How Maya Hieroglyphs Are Written: A Demonstration by Dr. Mark Van Stone

Added:

The Ideographic Theory of J. Eric S. Thompson

For much of the 20th century, the dominant paradigm in Maya studies—championed by prominent archaeologist J. Eric S. Thompson—rejected the idea that Maya hieroglyphs were phonetic. Thompson argued that the script was primarily ideographic and symbolic, representing cosmic concepts, mathematical ideas, and calendar calculations rather than the sounds of a spoken language. He fiercely dismissed the phonetic decipherment theories proposed by Yuri Knorozov, which form the foundation of modern epigraphy and Dr. Mark Van Stone's demonstrations. While the phonetic, logosyllabic nature of Maya writing is now universally accepted by scholars, Thompson's anti-phonetic stance remains the most significant historical counterpoint, illustrating how academic preconceptions once stalled the understanding of how the script was actually written.

Understanding the basic geography, timeline, and cultural significance of the ancient Maya civilization.
Familiarity with the distinction between logographic (representing words or ideas) and phonetic/syllabic (representing sounds) writing systems.
An introduction to the unique layout of Maya inscriptions, specifically the concept of glyph blocks and their double-column reading order.
Basic linguistic familiarity with consonant-vowel (CV) syllabic structures, which form the foundation of Maya phonetic writing.
The history of the decipherment of the Maya script, highlighting key historical breakthroughs by figures like Yuri Knorozov and Tatiana Proskouriakoff.
Practical epigraphy: Translating actual monumental inscriptions found on stelae, lintels, and pottery from Classic period sites like Palenque and Copan.
The material culture of Maya scribes, including the study of the remaining Maya codices, brush calligraphy techniques, and pigment creation.
The relationship between the written Classic Mayan language (Classic Ch'olti'an) and the modern Mayan languages spoken today.
Comparative epigraphy: Comparing the structural mechanics of Maya hieroglyphs with other ancient logo-syllabic writing systems, such as Egyptian hieroglyphs or Sumerian cuneiform.
251K views5Klikes6:42@markvanstone2012Original Release: 2010-09-06

Maya hieroglyphs are constructed using phonetic syllables where each glyph represents a consonant-vowel combination, often incorporating pictorial elements like centipede skeletons, fish fins, and upside-down faces; the writing process involves first drawing basic skeletal outlines and then adding finer internal details to complete the glyph.