Free Will Explained: A Philosophical Defense Against Determinism

Added:

Hard Incompatibilism and the Illusion of Free Will

In contrast to libertarian free will, hard incompatibilism posits that free will is incompatible with both determinism and indeterminism. Advocates, such as Derk Pereboom and Sam Harris, argue that if our actions are fully determined by prior causes, we lack the ultimate control necessary for moral responsibility. Conversely, if our actions are the result of random, uncaused occurrences, they are merely chaotic and still outside our conscious control. Critics of libertarian theories argue that inserting indeterminism into the causal chain does not grant agency; it merely introduces randomness, which is just as inimical to free will as determinism. Furthermore, advances in neuroscience suggest that conscious decisions are preceded by unconscious brain activity, casting doubt on conscious authorship. Under this view, human behavior is the product of biology, physics, and environmental conditioning, rendering the traditional concept of free will an illusion.

Understanding the core definition of Hard Determinism: The philosophical view that all events, including human actions, are ultimately determined by causes external to the will.
Familiarity with the Free Will Taxonomy: Distinguishing between Compatibilism (the belief that free will and determinism are mutually compatible) and Incompatibilism (the belief that they are irreconcilable).
Basic knowledge of Libertarianism in philosophy: The metaphysical position that humans possess free will, that determinism is false, and that agents have the power to choose otherwise.
Awareness of modern skeptical arguments against free will: Familiarity with the deterministic arguments often presented in contemporary philosophy and public debate, such as those by Alex O'Connor (CosmicSkeptic) regarding the impossibility of ultimate moral responsibility.
In-depth analysis of Event-Causal Libertarianism: Exploring how indeterminism at the level of neural events can allow for free choices without reducing actions to mere random chance (e.g., Robert Kane's 'Self-Forming Actions').
Comparison with Agent-Causal Libertarianism: Investigating alternative libertarian models where the agent as a substance, rather than preceding mental events, initiates new causal chains.
Implications for Moral Responsibility and Criminal Justice: Evaluating how accepting an event-causal libertarian view alters or justifies concepts of praise, blame, punishment, and rehabilitation in the legal system.
The intersection of Quantum Mechanics and Metaphysics: Exploring whether physical indeterminism at the quantum level provides a plausible scientific basis for philosophical theories of free will.
120.1K views3.9Klikes59:56@drnathanhawkinsOriginal Release: 2024-07-08

Free will exists according to an event-causal libertarian theory, which holds that our decisions are not causally determined by past events but can still be rationally explained by the reasons we choose to act upon; this theory accommodates both the 'could have done otherwise' and 'source' conceptions of free will by distinguishing between the rational explanation provided by chosen reasons and the non-rational choice aspect of decisions themselves, thereby resolving the apparent tension between determinism and free will.