Timothy O'Connor on Libertarian Free Will & Agent Causation

Added:

Event-Causal Libertarianism

While Timothy O'Connor defends agent causation—the idea that agents themselves, rather than prior events, initiate free actions—event-causal libertarians like Robert Kane argue that this metaphysical framework is both unnecessary and obscure. Event-causal libertarianism proposes that free will can be fully explained within a standard physicalist framework where actions are caused by prior mental events (such as desires and beliefs) in an indeterministic manner. According to Kane, free will is exercised during 'Self-Forming Actions' (SFAs), where indeterministic brain processes during moments of conflict allow for multiple possible outcomes. Critics of O'Connor argue that agent causation introduces an 'extravagant' and scientifically problematic category of causation that cannot be reconciled with modern naturalism. By keeping causation strictly event-based, event-causal libertarianism attempts to preserve genuine free will and alternative possibilities without invoking what many philosophers view as an inexplicable, near-supernatural power of the self.

The metaphysical concept of Determinism versus Indeterminism and how they relate to human agency.
The basic taxonomy of the free will debate, specifically the divide between Compatibilism and Incompatibilism.
The standard model of Event Causation, where physical events are causally determined by prior physical events.
An introductory understanding of Metaphysical Libertarianism as the view that free will exists and is incompatible with determinism.
Common objections to Agent Causation, such as the 'randomness/luck objection' and the difficulty of reconciling it with modern physics.
Robert Kane's Event-Causal Libertarianism, which serves as the primary alternative to O'Connor's agent-causal view.
The concept of Emergentism in the philosophy of mind, specifically how O'Connor argues that agent-causal capacities emerge from complex physical systems.
The implications of Agent Causation on theories of moral responsibility, desert, and the justification of legal punishment.
1.6K views33likes12:52@GordonPettitOriginal Release: 2021-01-15

Timothy O'Connor's libertarianism proposes that humans possess special 'volition-enabling' properties that allow them to directly bring about causal effects, unlike inanimate objects whose causal powers are determined by their properties; this agent causation operates through emergent properties that enable free action while remaining consistent with materialism and contemporary science.