Philosophy of the Self & Personal Identity | Marya Schechtman

Added:

Galen Strawson’s Episodic Self and the Critique of Narrativity

A major counterpoint to Marya Schechtman’s narrative self-constitution view comes from philosopher Galen Strawson, particularly in his seminal essay "Against Narrativity." While Schechtman argues that personal identity and psychological unity depend on constructing a coherent life narrative, Strawson challenges both the descriptive and normative aspects of this claim. Strawson distinguishes between "Diachronic" individuals (who naturally perceive their lives as a continuous story) and "Episodic" individuals (who live in the present, feeling little connection to their past or future selves). He argues that being Episodic is a perfectly valid and healthy way of existing, and that forcing one's life into a narrative structure can lead to self-delusion, distortion of memory, and artificial ego-inflation. For Strawson, a deeply ethical and fulfilled life does not require a unified narrative self, directly opposing the idea that narration is essential to personhood.

John Locke's memory-based theory of personal identity and the psychological continuity view.
The metaphysical distinction between numerical identity (being the exact same entity over time) and qualitative identity (sharing identical properties).
Derek Parfit's reductionist view of personal identity (Relation R) and his challenge to the unified self.
Standard philosophical thought experiments regarding identity, such as the Ship of Theseus and brain transplant scenarios.
Galen Strawson's critique of the narrative self, specifically his defense of the 'episodic' way of experiencing life.
The application of narrative identity theories to bioethics, particularly in understanding agency and identity in patients with dementia or severe memory loss.
Marya Schechtman's later 'Person Life View' from her work 'Staying Alive', which integrates biological, social, and narrative elements.
The relationship between narrative selfhood, moral responsibility, and how we attribute praise or blame over a person's lifespan.
1.4K views63likes1:10:51@TheDissenterRLOriginal Release: 2023-02-09

The self is fundamentally narrative in structure, meaning that being a self involves having a story-like organization that extends through time, rather than being a static entity; this narrative approach accommodates the complexity of human identity including change, conflict, and incoherence over time, while still maintaining a sense of unity through biological and social constraints that interact to form our sense of self.