Migration Policy in Divided Times: A New Vision | Christian Joppke

Added:

Postnational Citizenship and Transnationalism

An important counterpoint to Christian Joppke’s focus on 'neoliberal nationalism' is the theory of 'postnational citizenship,' pioneered by scholars like Yasemin Soysal. While Joppke emphasizes the resilience of the nation-state in regulating migration through a fusion of economic utility and cultural nationalism, postnationalism argues that the traditional authority of the nation-state is increasingly constrained. According to this perspective, migration policy and immigrant rights are increasingly shaped by universal human rights frameworks, transnational legal norms, and supranational courts rather than unilateral national sovereignty. Rights have become detached from specific national identities and are instead anchored in global personhood. Furthermore, transnationalism highlights how migrants maintain fluid, multi-layered identities and networks that span multiple countries, directly challenging the state's capacity to enforce singular civic or cultural integration. This school of thought suggests that rather than a successful nationalist retrenchment, migration is driving a structural shift toward a globalized, postnational regime where the nation-state's capacity to define belonging is fundamentally contested.

Understanding the core tenets of neoliberalism, particularly its emphasis on free-market capitalism, deregulation, and the global flow of labor.
Familiarity with the political rise of modern nationalism and populism, especially in Western democracies.
Basic knowledge of international migration systems, including the distinction between economic migration, asylum-seeking, and family reunification.
An introduction to the political economy of immigration, specifically how states balance domestic labor market demands with border control.
Comparative analysis of how 'neoliberal nationalism' is applied in specific regional contexts, such as post-Brexit UK, the EU, or the United States.
In-depth study of civic integration policies and the evolution of citizenship laws in multicultural societies.
Exploration of political philosophy regarding the ethics of borders, sovereign rights, and global justice.
Evaluation of contemporary policy proposals that aim to reform immigration systems to satisfy both economic needs and populist concerns.
126 views1likes58:38@MHLWchannelOriginal Release: 2026-03-09

Contemporary migration policy has fundamentally shifted from treating economic utility and cultural identity as separate selection criteria to a fused approach where states select migrants based on a combination of both factors, creating what scholars call 'neoliberal nationalism.' This new paradigm prioritizes 'worker citizens'—productive, economically useful individuals—over traditional citizenship distinctions, affecting labor migration (favoring high-skilled migrants), family migration (restricting it as a cost factor), and asylum migration (economizing it through 'good prospect to remain' policies). The policy represents a departure from both civic and ethnic nationalism, instead creating a 'community of the thrifty' that blurs the boundaries between citizens and immigrants.