Constitutional Interpretation Debate: Kenya's Top Legal Minds | UoN Law

Added:

The Radical Class Critique of Elite Constitutionalism

While the debate between Prof. Githu Muigai's conservative positivism and Dr. Willy Mutunga's progressive transformative constitutionalism represents the mainstream legal spectrum in Kenya, a major counterpoint comes from radical class-based and popular constitutionalist perspectives. Critics from this school argue that both approaches are fundamentally elite-driven and operate within a liberal-capitalist framework that fails to address the material inequalities of the Kenyan masses. This critique posits that the 2010 Constitution, despite its progressive Bill of Rights, merely re-engineered the post-colonial state to legitimize capitalist exploitation and preserve elite dominance. From this perspective, focusing heavily on judicial interpretation—whether conservative or transformative—distracts from the grassroots political struggles required for genuine socioeconomic redistribution and land reform. True constitutionalism, they argue, cannot be achieved solely through courtroom battles or elite academic discourse, but through active popular mobilization that challenges the underlying economic structures.

Basic theories of constitutional interpretation, such as originalism, strict constructionism, and the living constitution doctrine.
The historical context surrounding the drafting and adoption of the 2010 Constitution of Kenya, which sought to address governance challenges and historical injustices.
The concept of 'transformative constitutionalism' and how it differs from traditional legal positivism.
The institutional roles of key legal figures in Kenya, specifically the Attorney General (historically represented by Prof. Githu Muigai) and the Chief Justice (historically represented by Dr. Willy Mutunga).
Analysis of landmark judgments by the Supreme Court of Kenya (such as the 2013 and 2017 presidential election petitions) to observe these interpretive philosophies in action.
The legal arguments and rulings surrounding the 'Basic Structure Doctrine' in Kenya, particularly through the Building Bridges Initiative (BBI) case.
A comparative study of transformative constitutionalism in other Global South jurisdictions, such as South Africa and India.
Evaluation of how constitutional interpretation affects the implementation of devolution and the protection of socio-economic rights in Kenya.
532.4K views2.8Klikes1:57:31@vice-chancelloruniversityo3441Original Release: 2019-07-05

This debate presents two contrasting theories of constitutional interpretation in Kenya: Dr. Mutunga argues for a transformative, activist approach where judges should actively interpret the Constitution to promote its values, principles, and purposes, drawing from international law and interdisciplinary perspectives, while Professor Muigai advocates for a minimalist approach that confines judicial interpretation to the text and avoids judicial activism that could undermine democracy or create constitutional crises.