This debate explores whether humans have a strong moral duty to the dead, examining arguments about agency, legacy, and social consequences. The Government argues that duty to the dead stems from agency (people have plans for after death), obligations from before birth, death as necessity for life, and existential reasons, while the Opposition counters that obligations should prioritize the living, as dead people cannot be affected by our actions and cultural forces often weaponize this duty for harmful purposes. The debate highlights how obligations to the dead can conflict with obligations to the living, affecting areas like inheritance, cultural practices, and political movements.
Princeton IV 2024 Finals | Debate on Duties to the Dead
Added:without further Ado I'd like to call upon the prime minister to open the debate you're here hello everyone um before I start I'm just going to do some very quick pleasantries um first off I want to give a massive thank you to my main man Jason [ __ ] love you bro uh love having you as my partner it's been great it's been fantastic second massive thanks to everyone at the pen debate Society um you guys have been truly a second family to me all the way across the world and again thank you to everyone in this debate i' I've met all of you I've said pleasantries to you in previous rounds love all you guys um the last thing I would want to do is I want to give um a quick because debate is on the dead and also because I'm very grateful to be here in this final I do want to give some quick sort of like pleasantries and shoutouts to people who I'm debating for and who I you know who who have held me strong during times that I've been like quitting debating almost the first is obviously my parents uh um but also um to a few very special people have lost over the past year um firstly my maternal grandfather who I lost in October of last year um and who whenever have a debate about death I think about and lastly um my friend Alia who unfortunately um passed away um in Gaza while working for the red Cresent um towards the end of last year um your memories are with me and I debate for you guys p a life is [ __ ] beautiful it is insane that we get to live it is insane that we get to experience all the wonders of the world that we get to taste good food that we get to have experiences at all and don't just live in existential nothingness but that has to come to an end and the problem with the human spirit is that the human Spirit was not designed to face that end this is why every society on Earth has some sort of funeral ritual this is why every society on Earth tells people to take care of their parents this is why every single Society on Earth cares about those who have come before them there's a reason why this motion is a fundamental part of the human psyche it is a reason why we continue to care about those who have come before us to have immense gratitude for the universe that is often times unshaking in the face of great evil what does this look like in terms of this strong Duty we think it can mean many things but we think that fundamentally it constitutes three broad factors one as a living person when we think about a dead person we appreciate their life works and we carry out their legacy as they wanted it to be second we think of those when we are when we are fighting for a cause we think of those who came before us and died for that cause when we fight for it and three specifically when it comes to the act of dead bodies we treat dead bodies with dignity the same way we would treat human beings with dignity one important parameter for this debate we don't have to support every single manifestation of this duty to the Deb this motion is not about supporting a narrative but rather simply about supporting this obligation so if people do bad things on the basis of this dead person wanted this bad thing that can still be a bad thing because the ACT itself is bad but opposition has a moral duty to prove is that doing that bad thing is bad because of the fact that you're doing it by obligation to another person before you okay two arguments firstly as to why this is a moral duty I want to note the basis of moral obligation cannot be Pleasure and Pain but fundamentally has to be agency this is for two metamor reasons the first is edge cases we can always think of edge cases where Pleasure and Pain are stacked up such that we no longer can support this instances of mass gang assault for example or even like the alalas like thought experiment where it's like there's a child being tortured to support everyone else living a fantastic life edge cases prove that Pleasure and Pain cannot be our only calculus the second is that agency is a fundamental prerequisite for Pleasure and Pain even if you consider Pleasure and Pain in order to be able to have pleasurable or painful experiences you need to be an agent who has the ability to make decisions it doesn't necessarily matter whether Free Will exist what matters is that you feel that you are able to make those choices and thus feel that you're able to be a full person this argument will then prove that death does not end your agency and therefore we have an obligation to these people four reasons the first is that people have plans for after they die that we fulfill because they enact those plans while they are alive the intuition pump here comes from when we think about people who go into Comas when someone goes into a coma we don't necessarily know whether they're going to come back to life or not but we think you have an obligation to carry out what that person wanted because they wanted to do those things while they were still alive this then means that obligation doesn't come from the state of the the current state of the person who had asked for that obligation but rather the state of that person when they asked for the obligation which is why this is important the second reason is that obligations to people come from before your birth and therefore must extend after your death the fact of the matter is there are hundreds if not thousands of people whose actions affect you in a positive way and not just affect your life but your own legacy even if they lived before you my grandfather impacted My Life by setting my family up for Success even though I never got to meet him because like my paternal grandfather pastor and my father was 18 this then means that because they gave you an obligation you then give other people obligations this is therefore a necessarily continuous process where you have a moral obligation to those who have died third death is a fundamental necessity for life to exist and therefore you have an obligation to the people who have died before you death is necessary for life to exist one because Earth has lied resources and therefore deaths of people prevent overpopulation second the fact that in order for you to live any sort of life you need some sort of inheritance whether that's like a meager inheritance or just being given a house to live in that comes from people who have died before you and therefore you do have an obligation to them but also just the fact that like there's an evolutionary end of use to The Human Condition that comes when you die which is the reason for why human beings keep procreating which is why dying is a fundamental prerequisite to your very existence and therefore is something that you have an obligation to you would't exist without the dead fourthly this is a fundamentally existential argument the human psyche is not built to tolerate that every single moment even those people who say that they are comfortable with death are simply distracting themselves with other philosophies that make them feel like they are comfortable with death even the strongest aesthetic who believes that he is going to be reborn is afraid of that Split Second after he dies when everything goes to nothing El this is absolute existential trauma that is the worst form of harm you can imagine for this reason it is something you should care about this argument then proves a very strong moral duty I know we don't care about moral arguments much and BP but this is spefic specifically why you should care about this is about every single human being who experiences this it's about the essence of existence and it's about how the fact that the dead we treat the dead is an indication for how we treat people generally which is why we think it's an intent issue and something we should care about yeah Robbie go ahead agency is a bad metric because humans are terrible epistemic agents if your anorexic friend wanted to use your agency to starve herself it is your duty to be a paternalist and say no you are stupid don't starve yourself okay but the problem is that's not a reason for as to why human be like agency doesn't matter it's a reason for as to why you shouldn't particular people shouldn't be making decisions so maybe people who make bad decisions shouldn't have that have have that be respected but the fact of the matter is generally we consider human beings to be rational agents and therefore generally we should have an obligation to them the second argument is why we have better World outcomes we think that just respect for cultures we are their dead means that you're less likely to do things like desecrate native burial grounds desecrate the grounds of people who have come before you this is important because people believe it is important this is a form of cultural harm you enact on people if you don't believe it's important and therefore it is something that we should support the second is just that it makes people better off while they're alive if you know that people will have an obligation to you we think even the worst of people want to do some sort of good and therefore likely to live well and want people want to be remembered well or even do things if they like set up trust but the last thing is it creates a grounding for things like political reparations which is that it is often a very weak argument to say say we should just help people because they're suffering right now if you believe there's an obligation to the past that is a very strong argument to help the people who are suffering because of historical Injustice it is for all of these reasons that you will vote for OG great I thank the speaker for those veryify remarks and to start the case in the opposition side of the house I'd like to call upon the leader of opposition you're here hello can everyone here and see me if I speak like this yes fantastic throughout history mankind has continued to progress in spite of an Insidious Force the mummified hand of our ancestors repossessed by society's powerful a screaming Poltergeist repeating again and again to steal the life that we think is Ed to the living we think it is time to exercise this Spectre three points of framing first this debate is about whether or not we have a strong duty to the dead if we think that this particular Duty does not conflict with the living we think it is perfectly Justified for people who feel like they would want to respect the de to do so secondarily if it conflicts with an extremely frivolous will of the living we think that that too is reasonable it is government's burden in this debate to prove that they want a strong Duty that in likely in many cases given the framing that the OG themselves said is one that often supersedes the utilitarian pleasures and pains of those who are currently in existence second our primary contribution then is going to explain why the principle in this debate is going to be one that says they should always more often than not default to the living any argument that coo runs or any argument in this debate that benefits from this then is stem from its logical corollary that we are going to be the first ones to prove the last thing I want to point out is that appreciating those that came before you is in fact not mutually exclusive with believing that you owe a duty to them and I'm going explain that to you in our speech first thing I want to explain we owe no moral obligations to the dead here I want to cover the basis and explain why there are two frames in which neither case is true that we owe strong moral obligations to the Dead first on the utilitarian frame judge if you believe that pain and pleasure is the fundamental priority in which we ought to dictate moral obligations and the reason for this is that because it is arbitrary that human beings are born with some sets of Duties over others because these are the circumstances that are set by life we think we owe no moral obligations to those who are born you know those who don't experience pleasure or pain but I want to also and this is the second broader on deontological frame engaged with what we heard from the government bench as well the primary thing that we get here is this idea that we respect the human will now the end point of this argument is probably a cgu guardian claim right which is that the core of human existence is the human will because it's the ultimate value Choice the problem with this however is that Ashen does not give any way that this principle can be limited think about it the principle of the day extends infinum on their side of the house this is not how we appreciate even Wills that exist in the status quo if bar gives me a particular preference that preference is not respected infinitum or even in cases where it is something that we many in many cases seem unreasonable Wills have to be balanced on one side or the other the second claim that we get here is that you have duties to those who came after you um like I guess so but the primary difference between those who come after you and those who come before you is those who came after you had a choice in creating you you did not have a choice in those who are creating or who created you in the first place if they believe on opening government that the free human will is the primary construct in which we ought to dictate morality then what it arguably means in this debate therefore is that you ought to respect the category of those who who come after you but not those who come before you the final claim then is this idea that death is necessary for life to happen sure however no one choose to die it is silly we think to give special moral obligations to individuals for a process that they don't necessarily choose to carry out anyway what is the upshot then of all of this and to be clear this isn't just destructive it is constructive as well because the real people who are currently experiencing the human will are those who we know for a fact to be alive it is the people who currently exist who have active Wills that are able to change given present circumstances and these are the individuals therefore whose Wills we are best able able to fulfill but also the ones what we are most able to carry out if you believe for example that relationships form based on things like Reliance in the same way that a parent or child comes up dead people do not rely in many ways of our promises or our obligations because they can't necessarily react or change their position given what we have obliged them to do it is only those therefore that are living that are able to do this what then is the upshot of this argument the largest moral obligation we owe therefore are to those who are currently alive it is because of that therefore if opening opposition can prove to you that there are key tradeoffs that harm people who are currently alive at the expense of this moral obligation to the Deb we clearly take this debate this is the most substantive contribution that opening opposition can make in this debate it is the framework by which the rest of the debate will take place second claim then the shekele society and here I want to give a few key examples in which people are often Shackled by the will of the debt and impact them the first is things like probate Wills this means for example we often give and dictate people to for example give our assets to our children the problem with this is that most individuals are likely to carry out their future Wills in a selfish manner given the analysis that we heard from the opening government but here is the problem then it means in many cases it prevents the primary redistributive mechanism by which many individuals who La that agency can do because in the absence of things like Wills or inheritances often states which have a strong incentive to distribute for example example to gain things like votes or to support the social contract are the ones that are able to carry out before I carry on any further I'll take a POI from the closing team what is the trade-off to going to my de grandparents grave and putting flowers on it as a way of honoring them absolutely nothing if it makes you happy go do it the comparative however is if going to your great-grandfather's grave might harm people who are currently alive we object to that given the moral framework moving rapidly onward and and this is in set up as well right okay so this often means therefore that it is the people who are currently alive who face great harm that we don't like second often we feel that we need to hold ourselves to promises it's not just about our dead grandparents although that is terrible but also things like promising your romantic partner that you will not date anyone after their death these are things that often shackle people to people who won't even know the consequences of whether or not you're going to do a or be it looks like for example refusing to chase your dreams because your parents made you promise on their death bits that you ought not to do this but the second claim then I want to make here and I want to further this is that these obligations to the debt are often Amplified by cultural forces that are often dictated by the most powerful and therefore in many cases they are illegitimate what does this look like this looks like things like religion and clearly this is not symmetric because the belief that you owe a moral duty to your ancestors is therefore weaponized for example the Catholic Church believed that you ought to give indulgences and enrich themselves at your expense because you owe a duty to relatives who you did not necessarily know you exist in the worst cases this looks like the infringed cases Hindu practice of bride burning Sati because of the fact that many people believe that you owe a moral obligation to those who have passed on before you panel at the core of this argument it is the living not the Dead who ought to dictate our whims and fancies we're very proud to stand on opening opposition great thank you very much speaker for those very kind remarks and to continue and conclude OG's case call upon the Deputy Prime Minister you're here can when hear yes all right again some pleasantries thank you for Ashman for um being a great debate partner and teaching me how to do parley um thanks to P Society for being awesome thanks to the deter thanks to our opponents um super excited for this round cool for person on hospital bed knowing that their last moments are near being certain that their last legacies and their wishes will be re respected that their legacy will extend half their last breath a source of Solace and indeed to every single other person a reason to live a better life opening opposition is probably right that this debate is about the principle but I think the principal here is we all to respect people in their most vulnerable moments and indeed after those moments have passed one key point of framing note that just because a moral Duty exists does not mean that it is the only moral duty that is to say in status quo you might have a moral duty to your family might have a moral duty to society you might have a moral duty to your parents but all of these things can still exist simultaneously right it is unfear as to me as to why having one moral duty means that you cannot have any other moral duties so their entire case which is about weighing these things can still exist on our side of the house if both types of obligations exist the difference here is that in order for all of our case to be considered in first place we have to view the dead as fundamentally people who have rights to begin with that was our entire case I want to First deal with the principle we got from oo the first CL they say is that Pleasure and Pain are incredibly important important because everything else and all other moral Duties are arbitrary but look arbitrariness is just not a reason as to why things are not morally significant for example children often still have obligations to their parents because their parents were able to provide massive amounts of things for them even if they never consented to being born in the first place probably the parents have't obligation to the specific child that they that they have even if the specific child that was born and their wishes and their interest and their personality were not the ones that they chose consciously which means that arbitrariness is just not a distinction not a distinction in fact I would say that pain and pleasure are also incredibly arbitrary what does it say that like some forms of pain are more important than other forms of pain we think that in order for you to determine what these things are agency is a pre-requisite and that was the analysis that they never responded to the second thing they say is that it's going to extend ad and item right first note that we're able to weigh these obligations against other obligations right but secondly note that this just this probably isn't the case most dead people do not have wishes that extend like far every single time into the future like you ought to do this thing just add in an item right most people's Wills probably extend to their immediate family maybe their grandchildren at fast which means I think the scope of this argument is just relatively small but thirdly we would say that all of their analysis and all their logic probably allows for horrible things like the de creation of barrel Sid for individuals and note that this is something that is incredibly bad not like even animals even dogs when their relatives die still respect the areas in which they died so having memory of these things which means that we think this is something fundamentally intrinsic to being alive in the first place the a response is that this is arbitrary and it's just like social disgust it's not actually bad but obviously every single human value arises from the fact that there's social disgust from incredibly bad things that we deem are bad in the first place which means that you can which means that all of A's mechanisms just still flow at the end of the day the responses are not sufficient why does this prove the principle because not that the burden we have to prove is not the fact that we ought to respect the de and all be all like you don't have any other obligations we need to just Pro that these are a significant portion of people's moral decision calculus which the three me four mechanisms that we brought up certainly do before I go or actually yeah the second point we get from opening opposition is this argument that it's just pragmatically bad and that it's bad for people who are currently living the first thing I want to note is again Duties are able to compete which means that you're still able to weigh them but secondly they talk things like social like cultural forces ensuring that this narrative is doing a bad thing the first thing to note here is that like read the motion the motion does not say this house supports the narrative that people should have an obligation to the de it says that this house supports this right that's incredibly important because it's not a question of how the narrative is actually spread across Society it's specifically about whether this obligation exist in the first place which means that all we have to prove is this obligation is good not necessarily the application of the obligation is incredibly important but secondly note the absent this obligation even if it is about narratives but is you're likely to defend on their side of a house then it's just some things that are far worse into far as interest of power still have an incentive to maintain the status quo that's incredibly important because that is the point in which you think do things like spread obligations for example to your country for example or your race or the other like bar other things that are a lot worse the reason why they're worse is they're a way more arbitrary which means that based on the metric of O they probably lose but secondly they're just far less clear what does it mean to have an obligation to your country what is it obligation to your country that's far less clear than literally respecting the written word of your dead grandfather's will I think all of this is incredibly important because it means that the impact on people living is probably very marginally very marginal at best and even if it wasn't we proven that the dead matter too and that only happens on our side of the house before I go on I'll take closing the thing is you don't just have to defend one obligation you have to defend a strong obligation so what it's unclear on top half is what's the tradeoff here in which situation does a strong obligation override other obligation because your case seems compatible with other obligations as it is so far right so just something is compatible does not mean it is strong I have a strong obligation to my parents just like I have a strong obligation to maybe like my future children right that doesn't mean that this obligation is not strong in the first place I the mechanisms that we provide do prove it I you ought not to like desperate funeral grounds and burial grounds like you ought to respect like the bones like return like dead remnants of people to the groups that originally owned them in the first place I do think that there're just is a tension here right so all this proves that they were just massively winning the principle why win the pragmatics if like closing tries to go for something here okay go for something here because all the material that we got just got no engagement from o the fact that it leads to things like ethnic tensions because there are communities in the stats who that massively do believe that this is very important but secondly the fact that you're likely to get reparations that help improve the lives of existing minorities for example by ejecting their communities which large amounts of capital large amounts of respect things like that but third the argument that people just live better and more virtuous lives which means that if closing or o tries to argue that people with bad lives and have bad things then our narrative is key to check against it because it shows that you will will be remembered but what for what you did for what you did in the first place the scope of this is just massive right because it literally affects every single person and I would argue that every single person probably has some level of morality in their brains they probably believe that treating others poorly is incredibly bad they believe that they also do good things in life which is why on our side you actually kick those in and force those things to the mainstream in the front of their heads because those are the things that don't would be remembered before but lastly I think it is very bad to say that mental states are incredibly like determined morality right I.E death is probably a mental state it's just the point in which your neurons stop firing in your brain in your body collapses the reason why this is not true is because you would still allow the reason this is not don't grave like people's agency based on things like IQ you don't allow terminally ill people to make decisions which likely proves that people do have an obligation here even if they're dead in the first place we're winning on the principal and we're winning on the prag please vote OG great thank you very much DPM for those very fine remarks and to close the opening Health call upon here here hi can everyone hear me yes thank you it's now 7: a.m. in Singapore so Gare and I are somewhere between living and dead let's do this this motion is a terrible idea I think G solidifies the principle quite well so I'm going to start with the Practical I just want to First be clear on the comparative we agree with OG that people have duty to multiple things this motion is about when those duties conflict and whether you should have a strong duty to the dead for example it is a difference between spending a lot of money on a funeral or spending that money on food and clothes for your kids our comparative is in the absence of a stronger duty to the dead you prioritize your duty to the living all the time this is especially true with because the emotion says strong Duty so if it doesn't conflict with anything that is to say if you just have no duty to desecrate a burial ground then we think it's okay not to desecrate that burial ground that's not something we have to defend this is the difference between respecting the body of a fallen soldier and running back into combat to get that body or Soldier because it conflicts with other duties to yourself and to the living let's be clear we are not saying that G have to defend prioritizing the duty to the dead in every case but the delta in this debate is the cases in which they do the difference in this debate is where you prioritize a strong duty to the dead so we are we are perfectly okay to defend no obligation at all but I want to be clear this is the best case for them that's the comparative out of the way the difference in this debate is where people do prioritize their duty to the dead and we think they should not I first want to doal with the three harms that OG give us first on Des not desecrating cultural grounds I've already told you this is symmetric because it doesn't conflict with any other duty to the living even if you don't agree with that I think that there are also reasons on our side not to desecrate funeral grounds like for example people who are alive have strong attachments to that and we'll get very upset if you do this so we think that's an equally good reason to not do this on our side of the house that's not something we have to defend the nice thing they say is that people want to live a good life to leave a legacy the opposite is true if you are respected no matter what you have no incentive to be a good person when you don't automatically get respect because you're dead and actually have to do good things that is when youve incentive to be a good person finally reparations OG don't complete the argument and they never explain to you why reparations are more valuable than helping those in need if I had a finite amount of money I don't see why it is a bad thing to allocate it to the people who are alive most in need rather than the billionaire great-grandson of a slave they don't explain to you why reparations are more valuable than helping those in need withing obligations to the living are far better what does this mean on the Practical genuinely I don't think OG have much left compar this to Garrett's case which got shockingly little response he gave you a spectrum of impacts things like Wills hoarding patrilineal wealth to how we are able to get more cadaveric organ donation saving lives all the way across a spectrum do harmful religious practices like blood feuds and bride burning this was unique to this Duty yes we just to PRM closing right yes religion Etc might continue to be bad in other ways but there are practices that specifically require the duty to the dead to motivate them it is an incredibly unfortunate thing there some women in India believe that they are fulfilling their duty to their husband to be with them in the afterlife and believe religious leaders and jump into the fire and kill themselves this is incredibly punti on their side of the house the unique thing about the obligation to the dead is that it can't be confirmed which means that they get ventriloquized by those in power so even if it can be done perfectly on their side of the house the way in which it manifests in real life is incredibly bad what's the weighing the impact that this has on people is incredibly large and there are a couple reasons why it's magnified first because they are dead there is no way to discharge the duty in other way than what you perceive is that way second the fact that it interacts with other narratives and power structures like religion who are able to use this in bad ways means that this impact is going to be magnified compare this to the gov outcomes at best people feel soless for a couple of hours in the moments before they die compare that to the real impacts on people to for where where this Duty forces and coerces them to do really harmful things to their own lives people finally on like objects and things like that so people can hold sentimental value to objects but it will be a bad thing and it a bad thing to do to break them but it will be a worse thing to do to prioritize his attachment to the objects above all else so even on if they want to push us to desecrating funerals for some weird reason we the weighing of our outcomes are far higher that's done with the Practical let's move on to the principle Gareth explains to you that agency is less important than PL and and pleasure the only response we get is an intuition from copy pasted from another debate the difference in the kids case is that you chose to have kids and that is where your obligation comes from that is the same reason why you don't have an obligation to take care of all the kids in the world it is a primary moral principle that you ought not to be controlled by things you don't choose that's why racism is bad for example so we think the G analysis of why agency is more agency is less important still stands but I want to like really wipe the ground clear of OG so let's address the four reasons that they gave even if you even if you ignore the responses that Gare already gave first people in comas are considered alive after they die we think you don't have an obligation to respect their wishes second an obligation to people from before your birth does not mean you have an obligation to people when you die the reason people have an obligation to you you the reason you have an obligation to people after you is because your actions can affect them but your actions cannot affect dead people so you don't have this obligation third even if death is necessary for life this is no connection to obligation for example even if someone dying halfway around the world makes it necessary makes it for me to be left because of overpopulation I guess that does not mean I owe a specific obligation to all of these people fourth on the existential crisis OG say people don't want to die this makes it feel good but the desire for this is asymmetric a lot of the reason it feels good to have a wishes respected is because we grow up in a world where there is a duty to the dead we think that this changes in our world and this desire no longer exists so it was not that the fact that the dead had agency before that CG yeah if owing a duty to the date means you remember the date in in a good way because they did good things when they were alive why wouldn't this motivate you to do good things for the living to make sure you are remembered well after you dead we think that you should remembered for the good things you did not just because you are dead right the fact that you don't have a duty to remember them in a good life means that they actually have to do good things to be remembered also just like on waying I think that even if people are not remembered that well after they die this is a motivation to do good things while they're alive because other people would like them and they can actually get that benefit this is very symmetrical so we've taken out the four re they gave as why dead people at agency G explains to you that even if the closing half is a clash and which is more important either way it's a principal win for us if utilitarianism it's easy because dead people can't have utility if deontology it's also win for us because they lack Wills they don't rely on you they don't have special relations to anyone so there is no reason anyone ought to have a duty to them what is the impact of this this duty is morally incoherent and given that OG agrees that it often conflicts with other duties adhering to it makes people lead overall morally worse lives so on the principle I think it's a clear win for opening opposition either if you believe the agency is more important or if you believe that uh that um I believe the agency is less important or if you believe that dead people have no agency but even if you ignore all of that the horrible practical harms that can happen to people from small to big all of which are incredibly coercive and painful to people who are alive mean that o wins this debate all right thank you very much dep of opposition for those very fine remarks and that's the end of the opening he moving swiftly to the closing Health uh member of government to open here here I'll take my pii from o for engagement purposes in the chat at the fifth minute first a duty to repair injustices most people on the planet come from countries that were at some point in history War torn invaded and colonized following colonization and ression were hidden mechanisms of Oppression that have been entrenched within our systems Malaysia inherited A system that was racially divided by the British which produce a myriad of political problems in voter suppression corrupt strongman politicians which entrench power through legislations that are still in in place and oppress people right now post slavery black people in South apartheid and America were still subjected to terrible living conditions sanctioned by the state in overp policing redlining to prevent access to economic resources and discri mination which have led to the lost livelihoods until now this intensity is also a generational guilt white people feeling terrible that their societies were built on black and brown bodies this context is important because OG did not explain necessity and duty at best they argue some autonomy was sacrificed for present benefits this compounds its intensity therefore persuasiveness to society two ways that we extend the first it is the scale of their suffering which empowers this Duty because it was them sacrificing iing autonomy in all spaces to ensure you can exist is why you have rights the parents of first generation immigrants that cross deserts and gave up everything so that you had a chance to live therefore you owe this obligation in necessity second it is precisely because of the tragedy of death that creates empathetic responses from most situations where people would be apathetic it is when a human dies that cultural divides get bridged because we see a human soul that lived entire lives of suffering when we hear their stories told by those that came after them but also how their deaths were brutal and unjust this means it is not just a duty because of an asymmetry and creation of auton autonomy like OG says but a duty because your capacity to pass present policies come from the worst outcome of these people dying arguably you never had the political Capital to oppose police until those listed by BLM nationally created the emotional incentive for people to listen so it's not their past contributions it's their contributions right now even when they're dead why is this beating opening half primarily because o says that people Shackled by those who are dead is bad this material doesn't apply here because it justifies this obligation by highlighting present contributions rather than contributions when the dead were alive secondarily I want you to think about o and if life is so arbitrary what would you do in the comparative drown yourself in more alcohol and work to make your bosses richer it cannot be doing enjoyable things because doing enjoyable things can can still happen while you are serving these obligations if life is meaningless it is better that we create cycles of meaning that deepens our perception of the limited time that we have on this planet because when we are fighting for a legacy that their sacrifice will help people like them in the future life becomes meaningful third on anorexia and self harm if they find fulfillment from this do it it is not our place as privileged Debaters to tell monks in India that starve themselves in Protestant colonization that they should not have done that second extension grief note opposition's logic here is actually awful if self-interests are the way that they characterize things to be important don't pay for funerals because it cost [ __ ] money that you could buy other things that find enjoyment don't attend them because it might make you sad two things to observe here one someone important to you died you do feel sad you feel sad because they used to be part of your life that made it better the only logical progression for emotional processing is to feel the sadness which is done at most funerals second these actions are key to forming support structures the Delta is not whether you continue the fight like ois say but whether more people show up when I don't attend a funeral I am failing my family members that need me during that time conversely more people operating these obligations mean more people attend more shoulders to lean on and verify the sadness that you feel and talk about how to move on and they're uniquely the people that you need in the circumstance this means opposition uniquely harms people that are at very bad emotional states by reducing support structures notably grief is universal so this applies to most amount of people on the planet because death is also constant secondarily we mechanize OG when we explain grief being the precursor to enacting any agency OG talks about first emotional healing is analytically prior to structural change and fighting for it mourning the dead and accepting that they are dead if you don't resolve this you feel guilty for not doing it additionally ignoring grief specifically prevents you from enjoying other things second place an emphasis on death and owing duties means that there are prerequisites to earning this respect we don't think we owe duties to dead Nazis we don't think we owe duties to people we think we do this for like good people extending from OG this fear compounds as you get older and have accumulated more capital and agency to make more impactful changes rather than contribute to the hedonistic treadmill op subject you to we shame the terrible dead and misremember them in terrible ways which deters actions that are not good lastly I want to flesh out opposition's counterfactual specifically why their meaninglessness is actually worse before that I'll take o the moral motivation for reparations is to help the living who were disadvantaged if it was only about saying sorry to the dead you would build a very fancy graveyard and not give money to living minorities so there are separate like the point isn't if you do this or not the point is why you should do this and we say that an additional reason you should do this is because the Dead create the political Capital that make it possible for you to do this not just your autonomy to be able to enact this therefore this is logically prior lastly opposition's counterfactual you are fed a lot of non-starter obligations or interests ways to enjoy your life in ways that have diminishing marginal utility after a certain point continuing to work to get that promotion get that bonus stops being meaningful because you have experienced most emotions enjoys in life to some extent already having a duty to the dead adds to the layers of contributions you can have as a human when you teach now under our side you know that even if you are underpaid even if in the grand scheme of things you are meaningless which society tells you that by the way in terms of the life that you actually live being terrible because you're underpaid you are at least telling yourself that you're teaching future Generations that will live on and make life better for other people Ops duties here are contradictory are contradictory as well if you owe a duty to a live family you are also sacrificing that when you are doing things like work and you take time away away from your child so they don't have a comparative here even if this is the winning angle let's say you live a normal life and their Norms isn't intense and sometimes you still grieve it's still terrible because this just removes meaning in your life because contributions are perceived to stop being meaningful after you die so the inherent incentive and motivation that you have to do what feels good for you until you die happens under their side which means you get less incentives to behave well and lastly when your contributions stop at do you dying you do less things like sign up for your organs to be donated after you die specifically it entrenches the norm that nothing is important after your death therefore the only thing important to you should be your life for these reasons we wion all right thank you very much speaker for those remarks uh and before moving on to member of opposition just a really gentle but very important serious Equity reminder to please be very careful gentle and sparing especially when discussing potentially triggering material at all fronts just make sure that the debate does not come out with people feeling scarred or severely uncomfortable so yeah some words and choices can be made a little bit judiciously but thank you indeed now moving on to closing opposition member of up to start the case you're here thank you very much speaker for those very fine remarks and this is another reminder before going on to the next speaker please avoid triggering materials that would be just a little bit difficult for a lot of people and because this is a grand final a lot of people are watching and listening to this debate and they may come from different backgrounds so please be very very mindful of what is chosen to be part of your speech and if you choose some spicy choices please make it at least be worded well all right moving on then next to uh the next speaker I'd like to call up on go here here am I visible and audible yes to both uh I'll take PO is verbally death is not a stranger it walks beside us it is a quiet reminder that life is fleeting and we live in constant awareness of its present knowing that our time is finite yet what transcends this inevitability is what lingers beyond the final breath and that is the memory of those who have passed this is where we in closing government fill the Gap that is significant in this debate it is not death that defines us but how the memory of The Departed shapes the lives that we choose to lead how their legacy Whispers to us urging us to live a life with purpose to strive for goodness knowing that while life may be limited the impact that we leave behind is boundless the first thing I'm going to talk to you about in this speech is how was the uh closing government entrance into this the best OG pushes a pretty rigid principle of agency and I think o is right in questioning what is the extent of this and I think this is when both opening opposition and closing opposition run honestly blow bogus claims that try and tow the line between respect and this Duty that we are owing here is where open opening opposition makes claims like ah you can remember them for the good things they they did but don't you go owing them a responsibility though this is unclear because if the impact of what they're saying is relyant on people not caring about the date at all and investing all the Care into the living it's unclear if they actually get all the individual benefits that CG specifically talked to you about that comes analytically prior to any ability that they have to fight for proximate issues for the living the first thing I want to the second thing that I want to do in my speech is we out CEO CEO has let's be real they try and EP in this debate and try and talk about things like utilitarianism in more principal jargony sense I think a lot of the things that they talk about in terms of like caring about oneself and why like guilt will hold you back is pretty similar the aspect that they do extend on is on war heroes the first thing I want to talk about here is like if people respect these war heroes and this offense people on the ground in some way number one the owing of this responsibility can is like quite an individual thing if the state is respecting some date [ __ ] you can honor your date ancestors as well that fought against this particular date [ __ ] but secondly the analysis on why this will flood the media I think this is quite unlikely to happen because I don't think voters on either side of the house will be happy with like War like War Heroes being part of the media during like election Cycles because I don't think it's a key issue to begin with I think both the right and the left will be like dude we're [ __ ] poor can you do something to help us but secondly even if it does I think this is when we are able to counteract those narratives because this is where s explicitly talks to you about how the fact that the ones that come up before us have died it's not just to remember the good things that they have done in their life but it's the impact that their death has had the fact that George Floyd died as a result of being knelt on by a [ __ ] means that we are able to use that memory in order to fight for better like better ability and better outcomes for black people on the ground that currently are living I think this is the point at which we unlock like opening opposition's impacts in terms of fighting for the living but also this like weighs out completely closing opposition that has no Tipping Point mechanism as to whatever uh no Tipping Point mechanism whatsoever as to why this will be the case um in such a large scale weighing out then against opening opposition the first thing that they say is that people will trade themselves more than they need to because there's no end to this I.E listening to their parents told them on their death bait Etc the first response that I have is personal agency like people are not mindless followers of every wish or instruction I think people can selectively choose which aspects of a legacy to uphold especially when those legacies probably align better with their values I.E people find different ways to honor their the date even though their parents or whoever might disagree with them the way that they justify this is to say things like my parents would be proud of me because I'm happy and I'm living a good life and an honorable one as opposed to my parents would be disappointed in me because I'm a gay person the second response here is that unclear how individuals will just be okay with people dying I think this is the point that where oo is quite unresponsive to OG's premise of how death is not something that's preferable but I think here is where closing government specifically BS it home because I think we flesh out how grief is incapacitating in nature and the ability for people to live like normal lives and go about their day-to-day lives when someone important has died to them is severely hampered it is only by going through this process of grief that can only be birthed as a result of you feeling a need to go through this process because you pay an obligation to the date the fact that they did so much for you the fact that you now are like I don't know task to carry their U their like their dead body to their graves and stuff like that would seem like a responsibility that you pay to the Deb but it also makes allows you to come to terms much better with the fact that they have died therefore it's unclear why individuals with on opposition side will just move on with their lives and not care about the fact that someone important to them has died but thirdly then is the shaping mechanism of Legacy I think this is where S talks about how we are able to use uh the fact that this individ the fact that life is finite and the fact that we are remembering these individuals why this is able to create a feedback loop in the life of individuals to remind them that it is important to live honorable lives not just for the proximate materialistic benefits that I can gain in this life but it's the fact that I leave a legacy and I can be remembered and that is something that people care about because of often times people are afraid of dying people are afraid of the fact that they're going to leave this earth one day and the Very fact that they can stay alive in the memories of individuals it's something that incentivizes them to be much better the second claim here that opening opposition makes is that people forget their obligations to the living I think number one our claim on Legacy directly coun counters this by showing that individuals are driven by their desire to remember it well which promotes like ethical and Forward Thinking decisions as opposed to like really bad ones so when people understand their actions form the basis of their legacy I would argue they'd be less likely to hard wealth or like to engage in Wills like bad Wills in order to H wealth because then your family and friends will just hate you right for doing that I'm unclear as to why people would want to be remembered in this particular way when the idea of like how we owe a responsibility to the date and how we remember them constantly is going to be one that exists but the second response that I have is that we remember you for good things that you did not because you're dead I mean yeah what do you think owing a duty means it's to remember them in the best possible way it's unclear how contentious this response coming from opening opposition is yes o I'll thank you we cannot confirm the will of the dead and it is therefore those in power who ventriloquize what they would have wanted like religions or postconflict parties that is specifically why a strong duty is different from just respect uh I don't understand why this is contentious because I don't know why everyone is grieving over the same person or everyone is owing responsibility to the same dat people obviously there are majoritarian groups that will fight for like I don't know right-wing populist icons or whatever but there also minority groups that can pay pendant to like people who are like ancestors of them who fought for like things like Independence I think it's pretty clear how we weigh out opening opposition and like all bench as a whole I think we prove a more analytically prior case that unlocks the ability of people to like be better individuals and to be like better not be better individuals for themselves and to motivate themselves to do better but also to like help other people around them here is why we we over opening government I think we proved reparations much better because we proved how obligation as a result of not just things like agency and the fact that they lived the life but as a result of suffering but secondly we proved how grief and how a healthier and more unified greeing process where you able to feel the emotions of grief in a healthier way and in one that has more support structures it's much better for individuals and comes analytically prior to a lot of things that opposition talks about the weing of grief over structural changes is simple judge one is that grief is universal two is that emotional healing precedes any form of structural change that OG wants to talk about but three is the mental health implications that while structural changes may impact future Generations or be slow to materialize the ability to navigate grief and to have an immediate long-lasting impact on the lives of individuals and the psychological well-being is one that is inevitable and one that is long lasting me and Sali stayed up for like two [ __ ] days to do this tournament we better win this [ __ ] all right thank you very much go whip for those very fine remarks and finally to conclude the overall debate opposition live here here okay um thanks to everyone who supporting you know who you are three things in my speech firstly on postconflict societies our claim was very simple nationalistic leaders have used the strong duty to the dead to stoke the most toxic forms of hatred and nationalism how specifically does that happen a strong duty to the dead has been weaponized to make people engage in bloody conflicts that they wouldn't otherwise think about MOS mosovich who appealed to the Battle of Kosovo and the duty to the serbs who died to use that to attack Bosnian Muslims in Rwanda the hutus called for vengeance against the T tsis on the basis of avenging dead hutus Charles Taylor in the Liberian Civil War used the obligation to the dead as a justification to torture and kill people and crucially this is not a highb burden argument this is a very real and emotional narrative that gets used on radios in Rwanda in political messaging that recruits soldiers into armies and even if we win only these three cases that is still enough to win the debate The crucial burden that we fill is what makes this specific Duty especially powerful compared to other narratives that nationalistic leaders could use two reasons this is especially powerful and toxic one OG agrees that this narrative is particularly emotional and CG's extension also relies on this too if it's so emotional then that proves our argument that you're capitalizing upon this emotional vulnerability to manipulate people to a more significant extent and secondly the duty to the dead is relatively easier to manipulate why because the dead cannot speak for themselves we don't know how they change their wishes in response to changing social conditions so it's easier for opportunistic leaders to manipulate what dead people want and what would have been best for them in order to Galvanize people to join a particular cause what's the comparative yes opportunistic leaders still exist but we heavily moderate their behavior in two primary ways one focusing on what people need right now more closely aligns with stability within your country in many cases going to conflict also hurts you it also means that people within your own group or your own Army will also die so when you focus more strongly on an obligation to people alive right now or a vision of the future for the country you're less willing to for example Force soldiers to take risks that put them in danger and you're less willing to wage more war more willing to negotiate because people are not angered by this populist emotional rhetoric but secondly worst case scenario even if these conflicts still happen as Robbie points out parties don't stay in power on the basis of what they have for example done for people in the past they're more accountable to what they need to do right now this also responds to the DPM claim that nationalism on our side of the house is relatively more vague it's the opposite it's easier to moderate nationalism on our side of the house because you can look around and think about what people's needs are right now also o tries to hint in a POI to CG that we're derivative by saying powerful people can ventriloquized power one guys come on this is [ __ ] words this is not an argument secondly they only made this argument in the context of religious leaders they certainly did not say anything about postconflict societies our mechanisms are more specific to this context and we have weighed why this context is the most important responses to the extension go whip response number one you honor your ancestors who fought against Bad actors so for example this could be mobile Iz for good causes too one even in good cases it is bad to leverage a strong duty to the dead why because it makes people super emotional so you're less willing to for example negotiate with the other power even if that would be more strategic for them on our side of the house you can still intellectualize that something like brutality is bad or that an injustice has happened and on our side of the house you can just look around and say this could happen to people in the future so we Co-op that CG response but secondly the bad uses obviously outweigh the good uses of this narrative for the reason that in many cas cases Bad actors have stronger incentives to sort of manipulate people in order to gain power the second thing they say is that the media doesn't care about accountability for political parties in many cases the state controls the media to a more significant extent on our side of the house we get more accountability the only other implicit response that comes from gov bench is that there are fewer reparations on our side of the house two problems with this argument one we get better types of redistribution on our side of the house one of the main responses to reparations advocates in the status quo is people alive right now aren't responsible for these wrongs why should we car about dead people on our side the strategy that Advocates used is couched in language that others already agree with I.E you agree that we should care most about present day people then stick to your principles and make sure that we are giving money to these present day people so the tldr is our advocacy is relatively more convincing and the second thing to point out is that even if politicians capitulate to requests for reparations it's more likely to look like monuments on their side of the house whereas on our side of the house we have more practically beneficial forms of reparations that go to people alive today so the end point of this extension is that we get less bloody conflict on our side of the house and more accountability for parties that would otherwise engage in corruption this also applies into the future see Putin right now appealing to the deaths of Soviets in World War II in order to justify incursions in Ukraine and crimeia Crimea and I also flipped the gov bench material on reparations so we get redistribution in a more efficient way and we prove it better than opening opposition before I weigh why we win the debate outright OG so good people and activists are just as motivated as bad people dictators the good and bad probably cancel out on either side which means the consequences are symmetric you default to obligation dude come on I spent two minutes responding to this weighing one this outweighs the gov bench principle because I just proved that fewer people die crucially for agency to exist they need to be alive in the first place so if like the tricky weighing that OG wants to do is well it's a prerequisite obviously life is a prerequisite to agency so we are more important but also just to steal the deal on why utility is the most important issue one if people are equal obviously we should maximize agency as much as possible and the best way to do that is to ensure that people are alive and the second thing to point out is that OG is right that in some cases what you deem to be valuable is subjective but here is the key thing to point out even if people think that like more like soft goods are subjective an uncontroversial good that people think is good is being alive in the first place and given that people uncontroversially think it's wrong to be murdered or tortured by another individual our argument is compatible with many of the justifications they give second why does this outweigh opening opposition opening opposition has three pragmatic contributions one on redistribution this is explained in one line we prove why our advocacies are more successful secondly on loved ones the severity of watch watching loved ones be killed in war is obviously worse than grieving a loved one especially because there are alternative strategies to sort of address that grieving such as going to therapy whereas the trauma that's inflicted due to the severity of postconflict of conflict scenarios is obviously a lot worse and thirdly their stuff about religion using this in poor ways is obviously not not comparative as Robbie points out at the top ofo and thirdly it outweighs the opening opposition moral principle that dead people don't have rights why because this is just a defensive contribution against the gov bench whereas we are more offensive in explaining how individuals rights are actively stripped of them and everyone in the debate agrees that people alive right now particularly vulnerable individuals who are in these conflict scenarios do deserve rights and do deserve to be cared for we best respect those rights on our side of the house proud to win from Co right wonderful I thank the speaker for those very fine remarks and thank you very much everyone for a wonderful Grand Final debate that is the end of the debate so please virtually cross Flor shake hands
Up Next

Walter Benjamin's Arcades Project Explained | Theory Podcast
@theoryish_pod
1K views•2025-01-27

The Arcades of Paris: Walter Benjamin on Urban Politics & Philosophy
@internationalcentreforcont7204
2.3K views•2013-06-19

Should We Destroy the Machines? Big Tech Surveillance Critique
@TheStoriesWeTell303
167.9K views•2025-11-30

The Myth of Sisyphus: A Greek Legend of Eternal Punishment
@TEDEd
8.6M views•2018-11-13
Related Study Plans & Knowledge Roadmaps
Structured learning paths in Philosophy







































