Decentralized social networks like Farcaster aim to solve the centralization problems of Web2 platforms by ensuring that user-to-user relationships cannot be revoked by any third party and that developers have permanent access to the social graph, while still providing superior user experience through centralized clients built on top of the decentralized protocol.
Web3 Social Decentralization: Farcaster Co-Founder on Crypto Social Networks
Added:foreign [Music] welcome to Mint season six what's up man how are you doing thank you for being on well thanks for having me I'm uh I'm excited to have you on the podcast a lot is going on in the web 3 social space and what better person to talk to than the one uh who's building forecaster right I've been on farcaster a lot of people use fart Caster a lot of excitement across crypto Twitter that also now migrates to far caster and vice versa so a lot to talk about I want to start with you though okay who are you what does the world need to know about you um and more specifically how'd you get your start into crypto yeah so I think my background I'm originally from Massachusetts I went to school on the East Coast worked in Boston for a bit and then eventually moved to Silicon Valley I started on the operational side of things so didn't study something technical in undergrad I grew up kind of always with computers programming you know mucking around with the internals of stuff but for whatever reason didn't major in Indian college but when I moved out to Silicon Valley I had worked in Consulting so kind of got a job more on the operational side of things and I was working at a SAS company that does visitor sign-in software for iPads and I just kept hearing about Bitcoin from all of the smart people had started to meet in in the Bay Area and I realized I didn't have a my own point of view on it and actually if you back up when I first moved to Silicon Valley a college classmate of mine Fred ursulin one of the co-founders of coinbase heard that I was moving out reached out we got coffee mentioned they had just raised a series a for coinbase and we're looking to kind of hire out the first few employees and I categorically dismissed him thinking that Bitcoin was a Ponzi scheme why would you be spending your time why don't you work on a real-time company fast forward a year later I actually had read the white paper finally and couldn't stop thinking about Bitcoin and I think that the thing that got me most excited about Bitcoin in the kind of early days enough to make the switch over to coinbase was thinking about it as a Computing layer and kind of thinking about if you think about like Computing history you kind of go from mainframes to the kind of like okay PCS then you add the internet then you add mobile and then you start to go away from the local machine to the cloud and so each one of these new platforms offers really interesting opportunities for entrepreneurs and to build new products and experiences mobile being the most recent and in 2014 I thought okay Bitcoin is is clearly that next Computing platform right you can start to do new experiences that don't live within a centralized database and the first applications of that being money and payments and so I joined coinbase very much thinking it was going to be all about the new apps that we're going to be built on top of the coinbase API which ended up being wrong and I'm happy to talk through my experience at coinbase from what I learned there but so I kind of went in with a very naive point of view and then stuck around for five years and in many ways got lucky in the sense that the the market shifted and something like ethereum came along and the company did end up doing well but I always like to point out that I joined coinbase with the completely wrong thesis for what was going to be big uh at least for Bitcoin and I think we're finally actually starting to play out with some of the ideas that I originally were excited about in 24 but that's that's how I get started crypto what were some of those original ideas that now you're sort of seeing get played out right now well the the ideas that I I there was like one very concrete idea that I got excited about was prevention markets and there was a paper from the mercatus center I think Jerry Brito who now runs coin Center was still in Academia and he wrote it just talking about the history of of different prediction markets uh from a theoretical standpoint and I've always just found that to be fascinating I'm a bit of a political News Junkie and and so the idea that you could kind of use markets to predict elections better than polling is I've always found intellectually interesting and so that they talked about potentially using Bitcoin because one of the fundamental issues is in the U.S if you want to offer a prediction Market that's considered a derivative which is regulated by the cftc there's a notable example of a company that wanted to do a prediction Market specifically for uh Hollywood movies it's called Hollywood Exchange they raise a bunch of funding built out a product and they went to go launch this this product which essentially would allow you to vet on whether what the box office receipts for a movie would be and Hollywood crack down by doing a bunch of lobbying in DC which ultimately got the cftc to shut it down because they didn't want uh people to be betting especially insiders to be betting on whether a movie was going to flop or not because then you would start using that information as a consumer to potentially not go see that movie because it would be bad right which is kind of interesting if you think about it from a consumer benefits standpoint that Hollywood exchange would be great for Hollywood it would be bad in the sense that they couldn't really package up that movies and try to promote them uh but cfpc decided that that wasn't allowed and so that doesn't exist there's actually now an exchange in the kind of more fintech world that's not crypto related called the Kyle sheet and they are one of the first kind of more consumer oriented prediction markets that have found some amount of cftc approval or or at least the set of markets that they're doing um but I think that the other thing that I just generally got excited about in crypto is uh regulated markets are fine and if you know coinbase the experience I had there we did a lot with regulation and you have to get it right and and that actually ends up creating a lot of value for a business because not a lot of people want to do it some people call that regulatory capture but there's a there's a kind of aspect of the internet that I've always been interested in is permissionless innovation and I think the ethos of the internet is if you have a good idea you should in a computer and the capability to program something you should just be able to do it and with fintech it's it's much more okay if you can go convince people to raise money and then you can go build out like a special relationship with whether it's Banks or card processing companies and then you can put an API on top of that right a company like stripe or a company like plaid has done an excellent job at managing that and actually by virtue of them being very developer oriented have significantly increased the number of apps that exist uh in the world of fintech because each of those kind of apps that sit on top of a platter or a stripe they don't have to go do those relationships directly right but what's neat about crypto is there you don't even need the middlemen the apis and the data and the value are directly accessible to the end user as well as their and I think that that concept of of removing a huge chunk of um kind of like intermediaries is is just like a concept that I think is is really fascinating and frankly one of the most compelling reasons to work in technology for me is you can actually build these things on the internet that can exist as protocols that create coordination between humans but not necessarily any one individual or company so is that where social comes into the picture because of the things that you said that interest you you didn't bring up social media as like the keyword sort of within the entire that entire explanation and I'm curious like where does social fit into that vision of yours that exciting yeah I think um 2014 I wasn't thinking about social as a crypto thing in that uh a when when I first started at coinbase we were Bitcoin only and the push was payments which ended up again not not quite playing out and what coinbase ended up becoming is more of an investment platform but also a Gateway into being able to take Bitcoin or eth and then put it into whether it's defy or any kind of permissionlessly built out on top of these blockchains so that's an important function right it's not just purely Financial exposure but the in 2014 uh at least when I was joining coinbase I think that was right around when Twitter was was potentially hamstringing the API but prior to that Twitter it had a very open API and so you had a very diverse ecosystem of third-party clients I like to always point out that the pull the refresh the kind of universal of you know whether you're using a mail client today or Instagram to just refresh your feed that was invented by a third-party Indie developer Lauren Richter who had an app called Tweety which eventually ended up selling to Twitter and then Twitter technically owns the patent for pull the refresh and and they did something that's quite honorable they they kind of said hey we'll never prosecute anyone from using it but that was an ERA where I think that there was still a lot of Promise in social media as potentially this uh API driven yes there were going to be kind of first party clients but third-party clients there could be a diverse ecosystem especially for something like Twitter fast forward to 2022 I think we're in a far different state of the world related to social networks social media in that they are more centralized there are I think a stricter set of guidelines in terms of what's acceptable used versus not and I think in some ways there are some good aspects of that but at the same time I think it's kind of wild if you think about something like Twitter um you have a bunch of people in San Francisco making decisions on what is acceptable speech or right use for the entire world which is wild right right whereas something like the internet um again it's country by country but to me that's a much more credibly neutral platform in the sense that the US has strong Free Speech laws so if you maintain your own website and you don't follow a foul very limited set of things that would violate free speech that's on you and or you and your hosting provider right whereas if you live in another country that maybe has stricter limits on speech that that's your version of the internet but what's neat is uh it it kind of is global and you as an individual if you either get outside of your country or maybe have a pseudonymous way of publishing you really can get access to the direct level of the protocol whereas with these social networks you're much more limited in terms of where that company's leadership and jurisdiction is is for the company and then that kind of propagates out to the rest of the world and so I think where my thinking from 2014 to 2020 2022 era has changed is we've gotten significantly more centralized with social media and social networks they're significantly larger and more present in terms of just public discourse and I think we're starting to see the scenes uh where where they just they can't scale at this level and maintain some of the the core original promises that they have if you go back to the early uh product marketing for Twitter as they were very pro-free speech like that was actually their differentiator as hey Twitter is a place to be able to express what you think whether you're in the US or I don't know a country in the Middle East the the whole Arab Spring was a moment for Twitter at least in that moment and I think uh that's changed quite a bit and and the question is is like as Society should we have a neutral Public Square protocol that allows us to do some of the things that social centralized social media is significantly better than kind of open protocols right so the open protocols here via the web email RSS um but can you actually take some of the best aspects of centralized social media from the user ability standpoint discoverability and actually bring those into something that looks more credibly neutral like a more traditional Internet Protocol and so that that's the thing that I got excited about and why I'm working on it now interesting so I think we're seeing uh an increase of like Senate adoption across web 3 social applications whether it be from people trying to build applications to users trying to use these applications or creators trying to create content and monetize through these applications and I'm still trying to understand the space from like a macro lens I'm curious to hear your point of view what do you think is the current state of web through social we're early um I think there are a variety of different approaches they're probably more additional networks that pop up and people with different points of view on you on good things we are also in a slightly different situation compared to maybe some other technology Trends and that if you if you take the examples of Twitter and Facebook they were kind of in that first generation of of social media the web to uh social media boom and so a lot of the stuff was getting figured out for the first time for the most part because yeah you had some some earlier social networks for insta right Myspace but the the inflection point was really as as Society shifted over to mobile as being the dominant form factor that actually massively increases the amount of social media to use right rather than being something that oh I'm gonna sit on my computer and use Facebook versus being on the couch watching TV and also having Facebook open right um and so I think with web3 you're not in a situation where you're competing mostly against Greenfield like in that you're you're you are in a Greenfield situation you're you're competing against mature web to social networks for time spent right and so if you think about social the the it's a zero-sum game in that you only have a limited amount of time you can't spend time on two social networks at once so if you're spending it on one social network or watching Netflix that that's that's the trade-off and so I think web 3 social is is early days in terms of infrastructure development both the protocol layer as well as app development on top but also in the kind of figuring out what's the differentiator versus the mature options that basically everyone is already on right it's not like people are onboarding to social media for the first time with wet 3 social they're already on web 2 social media and if anything that's actually where you're finding a lot of those people as a developer of a web three you know social media product but the the the challenge is is okay I already have a big audience on what two social media I I have the Habit I've spent time curating my feed I like the algorithmic stuff that I'm getting maybe you don't um but to then actually get everything up and running in web3 that that that's that's where we really are right now can you actually offer something that is reasonably competitive such that someone is willing to trade off time spent over here in in web what three and and so that's actually something that we've been really focused on for the last two years is building the initial climate for forecast for the protocol because from our point of view the thing that's actually gonna Drive the most switching is you have to have a base level of feature parity right you can't say hey this is a really rough app but it's decentralized no no one's going to switch to that whereas if you can get a mobile app that from a performance standpoint feels pretty close maybe not quite there and then a sufficient number of kind of people that are interesting then you might start to get the early adopters who say oh this is actually kind of nice it's the spam Bots aren't here or I actually have more control over what I see in my feed but I think that's a pretty slow process right whereas maybe fast forward two or three years from now and you have a variety of attempts in web3 Social that have kind of gotten that first stage done you may start to see actually apps grow at a faster clip a more mainstream audience clip but I think where we are right now is in that kind of early early adopter deployment phase and then you have this kind of challenge of like okay well how do you cross that Chasm right but I actually think it's like you need to focus on the first phase first before you even worry about the things right I think there are a lot of people who when they think web3 social and I think nfts in a positive way kind of increase the aperture of what crypto can be for people rather than this kind of like very Finance quantitative numeric thing there's a visual element a very consumer element yes there's a financial element to it but I think as a result of that a lot of people especially with the kind of bull market of 2021 wanted to Proclaim okay this is crypto's mainstream moment and I can tell you having worked since 2014 people have been saying this is crypto's mainstream moment for way too long and I think I think it's just the wrong frame right I don't think we get to a sudden okay this is now mainstream right because I think the the analogies people like to use oh this is like 1993 and now we have Netscape that's going to kind of kick off this adoption the difference is there was no internet before whereas now with crypto it's a subset of the internet so inevitably like it isn't a step function of a change for a consumer if you just kind of the simple thing of okay I can get an Uber with Uber or someone goes build the centralized Uber you still get the Uber whereas pre-internet there was no Uber you know taxis or whatever but the the step function changes the zero to one and I think where crypto is always um fairly or unfairly compared is this I think that when people are being unreasonable they're trying to say it's a step function change but it's probably more incremental and I think that's even the wrong frame to be thinking about as an entrepreneur because I actually think what what's interesting is if you can just actually shift to say what new experiences or things that are fundamentally not possible in web 2 can you actually start to build and and so that that's one of the first principles in terms of building that we've approached with forecaster is use the amount of web 2 or web 3 as minimal as possible like the amount of stuff we put on chain is as you know small as possible and then leverage everything else from web2 that that's great in terms of usability and speed and all that and and see if you can actually start to get to a fundamentally new experience and in our case it's a it's a social network where the back end is truly a protocol and it's permissionless and then figure out okay how do you scale that from there without trying to say that everything is fundamentally better because to be totally Frank like it's not like our client for forecaster is like pretty good but it is not as good as something like Twitter yet and so there's a lot of work to do but I think that's okay because just like having an open brainstorm session I just reached I feel like a stage on Twitter I just crossed 10K followers okay and as a Creator as a content creator like that's that's like a pivotal moment for me and for many other creators right but I still like going to these other platforms because they act as pockets of information and they act as like pockets of like reset right like I feel like there's too much going on sometimes on these mainstream platforms whereas in these new social platforms it's like things are just like starting to cook up right like it's not there and the types of conversations you see having on those platforms are different than the conversations you have on the mainstream platforms right so I see from like an information pocket point of view right um another thing that's that's um that's super interesting is like I know you're big on on History right and also the way you speak I noticed like you reference a lot of like uh learning lessons and insights that you sort of developed and picked on uh picked up on like as you saw social media kind of develop I'm curious can you can you share more about like the history around the social graph right and if you build a web 3 social graph like what sort of problems are you aiming to fix right big picture um what did web 2 social graphs do wrong that you think yeah like these these more open permissionless protocols can do right yeah so I actually don't think there's a ton of great reading out there you kind of had to experience some of it and I was fortunate that I was not super old yet but I was in high school enough that I really got to see the full rise of of web 2 social media but the the kind of things to think about are you you have the kind of early version of the internet which is very much about read right so it's a kind of consuming information weather information sports scores stocks and then as the performance of browsers and Broadband connections you started to move to this kind of interactive model where uh you you could effectively use a web application as the in lieu of using desktop software right and as that happened you you had the kind of first wave of social networks Facebook in 2004 Twitter I think 2006 and a whole bunch of other ones that popped up but what's interesting is in that era the primary way of bootstrapping those social graphs outside of just people kind of friending each other on Facebook specifically because they went to school together so that was actually gated on email uh if you look at some of the the growth tactics this is what I've been told at least that Facebook used it was kind of the contact importer from your email address right it's like sign in with your Gmail or upload your your contact list and that in of itself kind of was able to create a pretty big graph and what's interesting about that is so let's say uh 10 of my friends had signed up for Facebook and I show up to Facebook because I was in their contact book Facebook actually had enough information to make a recommendation of here are some potential friends and I think there's the kind of apocryphal story of you know get to the 10 friends is the magic number and then a Facebook user became right so that that was the the Facebook implementation is gate on email based on school get concentration in those schools expand out to other schools and then eventually once you have all the college students in the U.S you can expand out for the rest of the world and the thing I always like to kind of point out is if you think about it Facebook stopped be stopped being cool the moment it stopped being only for colleges but because they had created such a high concentration of very engaged users at a I think a critical cool juncture for society right everyone younger than a college student thinks they're cool because they're in college and then people who are graduated from college obviously were back in college right and so at my theory on that is that that concentration of you know basically college students had this crazy Half-Life where even if college student engagement started to slowly decline on Facebook it didn't matter because the rest of the world wanted to kind of go after that original feel and then you eventually get to several billion people using I mean a phenomenal success from building a social graph Twitter a little different in that it was a little bit more SF Tech scene and the uh you know South by Southwest and and it kind of started actually as a slightly older platform relative to if you look at a lot of social networks you tend to be younger and the push with Twitter is if you actually look at it it just didn't grow that much in the scheme of things for the first five years and and really it's in only in the last five seven years that it that it's had um a significant like really big impact on society it really kind of run the 2016 election I think Twitter became a lot more mainstream um obviously always high status from the you know the hashtag or the app reply but in terms of Twitter being used as kind of this true internet Public Square I think 2016 and after that's that's where twenty you know Twitter and then part of it is the president was using Twitter directly right um and so I think that Network I don't have as much insight into exactly how the social graph developed but that said I also think one thing to think about with Twitter is Twitter is is not a social network for most people who use it I think you know on the order of 200 million people use Twitter every day what percentage of people are actually tweeting liking replying it's relatively small whereas I think most people use Twitter as an information feed and just simply a way to catch up on news whereas if you know you or I the way we use Twitter is this kind of intellectual you know thought leadership Network where you're meeting other like-minded people in your industry to kind of have a better perspective on whatever you're working on and that version of Twitter is what it started with but really has not expanded it didn't we didn't have 100 million people all of a sudden doing uh threats on Twitter right and so that's actually something that's influenced our thinking with forecaster is if you actually think of of the addressable Market that you have to go after in order to be something that's competitive with Twitter that that total number of users or the 200 million people using it every day that's a daunting number and feels like you can never get there but if you reframe it to say actually that the Twitter version that we're trying to compete with early on is go for the people who use Twitter as kind of this public intellectual social network right then that's a far smaller number and and it makes it more achievable right like you go from being barely any way that the percentage of the way they are too okay maybe you can get to like point one percent and you know then to point five percent one percent ten percent and so I think that is a way of reframing what we're going after and the other interesting thing about people uh who use Twitter as a social network is they're the ones who hit the problems the most right they post about you know metamask or the future of of crypto wallets and then they get all the the crypto spam responding to them right the I you take a lot of time to craft whether it's a thread or a post for your podcast and for whatever reason the algo is like oh you put a link we don't want you clicking on the link because that kicks you out of the app okay it gets down rated and so that is where I think the the opportunity for a new Social Network at least in the bootstrapping mechanism it's to go after the people that feel the acute pain points of Twitter but the challenge with those people and I think we've talked about this uh on on DM is you're trying to build an audience and so you're going to optimize for the platform where you feel like you're going to get the most reach and so for something like forecaster we're approaching it with this kind of very deliberate growth invite only only 3 000-ish people in in a beta it's gonna be hard to justify for you as a content Creator to say hey I'm going to spend more time on forecaster because I really want to build my audience if you feel like there's a there's more potential on either another three social network or realistically something like Twitter and it's actually an Insight that when we launched forecaster last year I onboarded a whole bunch of people that I would call are my Twitter friends and people in my Professional Network and they had talked a lot about you know for a long time about the need for a decentralized uh version of Twitter and so I started working on this thing I'm ready to onboard them they go through an onboarding with me they're really you know excited they're like wow this is actually pretty decent never come back and I reach out to them and ask why didn't you you come back you told me that you thought this is an important thing and whether they were willing to admit it or not I think I finally figured out and this is obvious in retrospect but I think you sometimes have to just go through the hard lesson of it sure is if you have 500 000 or 800 000 followers on Twitter and you have 80 followers on a Nason social network how are you going to justify spending the time on that Network out of just pure passion or interest but those people are busy so like of course they're gonna default to the thing that has because ultimately if you're playing this kind of public intellectual Social Network game right what you care about is meme propagation and I know right and so quantity does matter now I think one thing I would say is quality has been very hard to measure traditionally and I think one interesting thing about a decentralized social network that is crypto native like forecaster is one you cannot have a whole bunch of competing companies have full access to the entire data set right so one thing about Twitter like the proverbial fire hose I think that that's pretty limited and who has access to it I don't even know if they they even give access to it at this point but the idea is you can't actually do a full measure of the entire network you have to do sampling right right whereas with something like forecaster you can genuinely you can just actually index the entire network right and then what's interesting is you can also look at the on-chain activity and so you can actually use that on train activity in two ways I think is interesting is one you can quickly figure out if things look spammy right because it's very expensive to put you know high value nft or even you know five thousand dollars worth of ethereum into a whole bunch of addresses to kind of fake an account sure whereas contrast that to a Twitter account you know bot account where you know it's super easy a lot of times they just need a phone number which you can programmatically create with voice and and so I think that that becomes really interesting because you can actually start to measure the quality in by whatever metric you want of your audience in a way that in web 2 you get a little bit of it like Facebook can have some centralized reporting tools but it but it's it's pretty General and crude whereas I think this you get a lot more detail with with web3 and maybe it doesn't always sit the same maybe we get a little bit more privacy on chain in terms of what we're doing but I think it's it's an underexplored area and I think as we scale forecaster I do think people are going to build some interesting tools so that you have a much better understanding of your audience building on a you know decentralized crypto native Network like forecaster and yes your audience might only be 10 or one percent of your audience on Twitter but you have higher confidence that it's actually a higher value audience and an audience that might actually refer your podcast to another friend right and so so I I think that's like one element that we're trying to figure out because it's just going to be a really long time before we ever kind of reach the level of scale that web 2 social networks have I'm curious Dan because I'm trying to figure out like what does it mean to be a crypto native Creator let alone build an audience using like web3 Primitives right so one thing that I've been experimenting with is like giving out like nfts to my listeners as a way to kind of like prove their participation across Seasons right and over time like there's been thousands of nfts that have been minted and now I'm trying to use that information to create better content for them right by seeing like their their activity on chain right so that I can find better sponsors Etc find better guests so if I notice that a lot of people have been for example collecting music nfts that tells me I should be having more music nft related conversations if I see a lot of activity around like web3 social applications right um then I want to have more web 3 native social conversations right hence why I did like this this season on like web3 social media data like interoperability Etc right and I'm trying to figure out still like what does it mean to be a crypto native Creator and build an audience in web three right do you do you have any insight on that like do you have any opinions on that well I think you're you're on the frontier so you're what you're coming up with are from an idea standpoint is is the Innovation that you know enough people doing it you'll start start to come up with the new patterns that may be more crypto native or what three native and so one thing that you mentioned that I think is really interesting is you actually have insight into what your listeners assuming you kind of correlate listeners on a web 3 social network like forecaster or or other ones you can actually look at their own chain activity and then start to glean insights and say oh interesting um 100 people who are following me also have the new Reddit Avatar that's on on polygon I think and maybe I should actually reach out to Reddit and see if I can find the the lead engineer or product manager who did that product as a way for you to offer a more compelling interview that is really relevant to your audience or at least a portion of your audience and then that person might not have been interviewed before in terms of like a like a bigger podcast or other times to focus on a CEO or something like that right and so I think that those insights that you can start to permissionlessly get from from your audience may offer better tailored content for uh your your audience or like subset segments of your audience I also think that the uh concept of fandom is is I'm not nearly as deep as some of the other people in the space who are building dedicated companies to this but I just think it's a really interesting concept because if you take Kryptonite 3 and put it this up for as long as music has existed there's always been that kind of early fan hipster who finds a band really enjoys them when they're kind of under the radar and and you know really passionate about it the that early passion creates some Word of Mouth which creates more and then that Network effect right you can kind of model a bit like a social network gets big enough that the band becomes more mainstream which then brings even more people but the the original people who were early kind of get disaffected like oh I like them before they got big or they sold out or whatever and just the idea that there could be a proofable way not not even have a financial setup just a provable way to say oh I used to listen to X artists before they were right the classic hipster one and it's like okay we'll prove it like show me the music nft or you get to a level where every Spotify stream somehow is in a decentralized data structure we're ways away from that if that ever happens but you can generally understand the concept that provable skin in the game historical on kind of an immutable Ledger it starts to open up some new interesting experiences right right maybe those artists now can actually say hey yeah we're really big we do these big Stadium tours but every year we do a concert in New York City at Madison Square Garden for our original 50 000 fits right and for the rest of your life you have access to that concert that kind of seems interesting you can find someone like a web two person who hates web 3 is going to go oh wait well you could have had a fan club and then you could do fine yeah you could do that but I think like part of the beauty of web3 is it changes people uh kind of to think bigger or new paradigms and the ability to permissionlessly do that is pretty cool right imagine if you give a free concert to your original 10 000 fans don't even need to pay just show up to the door show me the nft that's it like no money exchange has just pure brand can't do that for the most probably like you'd have to maintain this list and well okay what happens when you want to switch providers whereas if it just lives on the blockchain it doesn't matter like that nft will exist and so let alone let alone try to get that information too like when a Creator Builds an audience on like a web 2 native platform there's only so much information that they can get access to right whereas in crypto when you're building these audiences using either tokens or or nfts whatever it may be right like that lives immutably like you can always go back to that record like one thing that I'm thinking like at some point as the podcast grows I can do some type of like David Letterman type of where I just like rent out an auditorium and everybody that's sort of collected my my early my early seasonal nfts they'll have access to watch like a live interview with us right um and experience that yeah I think uh I think it's really cool I'm also trying to think from like uh a monetization point of view I think we sort of maybe just skim the surface of what monetization looks like a lot of my bet is that all media will be tokenized to an extent right and and all media everything will be collectible to an extent to in some shape or form and what does that look like uh in terms of monetization so right now a lot of creators they measure success from like views on YouTube or subscribes right how does that look like in the context of web3 does that mean the number of of unique holders that you have at scale right does that mean like the number of primary and secondary sales you have like what what gets how do you measure the success of a Creator I don't know I'm thinking out loud over here but yeah well again I go back to this idea that I think web2 is very much about quantity everything is about scale like total number of users Cristiano Ronaldo has you know 100 million followers on Instagram or Kim Kardashian and and that's how you talk about it I think biology uh has come up kind of with this concept of like being able to measure a fan economy is is a far more interesting thing so fine Kim might have 100 million followers on Instagram but what is the GDP of the Kim Kardashian expanded universe right like if you kind of as a gimmick but right but people laugh at that right so he he was saying this a couple of years ago and now Kim Kardashian's potentially starting a private Equity Firm based on the fact that she's going to potentially be able to to use that distribution and so I think that what gets interesting is if you can actually take the distribution out of the silos like I have this many followers on YouTube I have this many followers on Twitter and you move it to kind of these these decentralized credibly neutral kind of core data structures where now the relationship is between the Creator the publisher whatever and and the the people who choose to follow them right and that is a actually it's an opt-in relationship right because the the person can always unfollow you it's not like you own that that follower forever right but the key is that no one can come in and say oh you know what terms of service violation we've decided that what you said here is no longer acceptable you've spent 10 years building an audience tough luck both right you get kicked off YouTube or Twitter there's no recourse there's no exit there's no oh take your followers here you go here all their emails now you can email them and so I think if you look at just the way web 2 social media is you as a Creator have to spend way more time of you either take the bet on these platforms will keep you forever probably fine uh or you do the extra effort of hey subscribe also sign up for my newsletter so I have a direct line of communication with you whereas fast forward if these web3 social protocols work you as a Creator you you just have a direct relationship you want to send them a podcast you want to send them a video you want to send them a cast can basically come through a variety of different clients applications channels but that that relationship is a single relationship and it belongs to the two people who've opted to be in it which I think is a pretty radical shift from what we've been used to in webto and that also means you have freedom of monetization right so I think the kind of idea space for monetization is just getting started not only because you have crypto with this kind of core Financial primitive and you can do things like nfts and D5 and the remix ability and composability of that but also just the idea that okay I can do a traditional subscription and maybe maybe it's not on train or maybe it's done through stripe and a traditional web 2 platform fine I I think the challenge is when you are reliant on platforms and in some cases platforms that are relying on other platforms with the example of like if you're on YouTube and then Apple iOS like there are two rent seeking platforms that want to take dollars before they even get to you right I think the most extreme example was I think meta Oculus they were trying to do a platform for that and then they had a like a Facebook like Horizons platform cut and I want to say if you did the thing on an iPhone it had like an iOS like it was just like Cuts all the way down right and what's great about web3 is like you can actually solidify through a cryptographic proof again the average user doesn't need to see this but from a developer standpoint that relationship between the Creator and a person In Their audience as well as what what also gets interesting audience to audience connections right and so that that's another interesting thing that that's hard to measure but if you think about it what if if you're Taylor Swift and you want your whole fan club Maybe Taylor Swift is big enough to have like a custom social app that people are willing to even show up to whereas most other artists or creators you're never going to have like a custom app that people are going to use they're they're basically their time spent is an Instagram their time spent as in in Twitter uh and so you kind of have to play the game there because that's where the attention is whereas I think with these kind of remixable composable Open Access social protocols I think there's a totally foreseeable future where for the three or five creators whether that's you know Video Creator or a music artist if I want to have a direct relationship with them I'm using one of these open protocols because it actually just does a lot of the plumbing for me and then there's probably some version of call it WordPress or whatever where you can kind of or Squarespace where you can basically as a Creator have a mobile app that the user is like oh great this is completely interoperable so when you post a video I can get it over here on Twitter the Twitter one if I want but if I really want to go deep with everyone else in the community I can use this token gated app that based on your show and I can get really really deep with other people who are members of the show and and we have seen this by the way with like the rise of discords is an indication that there is demand for this but Discord which look tremendous products and success in terms of just scale but it's imperfect in the sense that it's not really optimized for mobile it's it's a it's a gamer product at the end of the day right and so it's a very desktop heavy experience whereas if you think about it like when you as a as a Creator if you say hey I have a Discord and I have 10 000 people in my Discord you're just like another little icon in this whole long set of and then you know Discord controls and notifications and all the experience where you could imagine being if you know you're my favorite podcast producer I can actually now install your app which didn't take you a lot of effort in the scheme of things no different than a website because it's using these open protocols and now you get push notifications on my phone that are completely uh you know direct between you and and your audience uh and and whatever the experience right and so that that has a ways off and and maybe we don't get there I I'm a big believer that we will but I think you need to get the infrastructure in place first before entrepreneurs start to say oh this has become a commodity or this has become this kind of credibly neutral infrastructure that I know I can actually go build these apps for these different creators because this protocol is going to have some level of stability right and I think the example here is obviously email is an example of a protocol that if I really wanted to take the brain damage and go build my own email client right superhuman being the most recent yeah you can do it and and there's no you don't have to ask the email Consortium for permission if you understand SMTP and IMAP like it'll just work and and what actually even kind of neat is you can build an email client that works with Google and Google just because at least in the email World kind of has to support IMAP because it's kind of the de facto standard they don't even really get to say it's like oh wait so you're I can actually build on top of your back end and you did all the hard part and just build a better client which is what I think superhuman is today right like they don't even handle right the like low-level email Plumbing they're just an IMAP client or a deeper integration with Google sure but I think that that like becomes a pretty powerful thing where if more stuff in Social actually has that level of like permissionless Innovation and in the case of the building on Google that's not even permissionless it's like mostly permissionless right um I think you just yield a whole bunch of more interesting experiences which gets back to this monetization thing is I think we're just scratching the surface it's just to say oh well we'll have ad base we'll have uh subscriptions and then we'll have some amount of you know nfts I think it's you're just at the start it's like looking at the internet in 1994 and predicting all of the different business models and and new companies that have come out of it right right right one thing uh that fart Caster tends to be very public about in their branding and their image is that it's a sufficiently decentralized social network and I think when you when you come back to it you ask yourself like what does it mean to be sufficiently decentralized and I'm sure you get this question all the time I'm curious what is what is the answer to that like what is decentralized on farcaster how do you make decisions on what to decentralize um versus centralize like share with me your entire mental model about that so the way to think about how sufficiently and decentralized works is there's a spectrum between centralized and decentralized in terms of an application right right and in a centralized application most common example is a company runs a set of apis the company decides who uses those apis can revoke the API keys at any point and that's basically Twitter there is no adjudication process for getting back on Twitter Twitter doesn't want you on Twitter flock right same thing goes for the developer so Twitter has a bunch of apis uh in a prior era they were much more open they changed over time and so that is is very much the centralized approach other side of things uh decentralized right so something like SMTP for email uh git is another good example of one right like I can go build a competitor to GitHub and I don't have to ask GitHub for permission and it'll work out of the box because git is a decentralized protocol that does not have kind of like a corporate owner right but the the challenge when you start to get out on the decentralized side of things is the user experience tends to get very technical and uh way worse right you you just need to know how to do everything RSS is a good example of that right so to use RSS you need to know oh I need to have a feed reader and it's like oh I have a feed reader and and I need to keep all of my subscriptions in place and so the the protocol itself um tends to be the thing that is more decentralized and then the Spectrum in between is where you can get to something what we'd call sufficiently decentralized and so for our point of view rather than start with decentralize and work your way to centralization it's actually start with centralization and then work your way on the Spectrum to decentralization to the point where you can satisfy two conditions the first is in the case of a social network any user can have a direct relationship with another user and no one can take them away like that that away from them right so if you and I want to be connected there's no third party that can come in and say nope sorry sure you can't be connected the most extreme example of that obviously is if you have 100 million followers on Twitter or YouTube and the platform comes in and says sorry you don't have a relationship with those followers anymore so the the kind of user to user relationship or Creator to audience relationship that that is a core primitive in my view for what decentralization is and then the second thing is the access for developers right so if I want to go build on the the data set here and the apis there shouldn't be a single individual or company that can come around and say sorry terms of service change we're going to really actually advertising and sorry your app doesn't work anymore and so from our standpoint the way to accomplish that is the thing that needs to be decentralized is the effectively the identity which is two parts the first is an ID number right so every every person on social media is represented by an internal number in a database is just an ID one nice feature of that is on Twitter you can upgrade your username and you don't lose your followers right it's not like people were following Dan Romero before and when I switched to dwr I lost all of them it's because the way Twitter Maps follows is just to that ID number right and then the second thing is is the username which that is much more of a status symbol and a kind of uh like a your what represents how you interact on these networks and so if you can remove that from any corporate company in an API it allows uh any user to choose whatever client they want and not have to worry about lock-in or anything like that and I think an analogy here is uh Bitcoin and eth when you put it on a company like coinbase coinbase is a centralized company over here coinbase can choose to kick you off quite nice but when coinbase kicks you off coinbase you don't lose your Bitcoin or eth you we call it you know mandatory account closure that's what happens with coinbase for some compliance reason they don't take your money from you they say where do you want your money sent like we don't want to do business with you anymore but you as the user have the ability to exit and then interoperate with everything else in the ecosystem right it's not like special coinbase Bitcoin it's no it's like this is real Bitcoin and I can move that to FDX I can move it to a self-hosted wallet same thing goes for a social network so if in the totally centralized version you you get kicked off there is no ability to exit and then interoperate with the same graph uh you have to effectively re-rebuild it right another example of this and there's actually more relevant for social media is email so if I have a sub stack and for whatever reason I might not want to use sub stack anymore as a publisher or substack doesn't want to have host my content there is no confusion that the email subscriber list that I have belongs to me right and if I take that list and I move to a self-hosted option or a competing uh newsletter provider I'm I have under uninterrupted access to my subscribers that I worked hard to build that relationship with and so in our point of view that's the only thing you actually need to focus on the decentralization everything else you can actually have it be the primary way people deal with stuff is in a centralized client right and the the benefit you get from that is the centralized client is going to offer vastly Superior user experience because the economy is a scale that start to happen you probably have cloud-based services versus if you'd use the truly decentralized client where you have to host everything yourself you're now dealing with what happens when the you know my client goes down or the host doesn't work or I have to now upgrade it because there's like a vulnerability in the you know the node.js package that's in the open source software it like the user experience is significantly worse and that the the easy answer is why do most people use Gmail and they don't run their own mail server it's just because it just works it's easy right and and what's interesting about Gmail is you have a Gmail address that's not exit with interoperability if you have your own domain and you use G Suite you can move to a different host right because you on the domain you can just change where it's pointed but if you have a Gmail address and you get really attached to that Gmail address Gmail is not allowing you to move that to Yahoo and say okay well the Gmail address down below is this client over here generally I think Google's pretty good in that you can use other clients to sit on top of it but the relationship you do have with Gmail is they are looking at all your emails and Mining it for data right right for whatever advertising purposes they want to do that's that's part of it being free but I think that the the core of that sufficient decentralization is find the thing that you need to be able to get to be a decentralized point keep that decentralized and then let the market develop in a way that you're going to have centralized clients that people opt into and then people can choose more decentralized mm-hmm yeah I feel like Dan we need to have like a three hour long podcast episode because I've maybe asked three questions in this entire like 53 minutes and I'm impressed with how much you have to say around yeah but I wanna I wanna jump to some uh Community questions that we had to come across Twitter uh forecaster Etc okay um so this one comes uh from Martin okay how he sees how do you see clients uh for forecaster evolving Plus monetization plans in the future and we can even do this thing like fire rounds kind of thing yeah we have the initial client I think we've been building it for two years it's hit a certain level of Polish usability it's we have a mobile client desktop client so we've done a lot of work to kind of make it easy to onboard the forecast for the protocol everyone who onboards to so the company is named Merkel manufacturing forecasters the protocol anyone onboards to a Merkel manufacturing client has this really nice easy experience gets in now they're active on forecaster which now also means that they're an addressable user for anyone who wants to build within the forecaster ecosystem because now as a developer building a new client or experience I don't have to worry about going and convince someone to sign up for forecaster I already know that they're there I can actually just kind of focus on okay here are the active users let me let me try to Market my product or go to market in terms of that and by the way you can post in the feed and people will respond and you know that they're native forecaster users right so there's there's some built-in distribution there which as we add more users to the the protocol then the the distribution gets better the natural place for clients to start which which has already happened is simple view clients that are kind of just doing read-only operations right right so most of the apps have been built in the forecaster ecosystem today have been kind of read only where they index all the data or rely on a third-party indexer and then are able to show kind of a specialized View so an example of this is insta Caster chose all of the posts on farcaster that have an image in it pretty straightforward pretty interesting UI relatively easy to boot up but right now it doesn't have the ability to also use that client to then post back an image into our customer we've been doing a lot of upgrades to the underlying protocol over the last few months we're going to hopefully get there and offer a much easier way for a developer to actually now go from just read access to both read write and that right access is where I think you're going to start to see people do two things so the first is actually just okay I'm going to be a specialized client that does something really well I don't know maybe Services all the questions on forecast or all the recommendations and it shows it in a slightly different way and anytime you take an action there maybe you like something it kind of propagates back into the protocol and then it would reflect in that that kind of like feed experience for other users those are probably the easiest place to start because they they're smaller projects maybe you can do them over a weekend or a week and and you start from there I think that the longer term you'll have uh people building completely new social experiences and using forecaster to bootstrap the social graph and all of those interactions the likes the replies because it kind of get it out of the box for free but those are apps that probably need a larger number of people the more substantial apps probably start to exist when you have 10x or even 100x the number of users right so today we have about 3 000 people using forecaster private beta invite only been really deliberate about growth so maybe 10x or 100x from here thirty thousand three hundred thousand that's where you start to get developers who go okay maybe maybe it's actually worth me testing out this kind of weird social idea I have on on this network because that gets to them at least enough potential users that if you know you get 10 of them now you at least have an early user base that you can play around and as the the overall protocol grows I think that the the sophistication of the apps will get more and more sophisticated and I think the natural way to monetize for these different apps are is as the network gets more scale I think you're going to see naturally apps do free with ads or something but I do think in the early days and part of this might be a norm set by our client we plan to use subscriptions as the primary do monetization because we actually think it aligns the values that we are hoping to have in terms of what the network should be uh is this kind of a little bit more sophisticated Pro feeling Network versus lowest common denominator scale of maybe some of the web 2 social networks and the other nice thing is that it aligns how we built the product with what our users want versus how to get them to spend more time so they see more ads right so interesting every subscriber we have essentially you can think of it as like Amazon Prime where what what Amazon is constantly trying to do is they're trying to find other things that they can add to the prime bundle that make prime subscriptions that much more valuable to their subscribers right it's this kind of drive more value same thing for Netflix right Netflix is looking how can we add better and more interesting content for the same price that we're charging for people but that that is a fundamentally different model than something like Facebook and Twitter they have to keep users happy enough but there's always that kind of tension where they can dial up the amount of ads in the feed or just do whatever they want because they're ultimately focused on time spent a good example of this recently is Instagram because of tick tock is is pushing reels the revealed preference by the way is people love algo feeds despite what people complain but but the push is a result of you we're trying to actually compete in a zero-sum world of time spent between Tick Tock and Instagram and so doing the the kind of change is you're focused on what what gets our users to spend more time versus does is this actually what people want and it's it's a hard thing because again the reveal preferences people actually do like algo feeds but I would say it's a slightly different model for us in that you could imagine that the average person is spending 10 minutes a day on forecaster we may actually launch a feature that maybe it's algorithmic machine learning or just filters that allow people to be more efficient in finding whatever they're looking for in forecast for when they look at the feed that it reduces the time spent from 10 minutes to 9 minutes and 30 seconds in an Advertising based business probably not a good thing right because the amount of time you spend is probably how many correlates with how many ads you see whereas in a subscriber based business you could argue that that is actually providing more value to the customer because now what they got is they got 30 seconds back as a result of it being higher signal or or more efficient for them right so thinking of it as like a tool versus this kind of uh almost like competitors with television of like we just want you to spend time here and then look at a bunch of ads I think is a is uh something that we're going to try to experiment with but if it works I do think it sets and Ethos in the ecosystem at least for the early adopters and I think more Pro users the people who are using the network as this kind of public intellectual social network that I bet you if you could actually go back in time if Twitter could choose a different monetization path they probably would have done this instead of trying to kind of always be this Facebook that never has the same scale or the ability to do the targeting and I actually think their business would be in a fine place today compared to basically it's a it's a public company that has never made a single like the total cumulative amount of profit is negative is a public and part of that is also I think they're overstaffed there's like 8 000 people that work there um and you can't solve the this bamboo problem but part of that also might be a set of incentives is that you don't want top line numbers in an Advertising based business to go down maybe a little cynical on that but my point being is I think clients in a new ecosystem in 2022 may find success with with subscriptions uh thinking of themselves more as tools accessing this kind of public social network data set versus we need to kind of be this lock-in and everything needs to be in the mothership right um so that that's one way I'm thinking about it okay a couple more questions um how do we beat the Bots I tweeted this recently I think Twitter could do this tomorrow if they really wanted to just take the hit on their total number of users and I think we'll plan to do this with Merkel manufacturer's clients phone number uh credit card on file so so you know don't charge them but you know maybe do a one-time charge of one dollar so you have that yeah coinbase we asked for a passport so you could do another thing and it should just be a set of steps five steps to get verified and that's how you get a blue check not your celebrity or you work at some media organization or whatever or maybe you have two different types of checks right right but I bet you a ton of people would go through the the friction if they spend a lot of time on Twitter to get that check mark especially if you could say hey the algorithm will boost uh anyone who's verified and and explicitly we will not show replies from unverified people you can use Twitter as an unverified way like that's a consumption mechanism but if you want to participate in the conversation you need to go through a little bit about it okay so so to me that's what we do at local manufacturer and then you don't have Bots plus it costs money to register a forecaster username because there's a launch income right right are there uh Akil bvs asks are there any plans for incentives to build on top of forecaster to attract developers what sort of new apps with social Primitives Slash use cases do you think Builders can build well the second part of that question is the you know worlds or oyster if I if I get every new social app I would probably get the new primitive to go after because it's a lot easier to grow if you have a viral new primitive uh that said I think um incentives that's something that we've tried a little bit so we had a couple of people build early apps last uh like you know in the spring and we offered them kind of a one-time block grant no strings attached for the summer and just to kind of defray server costs and encourage them to keep building the apps that they were doing that worked pretty well so I think that we probably will do something along those lines I think what's important though is people show organic interest and there's no promises like oh if I build something you're going to give me a grant it's more of a you know know when you see a good faith effort which maybe doesn't scale but I think aligns you much more towards a organic Community versus a strictly paid for mercenary community so I think we want to avoid that that part but there's probably a pretty optimal trade-off and I think going back to the the ideas the one thing I think that I'm excited about is one primitive that every user on farcaster has a private key so it's the first Network that just by itself you signing up for forecast username you have a public and private key even something like signal you have to actually verify with the phone number and so you can imagine the amount of encrypted or zero knowledge if you want to get work able than the crypto side types of experiences that you can permissions to build as a developer knowing that every single user on forecaster in order for them to even be on forecaster have to have a private key that's that's hot right live I think is a an idea space that someone will build something really interesting and to use a framework that I think a lot of people talk about generally social networks that succeed offer some new type of speech or new primitive that enables people to communicate in a new way and I think that entire space of of new encrypted experiences and new zero knowledge experiences is completely under tapped partially because the it's Cutting Edge technology right like you have to really understand it it has not been there's no Ruby on Rails equivalent for ZK yet and and so I think it'll take some time for that to happen got it um we're we're way over but I appreciate you seeing a little bit longer Dan Before I Let You Go um how do we get a forecast uh forecaster invite if if those listening want to join and uh where can we find you yeah so if you've made it this far that's proof of work proof is work enough that if you DM me on Twitter dwr and mention you heard the podcast I'm happy to send you an invite uh I think we're really trying to be deliberate on people who are thoughtful and optimistic energetic and if you're spending time listening to a podcast someone talking about what through social you're probably a good candidate cool cool thank you so much we'll have to do this again soon but uh yeah until next time cheers
Up Next

Workplace Trust Building Communication Training Webinar
@CiMH2125
160 views•2013-10-07

How a College Dropout Built Two Companies Through Freedom and Health
@liampingree
155 views•2025-06-16

Decoy Effect: How Pricing Psychology Influences Consumer Spending
@bobinvestsUS
90K views•2026-01-05

The Planned Obsolescence of Light Bulbs and Tech
@veritasium
25.3M views•2021-03-26
Related Study Plans & Knowledge Roadmaps
Structured learning paths in Business






