How Indonesia Ended Military Rule in Politics | CNA Insight

Added:

The Persistence of Military Influence and Incomplete Democratization

While the mainstream narrative celebrates Indonesia's transition to democracy and the official abolishment of the military's dual-function (dwifungsi) role, many political scientists argue that military reform remains deeply incomplete. Critics point out that the Indonesian Armed Forces (TNI) has preserved significant informal political power, economic influence, and institutional autonomy. A primary driver of this is the retention of the military's 'territorial command' structure, which mirrors civilian administration down to the village level, allowing the military to maintain local intelligence and social control. Furthermore, former military figures continue to occupy key political offices, and the military is increasingly deployed for domestic security and civilian tasks. This perspective suggests that instead of achieving complete civilian supremacy, Indonesia's democratic transition resulted in a compromise that leaves the military with substantial veto power and a persistent capacity to influence state policy, posing a continuous challenge to democratic consolidation.

Understanding of Suharto's 'New Order' (Orde Baru) regime (1966–1998) and its authoritarian political structure.
The concept of 'Dwifungsi' (Dual Function), the historical Indonesian military doctrine justifying its dual role in national defense and socio-political affairs.
Basic theories of democratic transition and democratization, specifically how authoritarian regimes undergo institutional reform.
The catalyst of the 1997 Asian Financial Crisis and how it destabilized economic and political power structures in Southeast Asia.
Analysis of contemporary civil-military relations in Indonesia, examining civilian control over the TNI (Indonesian National Armed Forces) today.
Comparative study of military-to-civilian transitions in Southeast Asia, contrasting Indonesia’s path with Thailand, Myanmar, or the Philippines.
The study of Security Sector Reform (SSR) frameworks, specifically the separation of the police (POLRI) from the military command.
Exploration of democratic backsliding and the rise of neo-patrimonialism or populist politics in post-Reformasi Indonesia.
567.9K views8.8Klikes48:06@CNAInsiderOriginal Release: 2021-04-14

Indonesia's transition from a 32-year military-dominated authoritarian regime under Suharto to a thriving democracy demonstrates that successful democratic consolidation requires not only political reforms but also the military's genuine commitment to civilian supremacy; unlike neighboring countries like Thailand and Myanmar where militaries continue to dominate politics, Indonesia's armed forces have successfully transformed into a professional institution subservient to civilian leadership, leveraging modern communication technologies and civil society oversight to prevent political comeback attempts.