Civil-Military Relations in Lithuania: Smetona Era 1926-1940 | Academic Lecture

Added:

The Defensive Modernization and National Stabilization Perspective

An alternative perspective in Lithuanian historiography argues that the 1926 coup and the subsequent Smetona regime were necessary measures to safeguard national sovereignty against external threats and internal instability. Proponents of this view contend that the fragile parliamentary system of the 1920s left Lithuania vulnerable to Polish expansionism, German pressure, and Soviet subversion. Under Smetona's authoritarian guidance, the state achieved remarkable socio-economic stability, fostered a strong national identity, and significantly modernized its armed forces. Rather than viewing the military merely as a politicized tool of regime survival, this perspective highlights the high level of professionalization, discipline, and patriotic education within the interwar Lithuanian Army. Consequently, the ultimate decision not to resist the Soviet occupation in 1940 is interpreted not as a failure of civil-military relations or military decay under Smetona, but as a pragmatic, albeit tragic, calculation in the face of complete geopolitical isolation and overwhelming foreign force.

Fundamentals of Civil-Military Relations: Understanding the theories of civilian control of the military, military autonomy, and the risks of military politicization.
Post-WWI Baltic Geopolitics: The establishment of Lithuanian independence in 1918, the Vilnius dispute with Poland, and the challenges faced by its early parliamentary republic.
The Rise of European Authoritarianism: The broader geopolitical context of the 1920s and 1930s, where democratic systems across Europe collapsed into nationalist or authoritarian regimes.
The Anatomy of a Coup d'État: Theoretical frameworks explaining why militaries intervene in domestic politics and the conditions under which they overthrow constitutional governments.
The 1940 Soviet Ultimatum and Occupation: Analyzing how Smetona's authoritarian governance and military policies influenced Lithuania's decision not to armedly resist the Soviet annexation.
Comparative Baltic Authoritarianism: Comparing Smetona's regime in Lithuania with the authoritarian systems of Kārlis Ulmanis in Latvia and Konstantin Päts in Estonia.
The Forest Brothers and Guerilla Warfare (1944–1953): Studying the transition from formal state defense to asymmetric partisan resistance against Soviet re-occupation.
Modern Lithuanian Defense Policy and NATO Standards: Examining how post-1990 Lithuania structured its democratic civil-military relations and integrated into Euro-Atlantic security frameworks.
157 views6likes1:10:07@nationalfoundation7227Original Release: 2024-09-26

This lecture examines how conservative realism in military thinking, combined with weak democratic institutions and external threats, led to military intervention in Lithuania's interwar period, resulting in the 1926 coup that established authoritarian rule under President Antanas Smetona, which ultimately weakened the military's effectiveness and contributed to Lithuania's vulnerability during the Soviet occupation in 1940.