Bertrand Russell's Theory of Descriptions Explained

Added:

P.F. Strawson's Theory of Presupposition

In his 1950 paper "On Referring," P.F. Strawson presented a major challenge to Bertrand Russell's Theory of Descriptions. Russell argued that sentences with empty definite descriptions (such as "The present King of France is bald") are false because they assert an existence that does not obtain. Strawson argued that Russell failed to distinguish between a sentence and the actual use of a sentence. According to Strawson, referring is a speech act, not a logical assertion of existence. When we use a definite description, we do not assert that the object exists; rather, we presuppose its existence. If this presupposition is violated (e.g., there is no King of France), the statement is not false, but rather lacks a truth-value entirely (a truth-value gap). This perspective shifted focus from purely formal logic to how language is used in context, laying the groundwork for modern linguistic pragmatics.

Basic first-order predicate logic, including the use of quantifiers (existential and universal), variables, and constants.
Gottlob Frege's distinction between 'Sense' (Sinn) and 'Reference' (Bedeutung) regarding proper names and identity statements.
Alexius Meinong's theory of objects, particularly the concept that non-existent objects (like 'the golden mountain') must have some form of being to be spoken about.
The fundamental philosophical problem of empty names and how language can meaningfully refer to things that do not exist.
Peter Strawson's critique of Russell in his seminal paper 'On Referring' (1950), which introduces the concept of presupposition.
Keith Donnellan's distinction between the 'referential' and 'attributive' uses of definite descriptions.
Saul Kripke's lectures in 'Naming and Necessity' (1972) and his critique of descriptivism in favor of rigid designators and direct reference.
The application of formal semantics in modern linguistics and computer science for parsing natural language queries and handling database null values.
43.7K views2.8Klikes20:57@profjeffreykaplanOriginal Release: 2026-01-19

Bertrand Russell's 1919 theory of descriptions proposes that definite descriptions (phrases beginning with 'the') do not function as referring expressions but instead express complex logical claims consisting of three components: existence (at least one thing satisfies the description), uniqueness (no more than one thing satisfies it), and predication (the described thing has a certain property). For example, 'The author of Waverly was Scotch' is analyzed as 'There exists an author of Waverly, there is at most one author of Waverly, and whoever authored Waverly was Scotch.' This theory resolves puzzles about meaningful sentences containing non-existent objects (like 'The golden mountain is tall') by showing they are false because the existence claim fails, while remaining meaningful because they express coherent logical propositions.