Large-Scale Structure Observables: Cosmic Shear & CMB Lensing Class 3

Added:

Baryonic Feedback and Intrinsic Alignment Systematics

While cosmic shear and CMB lensing are celebrated as premier tools for mapping dark matter, their cosmological interpretations face significant skepticism due to systematic uncertainties. A major counterpoint argues that non-gravitational 'baryonic feedback'—such as gas ejection from active galactic nuclei and supernovae—significantly alters matter distribution on small scales, muddying the clean gravitational signals expected from cold dark matter. Additionally, 'intrinsic alignments' (IA), where galaxies naturally align due to local tidal environments rather than gravitational lensing, act as a severe contaminant. Critics argue that the current 'S8 tension' (the discrepancy in matter clustering measurements between weak lensing and Planck CMB data) might be a symptom of our inability to model these astrophysical systematics accurately, rather than evidence of new physics. This highlights a fundamental limitation: without solving the highly complex baryonic and astrophysical modeling problems, cosmological parameters derived from weak lensing remain highly degenerate with systematic errors.

Fundamental concepts of General Relativity, specifically gravitational lensing and how mass deflections affect light propagation.
Basic observational cosmology, including the origin of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and the expansion history of the Universe.
Statistical methods in cosmology, particularly the concepts of two-point correlation functions, angular power spectra, and the matter power spectrum.
The distinction between strong gravitational lensing and weak gravitational lensing, including the definitions of shear and convergence.
Cosmological parameter estimation (such as constraining Omega_m and Sigma_8) and addressing the current S8 tension in modern cosmology.
Advanced systematic mitigation techniques, including modeling of baryonic feedback, photometric redshift errors, and complex intrinsic alignment (IA) self-calibration.
Joint-probe analysis, specifically '3x2pt' analyses that combine cosmic shear, galaxy clustering, and galaxy-galaxy lensing.
Data analysis frameworks for upcoming next-generation cosmological surveys, such as the Vera C. Rubin Observatory (LSST), the Euclid space mission, and CMB-S4.
157 views3likes1:43:51@SAIFRResearchOriginal Release: 2025-08-06

Cosmic shear is the measurement of weak gravitational lensing effects on galaxy shapes, where the observed ellipticity of galaxies equals their intrinsic shape plus the shear distortion caused by intervening large-scale structure. This technique allows astronomers to map the distribution of dark matter by averaging the weak distortions across millions of galaxies, as the lensing signal is typically much smaller than the intrinsic galaxy shapes. The analysis involves projecting the 3D matter distribution onto the sky using the Limber equation, which relates the angular power spectrum of the projected convergence field to the 3D matter power spectrum through an integral along the line of sight weighted by a radial kernel. Key challenges include distinguishing lensing signals from intrinsic galaxy alignments (tidal alignment effects), dealing with noise-dominated measurements requiring large galaxy samples, and accounting for baryonic acoustic oscillations and small-scale structure that affect the matter power spectrum at high wavenumbers.