Learning in Games: Ultimatum, Public Goods, & Institutions

Added:

Cultural Determinism and Social Norms

While Al Roth's learning framework emphasizes how feedback and trial-and-error shape behavior within economic games and institutions, critics from anthropology and sociology argue that this cognitive-learning model overlooks the overriding power of pre-existing cultural norms. Researchers like Joseph Henrich and colleagues have demonstrated through cross-cultural studies of the Ultimatum Game that behavior is not merely a product of local feedback and game-theoretic learning. Instead, offers and rejection rates vary wildly based on a society's degree of market integration and cooperative norms developed over generations. From this perspective, individuals do not primarily "learn" the optimal strategy through iterative feedback within the institution; rather, they import deeply ingrained, culturally transmitted social norms of fairness and reciprocity to solve coordination problems. Consequently, focusing solely on individual feedback loops within a game risks ignoring the broader social, historical, and cultural structures that pre-determine human behavior in economic environments.

Basic concepts of Game Theory, including players, strategies, payoffs, and the Nash Equilibrium.
The mechanics and standard economic predictions of the Ultimatum Game, specifically regarding fairness and rational self-interest.
The structure of the Public Goods Game and the economic concept of the 'free-rider' problem.
An introductory understanding of Experimental Economics and how human behavior often deviates from classical game-theoretic predictions.
Advanced learning models in games, such as reinforcement learning, fictitious play, and Experience-Weighted Attraction (EWA).
Market Design and Matching Theory, specifically practical applications like the Deferred Acceptance algorithm used in school choice and kidney exchanges.
Evolutionary Game Theory, exploring how behaviors and strategies evolve in populations over time through feedback loops.
Institutional Design, analyzing how changing the rules and feedback mechanisms of an institution can steer collective behavior toward optimal outcomes.
530 views0likes42:03@SacklerColloquiaOriginal Release: 2014-03-10

In economic games, how players learn from experience versus description significantly affects outcomes; players tend to underweight rare events when learning from experience (unlike the overweighting observed in description-based experiments), and high variance in payoffs slows learning, which has important implications for designing economic institutions like school choice mechanisms and auctions that must account for how people actually learn rather than assuming rational optimization.