Cooperative Federalism: India Governance Forum 2022

Added:

Coercive Federalism and Fiscal Centralization

While cooperative federalism envisions a harmonious partnership between India's central and state governments, critics argue that Indian governance has increasingly shifted toward "coercive federalism." This perspective contends that structural reforms, particularly the Goods and Services Tax (GST), have stripped states of their fiscal autonomy, leaving them highly dependent on central devolutions and vulnerable to delayed compensations. Opponents argue that the central government uses financial leverage, such as discretionary grants and Centrally Sponsored Schemes, to impose national agendas on state subjects like health and education. Additionally, the unilateral decision-making on critical issues and the perceived partisan use of federal institutions (such as Governors and central investigative agencies) are cited as evidence of centralization. Rather than a cooperative partnership, this counter-perspective views India's federal structure as highly asymmetric, where the central government increasingly consolidates power, relegating states to administrative implementers rather than equal policy-making partners.

The constitutional division of power in India, specifically the Seventh Schedule which delineates the Union, State, and Concurrent lists.
The fundamentals of Fiscal Federalism, including the mechanism of tax sharing between the Central and State governments.
An introductory understanding of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) and the structure of the GST Council as a cooperative decision-making body.
The role and functions of the Finance Commission of India under Article 280 of the Constitution in recommending the devolution of financial resources.
Analysis of modern conflicts in Center-State relations, such as the controversies surrounding GST compensation dues and the distribution of cesses and surcharges.
A deep-dive study into the reports and structural recommendations of the 15th and upcoming 16th Finance Commissions of India.
The concept of 'Competitive Federalism' and how Indian states compete for investments and rankings, analyzed alongside cooperative frameworks.
Critical evaluation of local governance financial autonomy, specifically looking at fiscal devolution to the third tier of government (Panchayats and Municipalities).
1.4K views6likes1:40:20@SKOCHTVOriginal Release: 2022-05-15

Cooperative federalism in India requires effective institutional mechanisms to facilitate coordination between the central and state governments, as the current system faces challenges including declining divisible pool of taxes, inadequate intergovernmental coordination institutions, and a tendency toward centralization that undermines genuine federal cooperation; successful federal arrangements require continuous dialogue, appropriate fiscal arrangements, and robust local governance structures to address regional disparities and promote effective policy implementation.