Social Justice in European Constitutional Courts | Jasna Omejec

Added:

Democratic Constitutionalism and the Critique of Judicialized Social Rights

While proponents argue that constitutional courts must protect social rights to ensure human dignity, critics from the school of democratic constitutionalism raise significant concerns regarding judicial overreach and the 'countermajoritarian difficulty.' This alternative perspective argues that social and economic rights—such as those concerning healthcare, housing, and welfare—inherently involve complex budgetary decisions and resource allocation. Critics, including legal scholars like Jeremy Waldron, assert that these policy-driven choices are the rightful domain of democratically elected legislatures rather than unelected judges. From this viewpoint, when constitutional courts dictate social policy under the guise of fundamental rights, they undermine the separation of powers, preempt democratic debate, and infringe upon the sovereignty of voters who should decide how public resources are distributed.

The distinction between first-generation (civil and political) and second-generation (economic, social, and cultural) human rights.
The European model of constitutional review (Kelsenian model) and how constitutional courts operate independently of ordinary courts.
The concept of 'human dignity' as a foundational legal principle in post-WWII European constitutionalism.
The role and advisory function of the Venice Commission (the Council of Europe's advisory body on constitutional matters).
Analyzing landmark case law on austerity measures and social rights from courts like the Portuguese Constitutional Court or the German Federal Constitutional Court.
Comparative study of socio-economic rights adjudication between European courts and non-European systems (e.g., the Constitutional Court of South Africa).
The debate over judicial activism versus judicial restraint regarding budgetary decisions and social policy distribution.
Exploring the relationship between the European Social Charter, the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), and national constitutional jurisdictions.
180 views1likes15:57@المنتدىالبرلمانيللعدالةالاجتماOriginal Release: 2016-02-20

Constitutional courts in Europe must balance the principle of social justice with democratic governance by applying the principle of proportionality, ensuring that while social rights are constitutionally protected, courts cannot directly restrict fundamental rights or substitute their own policy judgments for parliamentary decisions, thereby preserving the separation of powers and democratic accountability in social policy implementation.