Grief is an emotionally driven process of attention whose object is the relationship transformed by the death of another person in whom one has invested one's practical identity. Practical identity refers to the set of commitments, projects, and relationships that give a person reason to pursue what matters to them, often involving other people such as business partners, spouses, friends, or colleagues. When someone with whom we stand in such a relationship dies, grief results because we have invested our practical identities in them. This philosophical framework helps explain why we grieve some deaths but not others, and provides a basis for understanding the rationality of grief responses.
Understanding the Philosophy of Grief with Michael Cholbi
Added:welcome to ppls perspectives a podcast bringing students and academics together to explore the research carried out by the University of 's school of philosophy psychology and language sciences and the impact this work has on [Music] society hello all welcome to the pilot episode of the new but old ppls perspective podcast this is the first episode of the rebranded Forward Thinking podcast that hasn't been active for a couple of years now if any of you remember that but it's been a long time since so if like me your memory doesn't extend into the BC Years BC of course standing for before Co or if you're totally new to the podcast our aim here is to provide audiences with short informal explanations of the work of our faculty members why the work is important and the impact that it has my name is Ellie Palmer I am a PhD student here at the University of Edinburgh working on a project called being after death about the temporal implications of an extended spatial identity in Japanese philosophy but today's show isn't about me in fact we're here with one of my brilliant supervisors Michael chelby welcome Michael how are you doing today aside from the Glorious edenburgh weather I'm fine that's great to hear do you want to start by telling the listeners a little bit about yourself and your background uh well as my uh accent betokens I'm from the very far west of Scotland the United States in fact um but I uh studied in the United States uh received my PhD uh just before the turn of the century uh worked in the United States for for about 20 years at a couple of different academic institutions and I came here uh in 2020 uh just prior to that um uh pandemic you mentioned um but I'm an ethesis who works in quite a few different areas um but probably best known for work uh related to death dying immortality so the theme of today's podcast is to discuss Michael's excellent book which was released last year I believe it's called grief a philosophical guide we aim to keep the format of this podcast series consistent between episodes so being the pilot episode I'll give you a bit of a rundown of how it's going to look so I'll be asking Michael five standard questions with some discussion in between each and the first thing I'll be asking Michael is to provide what we call an elevator pitch so if you're unfamiliar with that term it's essentially a brief overview of your work and your arguments that should be concise yet detailed enough to pitch to someone within the amount of time that you would share an elevator with them so Michael your book begins by discussing sort of the who what when of grief establishing an account of who we grieve for and the the circumstances in which we grieve so if you could begin by giving us sort of an elevated pitch of your research and this scope of grief that underlies the rest of the book well I'm a philosophical ethesis I've written on quite a lot of different topics but over the past oh half decade or so it's been grief that's been the focus of my research um in large measure my interest in this is shaped by the fact that uh grief and bereavement have been uh studied very extensively by people in Psychology and Psychiatry uh it's the subject of you know an innumerable number of uh poems narratives whatever and so um my objective here has been to try to figure out what philosophers can particularly contribute to grieving um but uh I've been doing this work as I said for about half a decade culminating in this book um that was published about 18 months ago uh which I think has had some positive impact and and gotten people to think that there's a lot more interesting philosophically about grief than kind of it appears at first so just to follow up from that elevator pitch I'm going to pull a quick quote from the book which summarizes your own account of grief so you say grief is an emotionally driven process of attention whose object is the relationship transformed by the death of another in whom one has invested one's practical identity so for listeners who aren't really familiar with card's practical identity what is this and how does it relate to your account of grief because that's sort of one of the most if not the most fundamental point that you make in the book uh well thanks for that question I do think it's probably one of the central premises or pillars of uh my research in this area so I think one question we want to answer about grief is what kind of relationship do you need to have with someone else in order for you to grieve their deaths or in order for it to sort of make sense for you to grieve their deaths we don't grieve everyone's deaths so uh it seems like we need some sort of a relationship with that person in order for the death to uh elicit grief in us so what I say in the book book is that uh we grieve those in whom we've invested our practical identities and that's a notion as you say that's borrowed from um Christine corgard and the idea ofpractical identity is that it's a sort of set of commitments or set of projects uh that kind of give you reason to uh sort of get up in the morning and pursue the things that really matter to you um and a lot of the projects and commitments that we have that are parts of our identity involve other people so uh you might have a business partner or a marriage or a friend ship or colleagues that for you are um Central to your identity and so when people with whom you stand in that kind of relationship die um the result I say or I claim is is grief right so before I read your book I was thinking for myself what I think are the most philosophically interesting aspects of grief and the thing I kept coming back to is this notion that people Express they've in a sense lost part of themselves so I think it's really interesting that that's precisely what your what the basis of your own characterization of grief is sort of based upon um so leading to our second question what else inspired you to conduct this Research into grief were there any other theories apart from cour guards or perhaps your own personal experiences that led you to pursue this Niche area well um this is actually an ER of research that for me did not really emerge from previous research it actually emerged from teaching um so I had been uh teaching the philosophy of death and dying for about 10 or 12 years uh when I first started thinking about grief and in the philosophy of death and dying a lot of the traditional questions you could describe them as egocentric right we ask people things like uh would it or could it be bad for you to die or you know would uh suicide willing your own death be uh irrational or should you fear your own death but I started to notice that a lot of students U when they engage with this material were not engaging it with it in so uh egocentric a way they were talking about the deaths of other people uh those who mattered to them their reactions to those deaths and so they were really talking in a way about grief um and that presented an interesting pedagogical question for me I could try to steer the students back on that egocentric track or I could um try to leverage right this you know apparent interest they had in thinking about other people's deaths and uh I opted for the latter and when I began looking into what philosophers had said about grief I discovered two things one of them was that they hadn't said very much uh only a few major figures in philosophy have uh said much very extensive about grief and I also thought that what had been said was often well not very imp not very plausible in fact in some cases struck me as um dismissive and contemptuous of grief so uh much of my work has actually been motivated by a concern to I guess you could say sort of vindicate or validate grief um to dispel the perception that some philosophers have had that this is um kind of a shameful or unseemly part of of human Affairs so given that there is not a whole lot of philosophical material already on Grief before you started looking into it um how did you conduct your research and were there any challenges for the across along the way well one major challenge is that uh I moved myself and my family from uh Southern California to Scotland in the midst of a global pandemic so there was that one um but besides that small logistical Kink um I think one of the things that is challenging about this particular topic is because there hasn't been a lot of philosophical work on Grief uh on the one hand you have a lot of freedom that is to say I didn't uh face a lot of sort of existing theories or existing positions that you know I was compelled to react to um or critique um but on the other hand that also meant that there weren't a lot of kind of guard rails right you know to build the research around um I actually found that to be uh in many ways very liberating right a little bit of sort of philosophy in the wild right a philosophy where there wasn't um a huge literature to respond to that's that's one Challenge and I think another challenge is just carving out what it is that the philosopher can contribute right to um our study of grief uh you know as I said earlier this is a topic that is you know very extensively discussed in Psychology anthropology Etc and you know uh you know the poets would be out of business right without grief so lots of people have talked about grief uh you could even say that our our oldest text that we still have available to us are are texts about grief right the Epic of Gilgamesh is a kind of you know grief Journey or or Awakening to mortality so a lot of it I think also came down to figuring out how to um situate my work right in relationship to you know the very big bodies of knowledge about grief that were already out there so yeah obviously you think and very convincingly argue that grief is extremely philosophically interesting so why do you think it is that grief was an area that was previously so overlooked in philosophy um I guess I would say a couple of things one is that um grief is obviously a very emotional uh event a very emotional experience for people but it's difficult to fit grief into the usual way that philosophers have thought about emotions I think the way philosophers have tended to think about emotions in recent decades is that emotions are sort of like patterns of responses to very specific kind of stimuli so you know the sort of standard picture would be you know you smell smoke and you know this causes you to feel fear uh and that doesn't seem to be a very uh promising picture or promising framework for thinking about something that's emotionally as rich as grief can often be um the other thing I would say and this I suppose is to be a little bit more uh uh I don't know politically antagonistic or or to be a little bit more sociological about the discipline but I think for a long time philosophers have had um a hostility to uh human experiences that they associate with uh weakness or femininity or um with uh you know sort of overt displays of emotion um and I think for that reason um perhaps the study of grief was thought of as um well kind of beneath people I don't agree with that obviously but uh I think that's been a prominent uh theme right when philosophers have decided to weigh in on Grief so touching on that you're talking about the emotions connected with grief something else I'm really interested in is the debate around the rationality of grief so I think it's worth discussing a little bit about how correct me if I'm wrong but I think grief you say it's not much of an it's not so much of an emotion but it's like a process of emotions so I don't think that's a necessarily unusual position but from what I understand it's like an active process rather than a passive process um so how do we deal there's different variations in how we deal with the experience of loss and I think this side of the argument plays into the discussion about rationality so I know a brief example that you mention in your book is a parable where the master visits the DS philosopher zangu who is grieving the loss of his wife and finds him like banging on a drum and singing instead of crying and I know he he responds to that by saying that it's a really weird Behavior I think he calls it extreme So within this umbrella of grieving presumably there are actions that we may think of as more rational grief responses to death and others perhaps less so what are your thoughts well I think at the broadest level um I've come to the view that the simplest way to capture what grief is is to say that grief is a a very intensive form of attention right so going back to what we were saying earlier about practical identity and the ways in which we grieve those in whom we've invested our practical identities I think when we're grieving what we're in effect doing is paying attention right to a relationship that has been changed by the death of another person and that would seem to imply then that when we think about the rationality of grief what we should be thinking about is kind of the rationality of attention right what does it make sense for a person to pay attention to with uh with respect to a particular relationship or you know how long should they pay attention to it how long should this episode of attention last um and I think that what in effect uh people um should want uh uh grief to look like is they should want it to take into account um to the extent that that it can the specific uh significat right that the relationship of with that person had right so we want it to be the case that you know if for example um someone dies with whom your relationship was perhaps a little bit fraught there might have been tension there uh it should make sense that your grief would include perhaps some resentment or uh worry uh because of course I think grief is in a way an experience that tracks right or encompasses the relationship that um we're grieving for or we're grieving about so your response actually reminds me of stories that I've heard from others where for example they have a close family member that passes away and at the weake there are people who the person that passed maybe hardly know and at the weake they're like acting completely distraught to the point where close family members think it's like really weird and uncomfortable so Also regarding rationality going back to the who when where Etc of grief um I think you talk about this somewhat in chapter five but do you think that there are people for which relative to ourselves and our relationship to them it's irrational for us to grieve well I think irrationality can arise in a couple of different ways so one possibility here is that we're grieving when we don't have good reason to so I think sometimes we can believe that a relationship we have with someone else is more substantial more robust than in fact uh it turns out to be or in fact our grief suggests that it is um I think grief can surprise us in this way right it can be the case that we might anticipate that the death of a certain person will lead us to grieve and in fact it doesn't and I think that that says something about the relationship we have with them that perhaps we hadn't previously realized it's not as again a substantial or robust there's also the prospect on the other side right I think people can often be surprised uh that they grieve for the death of a certain person that perhaps antecedent to their death they wouldn't have expected to grieve right they didn't realize right how fundamental or essential uh this relationship was to their lives um so I think that grief can can sort of go Ary with respect to rationality uh in in a few different ways so I was I was wondering at first if it's maybe a similar case to people grieving celebrities or public figures that I suppose they don't really know but I don't think that's quite the same because I think someone can rationally invest their practical identity in a celebrity but grieving in an extreme way someone who you may be sat next to in high school for six weeks and then didn't think about again for 30 odd years until they'd passed away it's not i' so wouldn't say it's rational because it would be quite difficult to say that they had any place in your practical identity yeah I always want to you know interrogate any uh you know specific narrative that people offer where they end up saying well you know you should be grieving this death or you shouldn't be grieving this death I mean because you could imagine a version of the story you just told Ellie where you know yeah you sat next to that person for six weeks and uh you know um you thought that maybe you would have formed like a romantic relationship with them and you could imagine you know an alternative uh biography for yourself where you did and you know you had gotten married and you know etc etc and and so I think it's it's not incoherent or inconceivable right that someone uh you know who who where the relationship has has I suppose foundered or kind you know um fell into disuse or something like that could nevertheless be a source of grief if again uh someone's identity is invested in that person in the right sort of way so I think our final question today before we wrap up is what is the impact of this Research into grief and how will this work ultimately benefit Society well I think one of the things my work has I hope to say is already done is I think a lot of the positive impact is know sort of one-on-one right in the sense that you know many of people who've read my work uh you know say that it's um helped them understand their own grief or understand grief in a richer way so I think there's a way in which uh in doing this work I'm I'm doing something that is for some people therapeutic though not exactly therapeutic in a kind of medical or clinical way um and when I teach this material I think students um do sense right that they're learning about something that uh is likely uh you know be something they'll need to confront in their lives so it's helpful to you know have thought about it in some way um I think in terms of other impacts you know I've had the opportunity to interact with um you know a number of different professional groups uh Physicians psychiatrists mental health professionals um and I'm hoping that you know some of my signature ideas about grief we've talked about practical identity uh uh the notion that grieving might be a particularly viable way to come to know oneself more richly um that we might see those ideas start to seep into you know professional practice or guidelines and then I think a third area that's still very much on the horizon is that I'm attempting now to think through some of the uh political implications of my own research and I've been seeking funding actually to support a project on um grief and mourning as human rights uh so the thought that would be that uh if we could establish that grief and mourning are human rights and what kind of Rights uh they are this might have uh implications for uh for example medical practice what it is that you know clinicians owe to breathed families um on social welfare policy for so for example um you know what should we think about uh the importance of societies providing you know funeral insurance for people um or even you know on like planning policy right so you know um in many parts of the world particularly Urban parts of the world you know we're running out of places to to bury people right and that may raise the interesting question of you know what sort of uh importance right should we attach to grief and morning if people have a right to grief and morning they have a right to you know bury their dead in a certain part of the of of a of an environment so I think it's already had some some uh positive impact and I'm anticipating that could have other kinds of positive impact in the coming years brilliant so I just want to finish by giving you the the opportunity to perhaps plug any upcoming work or events that any listeners who enjoyed this discussion might benefit to know about uh well further worker events so uh actually this very coming week we're going to be doing an online uh Workshop uh organized through the university here uh on philosopy of love and loss I'll actually be presenting a paper on uh the duty to grieve another scholar from the University of Leeds Luke brunning will be talking about grief in the context of um romantic relationships and romantic breakups um but in terms of other future um um contributions that I'm trying to make I'll be speaking uh at a conference in uh I believe it's going to be April of next year in Lincoln here in the UK talking about uh grief and loneliness and the ways in which grief can perhaps be a lonely experience but that might also be very important to the ways in which it's a valuable experience um but I always relish the chance to you know uh engage with people around these topics because you know I think it's it's a topic where since everybody or virtually everyone has some experience with it you know I hope that people can learn from from me but of course I also hope to be able to learn from them well that was a fantastic talk and I hope that this will get more people thinking about grief from a philosophical perspective as it does prove to have so many relevant links to other areas such as personal identity and rationality and so on and so it certainly warrants further expl exploration so I've been Ellie Palmer this has been the first episode of the ppls perspective podcast featuring Michael Shelby thank you for listening and make sure you go pick up a copy of grief a philosophical guide [Music]
Up Next

Princeton IV 2024 Finals | Debate on Duties to the Dead
@PrincetonDebatePanel
4.4K views•2024-09-29

The Arcades of Paris: Walter Benjamin on Urban Politics & Philosophy
@internationalcentreforcont7204
2.3K views•2013-06-19

Epistemology of Testimony Explained | Stephen Wright | Oxford Philosophy
@edinburghphilosophy
4.5K views•2015-06-29

The Myth of Sisyphus: A Greek Legend of Eternal Punishment
@TEDEd
8.6M views•2018-11-13
Related Study Plans & Knowledge Roadmaps
Structured learning paths in Philosophy

![Education - Blossoming a Child [Full DVD]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi_webp/JEKiaaLQU4M/maxresdefault.webp)




































