Walter Benjamin's unfinished magnum opus, The Arcades Project (begun in 1927), is a fragmented, database-like work examining 19th-century Paris arcades—covered shopping arcades that served as precursors to modern malls—through a revolutionary methodology combining Marxist critique with dream interpretation; Benjamin viewed arcades as spaces where commodity culture emerged, where electric lighting transformed urban experience, and where the flâneur (urban stroller) embodied the modern condition of wandering through manufactured environments, ultimately seeing these spaces as sites of both capitalist alienation and potential revolutionary consciousness.
Walter Benjamin's Arcades Project Explained | Theory Podcast
Added:we turn our attention to what might be called the libertarian left or more popularly anarchism this is the same logic shared by Marx and frud functioning libertarian socialist institutions I think they are an interesting model that I think is highly relevant hi hello am I saying hello as well hello yeah cold open so I finally quit my job after three and a half years finally especially I you know famously Hannah and I live together it's part of our Arc and it was just absolutely horrible cuz you were just confined to the top floor of our house for hours you were like the beautiful version of the Hunchback of notra just locked up on top of our house unable to leave I will say like so my job was working from home because I started it during Co and then they never brought us back into the office they said you could come in and at that point I was like no I'm I'm already committed to the home life but that meant I'd never met like half the people so saying goodbye to them all was so OD did you especially want to meet them uh I don't know I I would have liked to not work at I okay controversial take I liked homeworking for the flexibility it gave me but it does make you miserable at times yeah standard academic response I like homework like I would have liked to I don't know the office was so like it's on campus but it's 20 minutes from here so it's like out the way cuz it's in the business park which is where I don't think many people have ever gone I didn't even know we had a business park yeah there's a lot down there but no you were basically confined to the house for so long and now you're able to see the outside world it's quite beautiful yeah how does it feel oh my God so yesterday I was working on the PHD and then I stopped work at five and I was like I've got so much time I've read half a book like I finished the book I was reading it was a Dragon Age novel I'm trying to read them all before the game comes out I I was about to make fun and say like oh was it Very Hungry Caterpillar but no Dragon Age novel is infinitely funnier yeah I was reading that I'm trying to read them all before the game comes out on which Dragon Age novel if I might oh um what was it called I think it's the calling oh Classico yeah yeah it's so good I don't know about anybody else I really that's the one with um uh the lad marrick yes yeah who is a lad yeah why do I still remember all it's so good oh my God I genuine cuz I started reading it and I was like these are G these are side note these are books attached to games I was like there's no way they're going to be good and it exceeded my expectations so now I think it's really good even though I think like if anybody else read it they'd be like oh this is a book I I think it's like it's like a distant third in terms of like the classic 2000s video games novel series behind the Halo novels I've heard these and the well I don't know if they're really good there are a lot of them they have that going for him and the oh my God Assassin's Creed novels I didn't know there was Assassin's Creed novel no I'm not con I've not met anyone who's ever read one but there are billions of them I mean the video games just didn't stop yeah yeah there's a lot of games to base them off mhm yeah yeah the story of Assassin's Creed was really good in the beginning and then I was like where do we lose the plot I can tell you where we lost the plot the pirate one but apparently that's good apparently the game is good I don't know about the story I mean like you can't it was so good for like the ancient Rome one no was it no it was Renaissance yeah yeah it's yeah um but it was really great for the Renaissance one actually it goes into what we're about to talk about today oh my God because when I was uh studying uh history of architecture they actually hired historical Architects to help design the game uh CU they're like well we want this to be as accurate as possible so they actually like put all the stuff in I would be intrigued as to who specifically they hired to do buildings in Assassin's Creed I would take that job you would take that job yeah Assassin's Creed theer builds no doubt yeah imagine in a heartbeat I would play an Assassin's Creed just set in like 80s Preston or something oh my God the romics of it all where would they jump from though that's one of the things in ass they would they would jump for I think you'll find Preston has one of the highest Church spers in the in the in the entire British Isles I think you'll find um so you jump from that's that's a tall local Landmark do do some Parkour up that um jump into some hay bales which I assume there were in Preston in maybe not hay maybe just like a a skip filled with bin bags that would be amazing is what you're jumping into what would be the outfit would it be like a track suit yeah hooded shell suit is it a velvet one uh no not not AC's Preston silly money no it would be like a Run DMC cosplay yes he also wouldn't have a hidden blade it would just be a [Laughter] hammer someone need to make this anyways today's subject is W Ben oh yeah hi this is our first um Theory episode of the season and as tradition calls for we are covering Walter Benjamin again yeah this will be the last time we do it because I feel like the joke is starting to run try yeah that doesn't mean we'll never return to Walter Benjamin I don't think that will like stop especially given how large this text is yes it's huge but yeah no we usually start each season with a Walter Benjamine it's just accidentally happened but this time it was on purpose um but who knows maybe next year you might change your mind and um we're joined by a guest Matt do you want to introduce yourself hello I'm Matt I am also a PhD student at wari I study the O how am I going to describe myself today I study postwar private house building in England in the ' 50s 60s and' 70s and yeah that's that that's what I'm up to that's what I'm about amazing no so Matt and I met through our being in the history department but also because you're sort of in between history and art history yes where we kind of switch sides I used to study architectural history now you study architectural history used to study wider European history I would say say I wouldn't go as far as European wider history yeah and then we switched but I really wanted you on today for Walter benamy because you are probably the only person we could talk to about architectural history in that this has nothing to do with what you study at all uh no this is one of the things that periodically will show up on reading lists and I will see it and I'll just be like not today but now it is today yes is literally now I've been forced to confront the Beast I mean it's it's an experimental piece but it's not a difficult piece unlike his I feel like his other essays are a lot more difficult to tackle but this one's just weird yeah C certainly when you feel like he's trying to say something you expend a lot more sort of brain power in trying to sort of get through the sort of nomic statements to get at what he's actually trying to say whereas with this I don't know we'll get into it but I I think I certainly wasn't expending as much brain power trying to work out what he was getting at MH CU I didn't feel there was much being got at but okay so we have talked about Benjamin before so if you want more on the lowdown of who he is what he was doing and what are his most famous texts literally listen to the first episode of every single season we've done thus far but uh Matt is going to build up upon what we have already learned about Benjamine so take it away Matt uh okay so in that case the actually relevant bits of my Spiel that aren't just talking about him writing multiple essays about how great having his open marriage is so quite early in his in his career when he's a fryberg well actually when he he goes to fryberg and then leaves after a year to go back to Berlin and while he's there he comes into contact with various sort of Zionist political groups but while there he encounters the Jewish Scholars gersam sholom and Martin bber and that kind of Jewish mystical influence sholom was a sort of the cabala guy in in the sort of 20th century that has a big influence particularly on the arcades project and also I mean probably predominantly thesis on the philosophy of History also being miserable crucially has an influence on thesis of the philosophy of History uh probably to a greater extent yeah I think the other relevant points here are I I think his his his friendship with adoro is very important to this because the period of his life when he's writing the arcades project is the period where adoro is just sort of giving him things to do because he's he's severely underemployed in we are yeah he he can't he can't get a university job partly because he writes something incomprehensible about Gerta that's IM imagine if your University thesis was attacking the main scholar in your field and then also talking for a bit about how great your open marriage is um I mean that's currently what H well that's what happened at the University of Chicago yeah I mean many such cases but um still a wild choice to do yeah but there's that aspect of it and Ador know sort of V various Frankfurt School guys persuade him to publish various bits of it and if you if you go to the the published edition of the arcades project there's a couple of things you'll see called exposes and they are sections that he was persuaded to write into sort of proper chapters that he could send off to people to try and get funding unsuccessfully but there's you know several of his made Major Works come out of the arcades project so it he starts it in 1927 loads of his work until his death uh offshoots of the bigger project uh so work of art in the age of mechanical reproduction that comes from it Paris capital of the 19th century that comes out of the arcades project and his big long essay is on bodair I think it's like 160 pages of the arcades project is just boder which I will I will not be dabling in neither will I so quite what the point of the project was is very heavily debated because I think Hannah you were saying that you you read somewhere that it was meant to be published in the form that it is actually published in now yeah yeah so I was reading um and I will so any sources I forgot to say this to you man so I'll say it to you now any sources that you draw on we have a reading list which is just a Google doc that I put together from anything mentioned and then we leave it in the description so in the description I'll leave this Source but it's from real life mag and it's them talking about the arcades project but they said perhaps what is most interesting about the arcades project is it is not and was never meant to be a book it was essentially a card catalog a database of Deb's his potential for the final revision of the catalog was to remove all of his own writing and leave the experts to speak for themselves believing this the best way to tell history which insane um if if if you actually read the thing because I mean what one of the things that people have sort of wrestled with with the additions is that I I think I think I've read somewhere that like someone called it like an oppressive amount of quotes in like Mo most of the chapters the sort of quote that he's taken from elsewhere that that are in bold font usually outweigh his comments on it quite a lot so in order to get sort of what Benin himself is taking from this you have to kind of Astral project into his head a bit and sort of try and work out what each quote is sort of doing there and lot lots of the quotes are quite sort of uninteresting it's just sort of statistics and here's some facts and figures I'm going to put in here and then others are a lot meater but we'll get into that yeah there's also like a lot of anecdotal information it for me and we talked about this off off mik but it reads like someone's in the middle of a research project where they're getting all their sources together and things that they're referencing and you can sort of read between the lines and see where the train of thought was going but sometimes like you know with sections and things moving about the train stops abruptly at somewhere and then you hop on another train so it is a bit of a messy read it's a challenging read this is I don't think this is a beginner friendly text you have to know a lot of history and a lot of what's happening contemporaneously to that time to even pick up on the Nuance that is being sort of curated and developed CU that each convolute is a very specific point to a very specific time period and yeah like this there's a reason why I kind of we we wanted someone to help us with this or at least just to break it down because it is not an easy text yeah I don't I don't know how helpful I'll be uh but we'll certainly all sort of share the burden um because it it's the way it's published now so it was originally amazingly it was originally conceived as a short newspaper article about the arcades of Paris and it quickly ballooned out of control so it it balloons into a long essay then a book and then by 1930 he's describing it as the theater of all my struggles um my PhD yeah our all our phds the theater of all my struggles but it it's incomplete when he dies and the full array of notes and sort of half completed sections is public published in German in 1982 and then it only gets an English translation in 1999 which I mean the delay on that is obvious cuz it's like over a thousand pages in length but the I mean the the reader Guide to the arcades project so if you you'll hear us talk about sort of convolutes instead of chapters it has these things called convolutes which I think if I remember correctly it's not to do with it being convoluted it is convoluted but it it's from sort of the literal meaning of the word which is I think it's vaguely architectural Volute means sort of flowering I want to say it something to do with the top of columns don't quote me on that um it's uh rolled longitudinally upon itself sure I can imagine a column doing that yeah so that there's those but within the chapter itself within the within the convolutes themselves uh it alternates between a bold font and a smaller font so the smaller font is benin's sort of it's benin's own writings but those writings still include quite a bit of quotes so it's not in it's not sort of that clearcut but the the ones in bold their extensive quotes from the sources that he's drawing on and in terms of the sources he's drawing on he is drawing on a lot because I mean it's it's it's about sort of like a decade where he's just sat in the bibl Tech National reading everything and I think the approach he had is actually as a historian the thing I sort of got a lot from it was you can imagine someone taking this historical approach in the sort of 90s the translator's introduction actually puts this very well if you'll permit me to to read out a bit so Benjamin's intention from the first it would seem was to grasp such diverse material under the general category of erish shika signifying the Primal history of the 19th century this was something that could be realized only indirectly through cunning it was not the Great Men and celebrated events of traditional historiography but rather the refu and detritus of History the half-concealed variegated traces of the daily life of the collective that was to be the object of study and with the aid of methods more Akin above all in their independence on chance to the methods of the 19th century collector of Antiquities and Curiosities or indeed to the methods of the 19th century ragpicker than to those of the modern historian not conceptual analysis but something like dream interpretation was the model the 19th century was the collective dream which we its heirs were obliged to re-enter as patiently and minutely as possible in order to follow out its ramifications and finally awaken from it now dream interpretation there will ring alarm bells in the minds of most historians and I I think the text as a whole Rings a l AR bells in sort of most historians in that he's trying to draw out meaning but quite quite how he's doing that is quite esoteric yeah in the fashion that dream interpretation is esoteric but yeah yeah I remember when I first read pieces of this when I was an undergrad we read the pieces on the Flur um which is very long and hence why we did not do it but it was this alongside a lot of Freud to sort of of go into what it meant to occupy space and walk around space and what this this may sound completely strange to someone that does not understand concepts of space not in like here you are sitting in a room but it's how rooms function and how things are designed to function because the practice of Architecture is not just about the Beauty and the Aesthetics but it's how people move and occupy space so there's a thing called circulation sort of like how the heart pumps blood in and out Architects purposefully designed spaces to work with the subconscious of people of here's the entrance here's the exit and how you move and interact is purposefully manufactured so when Benyamin is going into these ideas of spaces and how and using this like dreamlike state of occupying an an arcade which we will get into what it actually is very very soon there is a dream likeness to this because he's looking at actual construction and purpose of construction he's also mixing in his own like Marxist leanings with what it means to live in artificial manufactured spaces that are then pseudo environments but in their fake environment nness they're creating a new environment so he's sort of looking into what makes up all of these different things these little clusters into a larger thing and obviously very difficult to get every single little bit of what an arcade acts like a space there's many different things happening especially in the late 1800s early 1900s with the speed of which technology is moving yeah no I think like I'm trying not to jump ahead but so for this specific episode we or me and paa I guess you've read more on that but I read a little bit more yeah yeah um we specifically read convolute T which is about modes of lighting and that was one that's convolute capital T capital T yeah there is there is a list of convolutes that are capital letters and there is a list of convolutes that are lowercase letters okay interesting capital D yeah but um we've read about modes of lighting and that was one of the things that struck me right like it really captured even though it was only in quotations the feeling of the space even if you know I don't specialize in anything to do with any of this so I didn't have a reference for any of it but even I could like feel the space like just to jump ahead a little bit but he talks at one point there's a quote like it's they've all got like weird letters and numbers for each bit but 1 a was about on the ladies of the cash register all day long they go about in their hair colors and dressing gowns after Sund down however when the gas is lit they make their appearance AR raay as for a ball you know like this is very like Poetic it's not this happened at this time and that kind of History do you know what I mean which makes sense from what we've read of Benjamine before yeah no so I guess let's go into what an arcade is because we've been talking think around this kind of explaining what the text is but why why arcades so arcades are more popular here I think in in the UK and in Europe in general there's there's more of them left here certainly yeah in the states I don't think I've run into an arcade willing to be proven wrong can I just ask Matt is there some in Birmingham there are there are plenty in birmingh okay okay cuz I I'm going to get into my sort of nationalist thing but um okay okay yes there there there are several in Birmingham the there's Picadilly arcade there's the Great Western arcade there are I'm sure many others but yeah Leicester has them Manchester has them uh loads of Seaside towns have them Cardiff yes cardiff's just about Seaside town but yeah yeah so an arcade is technically a passageway with coverings with like arches either on the side or on the top top most arcades from its Inception have been converted into little shopping centers or cafes um these were really really good cuz one they were sort of easy to build cuz it was just get iron up structure glass and it was also really good covering for bad weather so you could sort of hide in an arcade for a bit you can get a coffee you can get you know you can go to The Butchers you can go to the shopkeepers to get a hat whatever you want these things also tended to be built near train stations or on train stations or it would be like a hybrid of the two yeah sort of near train St I mean the all all of the arcades in um in Birmingham and near the train stations uh so pic did the arcade is next next to New Street and Great Western arcade is next to Snow Hill yeah and there's um with the Underground in London there is the arcade in Kensington um which is a smaller one but still existing so these spaces were really curious because it was a concentrated shopping instead of it being a large market area they were sort of condense into these little like kiosks and you know it was the place to be you would walk around because you were safe from the rain you can stay dry most of them had paved Street ways so your shoes your coats wouldn't get dirty it was sort of like it was the modernday mall and you know as the text is going to go into at first a lot of these had gas lamps but then with the invention of electricity and the installation of electricity into these spaces things could stay open longer so there is this new development of what it means to be a pedestrian what it means to be um a shopper and what businesses me to represent and I I think the fact that one of the sort of biggest things is the fact that these are places that people go to for fun it's not sort of you don't go there when you need something you go there when you want to see a bunch of cool things because I mean lots of them had and that there's a there's a whole different convolute about this but loads of them were home to um panoramas which were large paintings later it ended up being large photographs of sort of scenery a streetcape uh that people would go in as sort of visitor attractions sort of like Cinemas became so you know they're they're they're they're a popular visitor attraction they sort of the The Talk of the Town I will say Benjamin I think thinks they're invented in Paris they're not um there's lots of that going on uh yeah and like there is a specific art historical word that goes a lot with arcades and with panoramas and all that stuff and it's fantasmagoria so it is this like otherworldly sensation so fantasmagoria is defined as a sequence of real and imaginary images like that seen in a dream so once more we get this dreamlike state so it seems kind of strange to I think people now why this would be such a like dreamlike thing but people need to remember that lights are new things were really dark and you know you can see it like I think a good representation would be like a rembrand where you have like a singular source of light and that creates this weird interaction with you in your environment but with the creation of electric light one there was a buzz like it wasn't a silent thing it went from you know like the sound of like light gas to like just like this weird electric thing that no one had ever experienced before then the quick and availability of it there you know no longer needed one of the people with the gas to light it up now you could you know flip a giant switch cuz you know it's still the 18 1900s but the sudden burst of light it it almost feels theatric so people would walk around these spaces and sort of Marvel at like you know go wow we don't even need the World's Fair anymore the World's Fair is here yeah there was um part like it from Benjamin's own writing where he calls them um fairy Gros or like he Compares them to fairy gr and I think that's a really lovely image but where hang on M where were they invented then panoramas oh no no like the arcades oh arcades uh gosh um I I need I need to do some quick Googling here wait so you knew where panoramas came from yeah well I mean the first big one is it's it's a blo called Robert Barker oh yeah that's not French yeah um but yeah he he does panoramas of of London that there panoramas are really popular around the sort of turn of the 18th 19th century in London as well as Paris there's oh God there's a famous building that used to be the it was called the London Panorama and it might it might be the leester square runda that would make sense because of the size of luster Square yeah but it was demolished and then replaced with something else yes it was turned into the Catholic Church of nraam De par o um which is the French Catholic Church in London um that was this has layers I just had to yeah poor Benjamine yeah if he if he knew about that he he exploded um but in terms of where arcades come from I don't really know that off the top of my head it's also difficult to look up first arcade because it's just like for video games okay so technically the first arcades were aquad dos uh well in terms of yeah but but that's just the word because it Arad just means that it's a series of archers I will say also there is arcades are also usually compared to the way Gothic Cathedrals are made because of the entrance of light yeah so if you go into like a go or even if you look at like a replica of a Gothic Cathedral there's layers to how Cathedrals are where there's like the is it colonade yeah there's a row of columns on the ground right and then it and then it goes up it depends on how big the the church building is but it should have a clear story and the the clear story is a sort of intermediate layer between that and the larger windows but ultimately everything above the kind of bottom layer is that's meant to let in light so that that's the lighting system of the building and arcades function mostly the same yeah so that's why it's kind of difficult to get like you know where was the first arcade there was versions of it all throughout time cuz the name arcade is also just like a technical term because it's what the style of building is it's not like the arcade yeah yeah so that's what arcades are yeah that's a long way of going around it I mean I'm seeing that the covered Market in Oxford was opened in 1774 that predates the pet Royale in Paris by 10 years so all right that's a win for us um zero Benjamin yeah I'm not convinced the covered Mark I I it it's it's a covered Market it's not really an arcade I don't think because I think the the what distinguishes the arcade is it's effectively an Alleyway it's going from one street to another street but sort of with shops either side of it and it's covered whereas the covered Market is sort of a building in itself you don't really use it to get between places yeah I defined it as the Confluence between materiality commodity and modernity so I think those three things need to function in order for it to be an arcade yeah you've got you've got to have some iron going on you got to have some from some fabricated glass yeah it has to contain lots of smoke in there cuz also like we're describing it as this like amazing space it stank you know it had gases all up in that cuz you know you had like very old heating systems going against contemporary stuff that was going going on with electricity so it was a space of mess it was a lot of people you know it was also known for like a lot of pickpocketing a lot of crime CU it's it's just an Alleyway with like a bunch of people just there but it was also once more like we said before it was also a market so it was just like this weird combination of things and where I think benam me's Obsession of this came about was one probably growing up in these spaces and then two just sort of how large they became yeah I mean did Belin have shopping arcades let's get a quick quick research I'm pretty sure they did I know they had bin ar oh I'm just going to get like flipper Hala no I oh God the fried Sten arcade oh okay yeah well because friederick staso is the that's the big sort of 19th century shopping Street yeah what I was going to go with this was a lot of these arcades were then knocked down to make way for contemporary malls yeah in Paris in particular they were knocked down during um Baron housman's reordering which I mean most of these arcades were only around for about sort of 40 50 years before they were demolished for more efficient uses of real estate yeah and this is like the creation of the big shopping malls where you know they were insane herods here in the UK was one of the big original ones wasn't it and this is where like storefront design became a thing where you had the mannequins with the clothes and all these things arcades had versions of this but it was too small if once more it was an Alleyway so it went from these like spaces of like transientness of going from point A to point B then maybe shopping in the middle two spaces completely dedicated to shopping and you can peruse around the shopping areas but at the end of the day there is an expectation that you will buy something so there is this like weird Nostalgia I think also with Benyamin looking at the arcades as like the beginning of this like takeover of commodity culture yeah definitely there's a very good quote by a guy who I definitely have to look more into guy called Egon friedel who was a sort of German cultural historian in like the 20s so as they all were yeah but well well no that's the thing no no one was doing like you you were doing sort of art history or you know but apparently loads of his work is sort of anecdotal which I don't know I always like reading lies um but he he says and this is really interesting this made me want to read more of his work he says and for those reading along this is T1 a comma 10 uh we said in the first volume that every historical period is based in a distinctive light hard hard statement um whether dial or nocturnal now for the first time this world has an artificial Illumination in the form of gas light which burst onto the scene in London at a time when Napoleon star was beginning to decline which entered Paris more or less contemporaneously with the bourbons and which by slow and tenacious advances finally took possession of all streets and public localities by 1840 it was flaring every where even in Vienna in this strident and gloomy sharp and flickering praic and ghostly illumination large insects are busily moving about shopkeepers I remember reading that and I was like oh my God yeah which it I me I mean admittedly I've not read much sort of history of that period like historical writing of that period but that seems sort of Fairly ahead of its time sort of like every historical period is based in a distinctive light like you can very easily imagine like someone writing that in sort of 2010 um sort of some sensory history person well I mean like I just think of the sphere in Vegas but yeah sure well because they've turned an entire Street there into an arcade it's a Fremont Street which for fans of Fallout New Vegas that is the street that the King School of impersonation is on Fremont Street they've turned that into a covered it's not really a covered Mark it's a covered shopping mall but like it's it's an entire wide street that is covered in a it's not covered in glass well it is covered in glass but it's covered in like a plasma T like a screen like like a LCD yeah TV screen that's sort of yeah blasting s adverts for Tom Jones concerts that you that's well that's exactly where I was going to go with lots of people are complaining about like the light pollution and how distracting it is while driving because it's so damn bright it's so bright it's huge like things like that and like the sphere specifically it's ugly it's mostly just used for advertisements it was like hailed as this like Marvel of LED work or whatever it was but it's just for advertisement and it like it's a hideous Skyline feature I'm sure like the same thing was said about you know the Eiffel Tower at the time sure but this one's like a true attack on the senses in that you cannot see anything past it it's so bright so it's causing like near accidents and the closer you get to it the more pixelated it becomes and it's not really used for anything it's just used for commodity there's concerts inside of it the horrible YouTu concert was in there yeah fish at least makes a bit more sense fish fish play there fish plate this F yeah I knew the Grateful Dead did but I didn't God is it just jam bands are they just inviting jam bands in there well it's old people that can afford the tickets so yeah oh dear we've offended a large demographic that does not listen to this podcast yeah but you know it's it's a space of commodity it is like you can tour it during the day but what is there to see that it's just for shopping it is a space dedicated for that kind of interaction so I just the entire time I was we were reading this um I just kept thinking about the sphere and just like how like it just the way that light is interpreted because at some points people are talking about it like it's like this magical thing and in a way it is like you went from like not Pitch black but like from a very different type of lighting that your eyes have adjusted to to an electric light that can almost be blinding because you're just not used to it for now like you know anything darker than the fluorescent is you know a cave but back then like there is a an large art historical study of how electric light change painting yeah because you can just finally see models being an everyday person working in these spaces and dealing with like this insane brightness also meant that like shops could be kept open later so like there's a quote here about gratuiti and how like it was now expected to pay a little bit more because you know places were kept open longer oh I was just thinking there's I was looking for there's a long extract that maybe I'm misunderstanding it but it reminds me of what you're saying about this like blind in light right it's t31 one yeah that talks about like the eyes initially put up rather well with this penetrating new enemy but by degrees they were dazzled blindness began as something temporary soon became periodic and ended as a chronic problem the really funny quote from that bit is um it's towards the end talking about sort of the impact of kind of cuz I mean Light Electric Lighting electric technology in general is you know it's to do it's to do with information and the am the amount of information that people are being presented on a day-to-day basis sort of you know in in in terms of products which you've already discussed but I want to go back to the products thing the there's the there's the quite at the end about sort of like various sort of business managers and sort of the impact this has on them and it says one branch correspondent tells him at 10: in the morning if a Shipwrecked vessel worth over a million another five after 10 of the unexpected sale of the most Pros house in the two Americas a third at 10 after 10 of the Glorious entrance into the port of Marseilles of a freighter carrying the fruits of a northern California Harvest all this in Rapid succession the poor brains of these men robust as they were have simply given way I mean yeah it's this is Time Square like of course there's like you know Oxford Street here in like Lester square and those are horrible spaces do not get me wrong I want to set them Ablaze but standing in the middle of Time Square makes me want to die it is an attack of information it is noisy it is a guy in an offbrand Elmo suit trying to get you to take a picture for $20 it is Hell upon Earth and your brain does shut down because you go into survival mode you're like this is far too much information this smells bad why does it smell like urine why is there like a Spotify playlist like download code in front of me why is the margarita Ville like filled with people it's too much see all all those guys in Time Square like some some of them have their own Wikipedia articles there's like the Naked Cowboy he has his own article but there's all those guys and they're relatively new I all of the like sort of performers and the kind of cuz certainly cuz the one of two times listener I've left the country in 2014 school trips New York uh it was still just guys selling you their CDs um in Time Square partially successfully to one member of our party yeah no it's they still don't worry they still do the mixtapes they they give it to you in your hand and then they tell you it's $5 yeah we we we found out it had his Instagram on the CD uh so we all we all went on his Instagram and left horrible comments cuz he scammed it this man's like I hate the English this kind of reminds me of less intense but do you know the new thing they've done at Houston where they've changed the big screen from that big screen they put smaller screens and now the big screen is just advertisement Why like I know why but like so unnecessary it's it's just adverts and it goes black and tells you we're saving electricity not letting you know that putting a screen on black uses more electricity than putting it on white great so thank you oo energy for lying but no actually Houston I think Houston is a good example because it's you know it's a bunch of shops that you can't really go inside of you just go up to buy food pray that you get your food on time before the train leaves and then you run to your train because they don't tell you until 15 minutes before your freaking train departs if you're lucky mhm and then you have to pray you don't get crushed yeahh I mean I I think the shopping experience at Houston I think it it much more utilitarian because I mean the the thing about sort of the shopping arcade or sort of any anything dedicated to shopping is sort of part of the point of it is that it's a diversion you know it's it's it's a day out or it's something that you you know walk through because it's nicer than walking along a rainy Street I would say maybe then the Bullard Birmingham with the multiple floors the bull ring bull ring what do you say Bullard for Bullard is in Coventry oh yeah whereing it's where the gay bar used to be oh yeah that I can't remember the name of um R yeah yeah the Bor ring is a is a much s better example with the stupid uh animatronic bll thing and it blinks it like comes to life I have a I have a personal Vendetta against Aussie the bull because one time what's the name Aussie the bull it's named after it's it's named after russie Osborne yeah because Birmingham loves touting the wrong things um it it loves it loves yelling about how oh we invented heavy metal Aussie osbornes from here don't you know and then trying to demolish the pub where they played their first gig but you know they've got one of my le like sorry this is Birmingham chat but like the they've got the like the Black Sabbath Bridge or something that's just a bridge they have no association with that bridge they want their own Penny Lane yeah exact it's it's it's just a tourist spot where people will take stupid photos they they they want it to be like Cam and locked but like it's not it's Broad Street come on no it's Broad Street getting Coyote Ugly but all is to say there are remnants of like arcades in the UK uh I think more than any other part of the EU because there's a couple in Paris that are still standing but there's there's not much left but here I've ran into a lot of arcades yeah I mean British Redevelopment here wasn't as you know much as we can play about it it wasn't actually as extensive as sort of European Seas cuz we didn't get bombed as much and also I mean Paris did it to itself yeah it did it through hous mination yeah that that's that's where those arcades went and elsewhere in Europe I imagine sort of you know War didn't help yeah so when you go up to like places like Manchester there's a lot of arcades still up and they're still used like it's it's one of my favorite places to go is like the Manchester arcades because it's sort of tucked away a lot of tourists don't tend to go there they like go in look around they leave but a lot of locals have sort of like reopt those areas as you know spaces there's not a lot of national commercial it's a lot of like individual shops some better over worse lots of lots of specialist shops yeah so um I went to like a really good like coffee shop but like they made like they grind their own beans they they roast their own coffee there was also you know like a specialty butchers thing that was like very specific odd meats that I was a little bit about but hey who am I but no it's sort of I I think it's interesting how it's still specialty shops it always has been and like it it's sort of more transitioned from a space of Wonder to more of like a local Hideout yeah an escape from you know what is now just car covered streets so I feel like yeah the arcades were like the last bit of pedestrian that we had in a way yeah and I I think in terms of conceptualizing the sort of Victorian city as somewhere that is oh God I'm going to sound like a sort of town planning bore but like somewhere sort of The Pedestrian experience is quite important and sort of people walking about and sort of promenading is kind of essential to the way it functions cuz I mean have we said the word Flur yet oh we haven't well I I sort of said that I read about the flanner right okay I mean do we are we going to are we going to go into the flanner yeah why not okay so Hannah do you know what a flanner is no what do you imagine a flanner to be I have no idea one who flans I've got the Wikipedia paged up and I is it not helping no so it says it says it was popularized in the 19th century for a type of urban male stroller lounger SRA or loafer that's those are all words that you would love to be described as um the so it comes about in the in the 19th century it's popularized a lot by bodair who Benjamin is obviously very interested in obsessed yes and it's sort of I I mean before we get into the flaner I'll talk about sort of how bodair figures in to benin's whole sort of idea is that lots of bod's writing and lots of sort of late 19th century decadent writing is just sort of listing products in shop Windows which sounds really odd but in in terms like people people reading this were just sort of like oh wow look at all of the stuff we can buy and obviously sort of I I think diagnosed some sort of social sickness as a result of that but you know it's it's in bodair it's in Arthur Mack it's in I'm sure various other decadent authors that I can't name uh but the that figures in quite heavily to what Benjamin's doing in this sort of interest and sort of explosion in the variety of commercial products and sort of advertising and Shop windows and stuff it also came in with people caring a a little bit like everyone's always cared about their looks but now with factories you can get new colors and patterns made with clothing and with other sort of materials so what before would be like a very tedious process of dying and construction well now you had sewing machines now you had fast processed cotton you had the development of synthetic dies you know For Better or For Worse because some people died because of them but you had the cre creation of new things and with that came okay so we have all these new things what do we do with it so you get strolling as a thing where you dress up real nice and you walk around and you show off the the new things you've purchased because also this is also the beginning of catalogues where you can actually go on a thing and go well I want this and this color and this da but before it this take a lot longer but now you can Outsource it to get made and then it be delivered I think what you on about there is sort more in terms of sort of putting on clothes I think that's more sort of promenading yeah um which is that that's yeah that there's a transition from promenading into sort of Flannery and sort of promenading develops in the sort of that's more of an 18th century thing M but by by the 19th century you have the the points of the is the Flor is not necessarily buying stuff they're experiencing the city for you know its City but it's the flanner is sort of identified by bodair becomes this sort of Ideal type and 19th century people are obsessed with identifying social types there a wonderful article about sort of people because people start getting buses people start getting trains sort of commuting and they spend an awful lot of time when they're not reading newspapers just sort of staring at MOS um just sort of like looking at people around them and just being like I know what you are um and sort of ident like there's sort of pages of gossip columns dedicated to identifying different Happ in Germany yeah it's types of guy um but the but the flaner is a type of guy and it's this sort of young to middle-aged man always a manh this is crucial who walks about the city to experience it to sort of get to grips with it develop a good knowledge of the sort of the mental geography of it and that sort of over time the Flur sort of persists as a type of person that you should build for you should build for people wandering um it sort of it starts a bit with um gorg siml who wrote something I can't remember the name of in the 1910s I think saying that the the city is designed or it ought to be designed sort of in order to accommodate people wandering because ultimately wandering is sort of what people do in cities which isn't really true I've completely misrepresented everything giml ever said there probably um he's fine but by by the sort of mid 20th Century it's being talked about in sort of planning documents and sort of like you have to design for people sort of wandering around you have to make sort of perspectiv so that things are sort of remarkable when you walk walk around a corner you have to put and and it actually figures in quite heavily to sort of shopping center design of sort of when someone's walking along what are they going to see first but it's it's this idea of the sort of pedestrian moving through and the kind of person mastering the tools of the city to sort of enhance their sort of their being and sort of self-actualization there are arguments about whether or not there are lady flanners the fluse largely regarded to be a myth by most authors uh they think let women can't walk around um wi women do not women be shopping women do not be floring um yeah yeah we only develop legs in the early 20th century yes I is going to say pal this sounds like you this sounds like a of you just like walking around experiencing the city I mean we have done this yes that there are I'll I'll say it I'm a fler um there are that I mean there are there are many sort of self-identified flers they largely call themselves psycho geographers nowadays but I don't you're both well no right FL flers there is no again I'm he's going to say it um I have never heard a woman refer to herself as a psycho geographer in my life mainly because I'm not convinced that Ian Sinclair has a very high female readership it's mostly fellas and fleeces in dolon you know yeah that's that that's the whole deal so what is it I'm reading about it geography don't don't go there don't get into it it's a dark path it's lads who are convinced that memorizing Street patterns gives them magical powers basically somebody described psycho geography as charmingly vague yes yes well it's an IDE yeah it it's taken from the situationists who which should be alarm Bells immediately um it's it's taken from the situationist as this kind of idea of sort of turning the capitalist logic of the city on its head by deliberately sort of going against its Logics and kind of just wandering about as you please sort of going where the wind takes you and then that was translated into in the sort of 80s and 90s in London it was translated into a great way to design Pub crawls essentially yeah um yeah for for the most part but also there is with the modern day FL flers um there there is works on preserving you know cities and stuff you know there's Jane Jacobs with the life and death of Great American cities and like the beauty that is a sidewalk and accessible spaces so these are all things that kind of tag along with sort of balair Benyamin this existence of I think it's sort of changed now from just walking with the city to developing Community within cities um and that Community is not just interpersonal but it is community with like the preservation of space and the maintenance of accessible spaces where you know especially as as we now have housing crisis things spaces being consistently bought up for private Enterprise yeah I mean I think lots of the sort of emphasis on sort of like Flannery and sort of wondering about and making the city it's partly to do with community and partly to do with just sort of making the city have some feeling that's not just like oh there's popey opening you know um how dare you which look I'm not a fan I'm not it's too much it's delicious it's too much you're wrong all right agreed to disagree about Popeyes go um but yeah just sort of making it have some meaning or feeling you know beyond just being sold there things everywhere which is kind of ironic given the that's the purpose of the city yeah well I mean you know as as someone that like I don't I'm not from the UK who would have thought with this accent but having moved to Coventry it was one of those things where had I not walked around just aimlessly I would not have found a lot of like little spots and shops and things that I like to frequent centry is getting a pop eyes as soon as I'm leaving yeah why was it this is a conversation for off mik but the point is you know that's how we befriended the guy from Gosford books us walking around absolute Legend um shout out to that place he's never going to open the door for any of you yeah but it's it's one of those things where it makes you appreciate the place you live in so I guess the Flor is not dead it just changes and evolves I guess yeah i' would say maybe travel vloggers maybe oh God TR vloggers is the new fler I I think right the the only authentically sort of flurish travel travel vloggers are like middle-aged guys who love getting on buses they they're the flaters of the age yeah if you're getting on a plane to cost I don't know where people go yeah yeah um it's not the um I have $3,000 to get on this plane and now we're going to travel like no it's none of that yeah no it's I'm spending €1 EUR on a mega bus to Romania um let's let's see how it go no bathroom challenge let's see how it goes no I'm actually currently following on Tik Tok this guy that's uh hitchhiking from Egypt to Japan uh now I'm not an expert in hitchhiking but there is a large body of water in the way there he's going from country to Country to Country and yes but I mean hitching can also go through vat you can hit on boat okay okay I don't know how he's going to do it he's stolen like one of the stands and actually he just crossed China okay yeah so he's getting there m I'll send it to you I saw a guy walking from or he was trying to pleas don't say this what if this is the guy I'm thinking of the guy who walked I can't remember somewhere in the UK it's like I beefer walk okay you're not talking about hardest geizer okay no no hardest gezer hardest gezer is the palest man you have ever seen walking from one end of Africa to the other one and being racist the whole way um don't look into him he's he's not he's not an admirable figure you know I will yeah we have gone so far off subject yeah yeah but I feel like we harder the modern day FL no that sounds like aely that sounds like a medium article okay um I think if anything our discussion is in the spirit of the arcades project in it is mostly just saying whatever he wants and just sort of free associative smash it together I do have an actual point about that okay great if we if we want to bring this back into the vague realm of intellectualism um surrealism big influence on Ben well it's it's people argue how much of an influence actually was on him but you know this is a coll ultimately it's and I mean the fact that he apparently wanted to completely remove his own commentary on it and just let the text speak to each other that's a very collage thing it's also a very sort of Pomo postmodernist thing in the sense of just you know let recognizing these things as texts and sort of trying to get at you know the sense of an age through its texts and making them speak to each other again again that's sort of very again I don't know whether to say ahead of its time because having seen that cultural historian guy I'm just like um but the yeah you can see why people in the 80s and 90s would sort of like completely freaking they're not out about this yeah I I see it as like literature bricka bra just like these individual things and I think you I mean you're right it is like the putting them to talk to to each other and in that conversation you sort of pick up like these like little Snippets of people's vision and you can see where Benjamin's vision is also then coming in just through the organization and the pacing yeah of these of these quotes and yeah it's it's it's so strange to call it his when he barely writes in it I was going to say it's it's sort of like the Cure ation of it all yeah him it's his in the sense of like my notes are mine even when that's mostly quotes I mean this reading this was wildly terrifying because I was just sort of reading it and I'm just like this is what my notes look like this is awful I'm not going like oh yeah I'm Benjamin I'm going like I'm Benjamin oh god um but it's these sort of big long chunks of quotes and extracts interspersed with his him occasionally just sort of like slipping in a fact just sort of being like in the pl de deil around 1848 there was a cafe dug Gaz that's it that's one note that and and just sort of like sprinkling in a fact or occasionally that there'll be bits where he says sort of I don't think it's in the gaslighting chapter but he he says something like there should be a bit explaining this which I do in my notes all the time just sort of talking to myself being like there should be a bit about this here which never gets done um um so yeah not an edifying experience reading yeah kind of reminds me but not really because it's different discipline but um there's a book called the mess of social science that talks about how messy research actually is and like putting everything together and all your ideas is ultimately like very difficult and and less so in history I think actually still in history but in sociology especially like we of write about the way we do research very neatly or it comes across as very neat when actually in practice is is a mess and so I think this is one view into that mess right like the like you're saying there's notes being like there should be this here or or this was built at this time like that's also what my notes look like right like it's um stuff from my participants interspersed with other people stuff and then at sometimes um I don't know if you've found this like you'll go back and you'll be like why why have I put these like five things together who who was I at that time yeah which is sort of it it's why on sort of one level I think the people who are sort of like no it was meant to be published like this it's meant to be that I'm just sort of like you know this is notes this is very obviously notes um but at the same time I mean there very they're very neatly organized notes and sort of tightly assembled in certain order so you know there is something to that and I mean also he um he used to write quite a lot in a format called the now this is a difficult word for me f f yeah yeah let's go for that um but that's essentially like just little epigram statements at sort of the end of sort of the gossip page is in so French newspapers and he used to do a lot of writing for that that eventually became oneway Street yeah yeah but that that's sort of collated and he loves an aphorism he just loves a little sort of gomic statement that's meant to you know mean something Grant I mean Su Susan sonag God help me always comes back to her yeah Susan sonag has a good quote about his writing style it's as though every sentence had to say everything before the inward gaze of total concentration dissolved the subject before his very eyes which I think is a it's very apt description because every sentence is so loaded with sort of stuff and meaning that you're just sort of like you could have very easily just sort of swwa the semicolons for man you know um or like you can explain this but it's as though he was going to die the second he stopped writing it had to say everything within itself yeah to sort of wrap things up because we can go on talking about this forever I feel yeah probably um we usually end with uh media connection and I was originally going to say the painting Nighthawks by Edward Hopper but in this conversation and like the fler and like sort of dangers and stuff like that I actually thought it came to my brain M by Fritz Lang with the usage of Shadows and sort of the dangers of modernity and fr slang's first time even including sound into his films where everything has a very purposeful artificiality to it so that you are on edge I thought that would be a pretty weird but good connection yeah and I I mean the kind of the murderer as Urban Wanderer is definitely a sort of thing going on there I'm trying to think you got me on Flur film what's on Flur films uh no God I was actually about to say before Sun Before Sunrise can you believe me um who are you what have you become um I love that yeah it is good and I love like you have to hand it to them all of them there's like three yeah second one's the best one yeah no question no question it's it's like 80 minutes long as well yeah 10 out 10 outstanding real time um but 80 minutes to completely dissolve Ethan Hawk's marriage is astounding he he he gets one look at Julie delpy and he's like I'm risking it all wife kids house gone yeah I'm I'm moving back to Paris um but the god Urban wander films what's a film where people do lots of walking I don't know let's go actually I have a very wanky British suggestion it's called London it has sequels called Robinson and Robinson in space it's by a filmmaker called Patrick Keeler and he's very into this psycho geography thing but it's framed as on sort of around the 1992 general election which doesn't really Factor into that much the narrator is I think I think it's a series of reminiscences about IMDB John Major as self uncredited the it's a series of reminiscences about his sort of colleague friend lover I can't quite remember called Robinson and Robinson is this kind of sort of urban traveler who's sort of wandering about and making observations and sort of like Benjamin various nomic statements about sort of the city and what it means and various things it kind of it sort of speaks to the sequels are less like it kind of expands outwards from London a bit but the the first one is is very sort of London Centric there's a lot of I think flano film making is less common than flano literature which there you you go you go into a local booksh shop in Hackney and there there will be a shell of all of it Ian Sinclair very worth reading his book London orbital that's probably the best one WGC bold he writes mainly about wandering around sort of Norwich but he he has a very similar book to you know what I'm going to lock in my recommendation here that there's that film which is fine but I'm going to recommend aitz by WGC bold which is a very good book better than rings of Saturn fight me UEA students of the world it's a book about someone investigating the life story of their friend who's an an art historian who's simply known as Al it and sort of going through the various places that they've lived and sort of locals and how that factors into their sort of life story oritz is a holocaust Survivor as well so you have a sort of tie into the sort of Benin connection and there's there's a bit of sort of I I think he's sort of into mysticism very vaguely but he's also into sort of collecting things he collects I think it's like moths insects something like that but yeah it's this sort of idea of a life sort of being sort of assemblages of various things and that's sort of speaking to various aspects of an age but it's a very good book you can find it relatively cheap in used bookshops uh because it sold it won a prize I think so it sold a lot of copies uh rings of Saturn a lot more expensive and worse in my opinion well Hannah an imedia connection I was trying to think but I don't know I what's your favorite film where someone walks around a lot I was thinking 28 Days Later you know what that's a shout is that where somebody was around the yeah whole like whole like first half hour of that is just lad's walking about for some reason I was like she's going to say Forest Gump no no no and when when we were talking about people walking around I was like should they say 28 Days Later is that stupid no yeah there we go yeah listen Matt has encyclopedic knowledge of the most random films you've ever heard of I know some films and then you make up the rest baby girl yeah yeah but 28 Days Later by the way everybody should go watch that CU that is a good movie that they they'll probably be put get back in cinemas um relative cuz there's the new one coming out that's like filmed on an iPhone sick yeah it was like an iPhone Pro 15 or something like that we should have more films like that I love a film where somebody what's it called where they're like are you talking about like the Cloverfield thing yes yeah love found footage yeah yeah cloverfield's great what's the famous One whe they in the woods BL witch yeah love that as well Han refuses to watch black and white film because she says it's old but absolutely devours anything shot on an iPhone if you sent me found footage films I would watch them all because I love them I do do you want to know what the best found footage film is okay it's called Lake [ __ ] it's on Amazon at the moment um I think in preparation for Halloween uh it's absolutely horrifying it's kind of it's about a teenage girl goes missing and is is sort of I think found dead but it's discovered that the week sort of in in the weeks leading up to her death something sort of happened to her that really sort of spooked her out I I won't spoil it but it's a pseudo documentary investigating sort of what happened to her I love it but it's it's really horrifying there are some very good Japanese ones as well Koji Shiri is a director you should look out for he did one called noroy The Curse I think I've seen this yeah he did one called noro The Curse which everyone thinks is brilliant he did one called ult is the one I'm thinking of yes um he did one called ult and he did one called cult I don't know what cult's like but ult everyone thinks is like really horrifying and then literally the last 15 seconds is like completely divides people on the film okay largely because of the quality of the special effects it's going to be kind of difficult to get my partner into this yeah he's not gonna like this but all of that I mean I highly doubt this is staying in but uh the oh you really don't know us okay but um podcasts are mostly for recommending films for people to watch really um but yes the the other not that I want to promote any competition but the reason I know anything about found footage films is a wonderful podcast by uh sha McAn at noorus on Twitter and that box who did a podcast where he watched 30 found footage horror films one every day in the month of October and basically gave himself PTSD um and that is called hundreds of pixelated dead bodies uh you can find it on Spotify it will be under the heading of a podcast called SF Ultra but that's fine scroll down a bit uh but yes that that that is a wonderful podcast if you want us to get into found footage horror it's amazing how you are so good at promoting other people's work and not yours no it's it's it's because the fundamental issue there is what I think has worth and and and value and is worth promoting that you have value and you are worth promoting I don't have a podcast no but you do have a Twitter yes I do have a Twitter uh it is at matt2 pgr Bliss on on Twitter Z me on zitter and with that Z me on zit enough and with that I guess we have to say goodbye okay bye bye thank you so much for listening to the is we really appreciate it and would love to hear your thoughts check out our Instagram Facebook Tik Tok and Twitter @ theore your pod for upto-date information and please rate follow and leave a review wherever you're listening to the podcast if you're interested in finding anything we have mentioned in the episode please check our show notes or description to find more details you can also contact us at Theory ISP podcast gmail.com see you next time goodbye [Music]
Up Next

The Arcades of Paris: Walter Benjamin on Urban Politics & Philosophy
@internationalcentreforcont7204
2.3K views•2013-06-19

Princeton IV 2024 Finals | Debate on Duties to the Dead
@PrincetonDebatePanel
4.4K views•2024-09-29

Should We Destroy the Machines? Big Tech Surveillance Critique
@TheStoriesWeTell303
167.9K views•2025-11-30

The Myth of Sisyphus: A Greek Legend of Eternal Punishment
@TEDEd
8.6M views•2018-11-13
Related Study Plans & Knowledge Roadmaps
Structured learning paths in Philosophy





























