification, wealth, and race influence the reproductive labor market.
Comparative family law, focusing on the legal struggles and evolving definitions of legal parenthood, custody, and citizenship for non-traditional families.
An intersectional critique of contemporary family-making, looking at how race, class, and geographic location restrict or facilitate access to alternative paths to parenthood.
35K views45likes10:11@anthrodorphinsOriginal Release: 2023-12-07

Kinship is fundamentally a social practice rather than merely a biological inheritance, as demonstrated by ethnographic research on LGBTQ families, surrogacy, and transracial adoption, which show that family bonds are formed through choice, commitment, and social recognition rather than solely through blood relations or reproduction.