Democratic Backsliding in the US: A Panel Discussion | UC Berkeley

Added:

The Institutional Resilience and Democratic Corrective Perspective

This perspective challenges the narrative of democratic backsliding by arguing that American democratic institutions have proven remarkably robust. Proponents, including various political scientists and constitutional scholars, emphasize that the U.S. system of checks and balances—particularly the independent judiciary, federalism, and legislative oversight—successfully constrained executive power during the Trump administration. Rather than experiencing systemic decay, they argue the nation underwent intense polarization and conventional political conflict within established constitutional boundaries. Furthermore, some theorists suggest that populist movements can act as a democratic corrective, re-mobilizing disaffected voters and challenging technocratic or elite entrenchment. From this viewpoint, framing sharp partisan friction and institutional tension as 'backsliding' overlooks the resilience of the U.S. constitutional order and conflates robust political contestation with democratic erosion.

The constitutional design of the US government, specifically the principles of separation of powers, checks and balances, and federalism.
The theoretical definition of 'democratic backsliding' and how modern democracies decline through gradual institutional erosion rather than sudden military coups.
The distinction between formal constitutional laws and informal democratic norms, such as mutual toleration and institutional forbearance.
The traditional, independent role of the judiciary and civil society (including the free press) as accountability mechanisms in a liberal democracy.
Comparative analysis of democratic erosion in the US versus international cases like Hungary, Turkey, Poland, and Brazil.
Proposed institutional reforms and policy solutions designed to reinforce democratic guardrails and protect voting rights.
The sociological and political impacts of deep affective polarization and partisan media ecosystems on public trust in democratic processes.
Long-term consequences of executive norm-breaking on the authority and independence of federal agencies and civil service.
898 views26likes1:25:59@BerkeleyEconomySocietyOriginal Release: 2025-10-21

The US constitutional framework, designed with checks and balances to prevent authoritarianism, has become vulnerable to democratic backsliding due to nationalized polarization, the rise of unitary executive theory, and partisan teamsmanship that has eroded traditional institutional guardrails. The Supreme Court's 84% success rate for the Trump administration, combined with attacks on judicial independence and the willingness of civil society actors to defer to executive demands, demonstrates how pluralistic institutions can be systematically undermined. However, historical patterns of democratic resilience, including the civil rights movement's success in generating sympathetic media coverage and building civic capacity, suggest that organized resistance and strategic mobilization remain essential tools for defending democratic institutions.