Ethics Since Logical Positivism | History of Philosophy 79

Added:

The Neo-Aristotelian Critique and the Revival of Virtue Ethics

While the trajectory of post-positivist ethics focused on analyzing moral language (meta-ethics) and constructing abstract normative systems, a powerful counterpoint arose in the mid-to-late 20th century through the revival of virtue ethics, spearheaded by G.E.M. Anscombe and Alasdair MacIntyre. In his landmark work 'After Virtue' (1981), MacIntyre argued that the debate between emotivism, prescriptivism, and modern normative frameworks was not progress, but a symptom of the fragmentation of moral discourse. He asserted that the Enlightenment's rejection of teleology (human purpose) left moral language incoherent, reducing ethical arguments to mere assertions of personal preference disguised as objective claims. Instead of attempting to salvage morality through linguistic analysis or abstract rule-making (like utilitarianism or deontology), this critique argues that ethics can only be rescued by returning to an Aristotelian framework. This approach shifts the focus from 'what rules should we follow?' to 'what kind of person should we become?', emphasizing character, community, and teleology over logical-linguistic analysis.

Understanding of Logical Positivism and the Verification Principle, particularly how it defines meaningful statements.
The distinction between Meta-ethics (the nature of moral language) and Normative Ethics (the study of moral action).
David Hume’s 'Is-Ought' problem (the fact-value distinction) and its influence on 20th-century philosophy.
Familiarity with classical ethical frameworks such as Utilitarianism, Deontology, and Virtue Ethics.
The revival of substantive Normative Ethics, exemplified by John Rawls's seminal work 'A Theory of Justice' (1971).
Modern Moral Realism and Cognitivism, which argue against emotivism by asserting that moral statements can be objectively true or false.
The mid-20th-century resurgence of Virtue Ethics, pioneered by thinkers like G.E.M. Anscombe and Philippa Foot.
The development of Applied Ethics in the late 20th century, addressing concrete moral dilemmas in medicine, technology, and the environment.
20K views192likes1:04:38@wheatoncollegeOriginal Release: 2015-06-16

Since the decline of logical positivism's emotivist theory of ethics, which claimed moral judgments are merely emotive expressions without cognitive meaning, philosophers have developed multiple competing approaches to understanding moral language and obligation: (1) Prescriptivism (R.M. Hare) analyzes moral language as imperative rather than descriptive, arguing moral assertions function as commands rather than factual descriptions; (2) Descriptivism (John Searle) shows how moral obligations can emerge from empirical facts through careful description of speech acts like promising; (3) Divine command theory (Robert Adams, Elizabeth Anscombe) argues moral terms gain meaning by referencing God's commands, providing a basis for moral law that avoids the positivist critique; (4) Contractarianism (John Rawls) proposes morality rests on social agreement behind a veil of ignorance, establishing principles of equitable distribution favoring the least advantaged; (5) Virtue ethics (Alasdair MacIntyre) traces ethics back to ancient traditions emphasizing character cultivation over rule-governed decision-making, arguing different ethical traditions are incommensurable and require participation in specific moral communities.