McTaggart's Unreality of Time: The Contradictory A-Series

Added:

The B-Theory of Time (Tenseless Theory)

The B-Theory of Time directly challenges McTaggart's conclusion by arguing that time is real and does not require the A-series (past, present, future) to exist. Popularized by philosophers like Bertrand Russell and D.H. Mellor, the B-theory posits that time consists entirely of tenseless relations: 'earlier than,' 'simultaneous with,' and 'later than.' In this view, often associated with eternalism and the 'block universe,' all events across past, present, and future are equally real. Change is redefined not as a shifting 'now,' but simply as an object having different properties at different times (for example, a leaf being green at time t1 and brown at time t2). By dismissing the objective existence of the A-series, B-theorists dissolve McTaggart's paradox of contradiction. This perspective aligns closely with modern physics, specifically Einstein's theory of relativity, which rejects a universal, absolute present.

The basic distinction between the A-series (past, present, future) and the B-series (earlier than, later than) of temporal ordering.
Fundamental concepts in the metaphysics of time, specifically the ontological debate between Presentism (only the present exists) and Eternalism (past, present, and future all exist).
The logical structure of a 'reductio ad absurdum' (proof by contradiction), which McTaggart employs to show that the A-series is inherently contradictory.
The philosophical definition of 'change' and why a coherent account of change is considered essential to any definition of time.
The B-Theory of Time (Tenseless Theory) and how its proponents argue that time can exist and be real using only the B-series, rejecting McTaggart's premise.
The A-Theory of Time (Tensed Theory) responses, including Arthur Prior's Tense Logic, which attempts to formalize and defend tensed propositions against McTaggart's paradox.
McTaggart's 'C-series', which is the non-temporal, static ordering of events that he proposes underlies our illusion of time.
The implications of McTaggart's philosophy on modern physics, specifically how his rejection of a global 'present' aligns with or differs from Einstein's Special Theory of Relativity.
12.6K views204likes3:35@CarneadesOfCyreneOriginal Release: 2016-01-10

McTaggart argues that time is unreal because the A series (past, present, future) is inherently contradictory: while no single event can simultaneously be past, present, and future, every event must at some point be all three according to the A series; attempting to resolve this contradiction by appealing to time's reality creates a vicious circle since one must assume time is real to explain how events can have different properties at different times, thereby begging the question against McTaggart's conclusion that time is unreal.