Compatibilism Explained: Free Will in a Deterministic World

Added:

Incompatibilism (Hard Determinism and Libertarianism)

Incompatibilism is the philosophical position that free will and determinism are fundamentally irreconcilable. It argues that compatibilism redefines 'free will' in a superficial way to avoid the core conflict. Incompatibilism splits into two primary schools of thought: Hard Determinism and Libertarianism. Hard determinists accept that the universe is deterministic and therefore conclude that genuine free will is an illusion, meaning individuals cannot be held morally responsible in the ultimate sense. Conversely, Libertarians argue that human agents possess genuine free will, which implies that determinism must be false and that we have the power to choose otherwise under identical circumstances. Critics of compatibilism, including philosophers like Immanuel Kant (who called it a 'wretched subterfuge'), argue that compatibilism merely describes voluntary action under constraint rather than the true, metaphysical freedom required for moral responsibility.

The basic philosophical definition of free will and its historical significance in ethics.
The concept of determinism, specifically physical or causal determinism, which posits that every event is necessitated by antecedent events and laws of nature.
The core tenets of Incompatibilism, including Hard Determinism and Libertarian Free Will.
The 'Principle of Alternate Possibilities' (PAP), which states that a person is morally responsible for what they have done only if they could have done otherwise.
The debate on moral responsibility, particularly P.F. Strawson's theory of 'reactive attitudes' and how it shifts the focus of the free will debate.
John Martin Fischer's 'Semicompatibilism', which argues that moral responsibility is compatible with determinism even if freedom to do otherwise is not.
Neuroscientific challenges to free will, such as the Libet experiments, and how compatibilists respond to empirical evidence.
The implications of compatibilism on the legal system, specifically regarding criminal responsibility, retribution, and rehabilitation.
1.7M views35.3Klikes8:55@crashcourseOriginal Release: 2016-08-22

Compatibilism is a philosophical position that reconciles free will with determinism by defining free actions as those that are self-determined—caused by internal factors within the agent rather than external forces—allowing for moral responsibility based on the degree of control individuals have over their actions, as demonstrated through Frankfurt Cases and Patricia Churchland's emphasis on control levels rather than strict free-or-not-free dichotomies.