Understanding Intersectionality in Aging: 2021 GGS Conference

Added:

The Universalist Approach and Methodological Critique of Intersectionality

While intersectionality provides valuable insights into diverse lived experiences, critics argue that applying it to aging policy and health research can lead to 'particularism' and methodological paralysis. Opponents of an intersectional-first approach advocate for a Universalist framework, which focuses on the shared, fundamental challenges of aging—such as cognitive decline, physical frailty, and systemic ageism—that affect all older adults regardless of identity. From a policy perspective, critics suggest that fragmenting older populations into hyper-specific subgroups can dilute political power, complicate resource allocation, and create competitive advocacy rather than collective solidarity. Furthermore, quantitative researchers point out that intersectional frameworks are often methodologically difficult to operationalize in clinical trials and health studies, potentially delaying practical interventions. Instead, a materialist or universalist approach prioritizes broad structural reforms, such as universal healthcare and basic income, arguing these deliver more immediate, scalable benefits to all vulnerable older adults than highly targeted, identity-based programs.

The core concept of intersectionality, originally coined by Kimberlé Crenshaw, which explains how overlapping social identities (such as race, gender, class, and sexuality) relate to systems of oppression.
Fundamental concepts of gerontology and the sociology of aging, including ageism and the unique physiological and social challenges faced by older populations.
The definition of Social Determinants of Health (SDOH) and how non-medical factors influence health outcomes and life expectancy.
The distinction between health equality (providing the same resources to everyone) and health equity (distributing resources based on specific, diverse needs to achieve equal outcomes).
Intersectional policy analysis and advocacy strategies designed to reform social safety nets (like Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security) for marginalized older adult communities.
Advanced methodologies in qualitative and quantitative gerontological research that capture the complex, compounding effects of multiple demographic variables rather than treating older adults as a monolith.
The application of culturally competent care models in geriatric healthcare settings and assisted living facilities to better support LGBTQ+, BIPOC, and low-income seniors.
Critical Gerontology theories that examine how power dynamics, capitalism, and systemic inequalities shape the subjective experience of aging across different populations.
411 views5likes9:05@GaGerontologySocietyOriginal Release: 2020-10-12

Intersectionality is a framework that examines how multiple social identities (such as race, gender, age, sexuality, and ability) interrelate and compound to create unique experiences of privilege or oppression, which is essential for understanding and addressing health inequities in aging populations, as demonstrated by how older adults from marginalized groups face compounded discrimination that affects their health outcomes differently than their peers.