Todd Haynes on Carol: Filmmaking Q&A with Wash Westmoreland

Added:

Critiques of 'Prestige' Queer Cinema and the Aestheticization of Desire

While Todd Haynes’ Carol is widely celebrated for its lush, mid-century aesthetic and formal elegance, some critics and queer theorists offer a counterpoint regarding the film’s sanitizing of lesbian desire and its departure from radical queer cinema. Critics argue that the film’s meticulous visual design—characterized by muted colors, shooting through windows, and classic Hollywood framing—creates an emotional and physical distance that intellectualizes the passion between the leads. Furthermore, scholars contrast Carol with Haynes’ early pioneering work in the 'New Queer Cinema' movement of the 1990s (such as Poison), suggesting that Carol represents a shift toward a 'safer,' more palatable, and highly aestheticized form of LGBTQ+ storytelling tailored for mainstream prestige audiences. This perspective argues that by focusing on affluent white protagonists and prioritizing historical nostalgia, the film dilutes the transgressive, politically urgent edge of queer cinema in favor of a romanticized, universalized melodrama.

Overview of Todd Haynes' directorial style and his prominent role in the New Queer Cinema movement of the 1990s.
Familiarity with the source novel, 'The Price of Salt' (later retitled 'Carol') by Patricia Highsmith, and its historical significance in 1950s LGBTQ+ literature.
Basic principles of literary adaptation in cinema, specifically how internal literary monologues are translated into visual and auditory film language.
Understanding of mid-century cinematic melodrama, particularly the visual style and themes of director Douglas Sirk, who heavily influenced Haynes.
In-depth analysis of the cinematography in 'Carol', specifically Edward Lachman's use of Super 16mm film, locations, and color palettes to reflect the characters' internal states.
A comparative study of other Patricia Highsmith film adaptations (e.g., 'Strangers on a Train', 'The Talented Mr. Ripley') to analyze different directorial approaches to her suspense and psychology.
Exploration of the 'queer gaze' in cinema theory, examining how camera angles, framing, and subjective viewpoints establish intimacy and power dynamics.
Investigation into the collaborative workflow between director, production designer, and costume designer in establishing a cohesive, historically accurate period aesthetic.
4.1K views68likes30:51@directorsguildofamericaDGAOriginal Release: 2016-01-12

In the film 'Carol,' director Todd Haynes and screenwriter Phyllis Nagy employed a sophisticated point-of-view structure that creates narrative ambiguity, allowing viewers to experience the story through multiple perspectives—primarily Therese's eyes while also entering Carol's world—rather than committing to a single protagonist's perspective. This approach was influenced by David Lean's 'Brief Encounter' and required Kate Blanchett to navigate multiple planes of access to her character, making her performance particularly remarkable. The film's visual aesthetic was developed through research into mid-century photojournalism and art photography, particularly the work of Saul Leiter, who captured scenes through dirty glass and reflections, creating an intimate texture that distinguishes the film from other period pieces.