How to Approach Bach's Two-Part Inventions: Piano Lesson, Part 1 (Robert Estrin)

Added:

Historically Informed Performance (HIP) and Baroque Articulation

While modern piano pedagogy often emphasizes seamless legato lines and expressive dynamic shaping to highlight the subject and counter-subject, the Historically Informed Performance (HIP) perspective offers a distinct alternative. Proponents of HIP argue that Bach’s Inventions should be played using 18th-century keyboard techniques. Instead of romanticized phrasing and continuous legato, this approach prioritizes 'ordinary touch' (a default non-legato articulation), terraced dynamics, and rhetorical clarity. Since the harpsichord and clavichord cannot produce gradual dynamic swells like a modern piano, musical expression is achieved through micro-articulation, agogic accents, and timing. This teaches students to treat the voices as a spoken dialogue with clear, detached punctuation rather than sustained, modern instrumental melodies.

Basic keyboard proficiency and hand independence, allowing the student to play different rhythms and melodies in each hand simultaneously.
An understanding of musical texture, specifically the difference between homophony (melody and accompaniment) and polyphony (multiple independent voices).
Familiarity with basic music notation and score reading, particularly the ability to read treble and bass clefs at an intermediate level.
An introduction to musical phrasing and basic articulations, such as legato, staccato, and non-legato playing, which are crucial for Baroque interpretation.
Transitioning to Bach's Three-Part Inventions (Sinfonias) to apply contrapuntal playing techniques to three independent voices.
Studying the structural mechanics of fugues, including the concepts of subject, answer, countersubject, stretto, and episode, preparing for Bach's Well-Tempered Clavier.
Exploring Baroque ornamentation, including the proper execution of trills, mordents, and appoggiaturas in historical performance practice.
Developing advanced voicing techniques, such as emphasizing a specific thematic line while maintaining a softer, supportive volume in the secondary voice.
38.1K views553likes4:07@virtualsheetmusicOriginal Release: 2015-12-02

Bach's Two-Part Inventions are counterpoint pieces featuring only two melodic lines (subject and counter subject) throughout, where the performer's key task is to delineate these lines through phrasing and articulation rather than dynamics, since Bach did not specify phrasing in the score and both hands function as equal melody lines rather than melody with accompaniment.