The Lost Art of Giving and Receiving Compliments | Stanford MBA

Added:

The Paradox of Praise and the Risk of Undermining Intrinsic Motivation

While giving compliments is often promoted as a tool for motivation and relationship building, psychological research highlights "the paradox of praise." Critics and researchers, such as Alfie Kohn and Carol Dweck, argue that compliments can severely backfire. First, compliments often act as extrinsic rewards, triggering the "overjustification effect" where an individual's intrinsic motivation decreases because they begin performing tasks primarily for external approval. Second, praising innate ability rather than effort can foster a "fixed mindset," making individuals risk-averse and anxious about failing to maintain their praised status. Furthermore, in professional settings, compliments can be perceived as patronizing, evaluative, or manipulative, which can raise suspicion and damage trust rather than strengthen it. Consequently, this perspective suggests shifting away from frequent compliments and instead focusing on objective feedback and encouraging self-evaluation.

Fundamentals of Emotional Intelligence (EQ), specifically the components of self-awareness, social awareness, and relationship management.
Basic principles of behavioral psychology, particularly the concept of positive reinforcement and its effect on human motivation.
The transactional model of communication, highlighting how a sender's intent can differ from a receiver's impact.
Cognitive barriers to communication, such as the spotlight effect, imposter syndrome, and negative bias in self-evaluation.
Advanced professional feedback models, such as the Situation-Behavior-Impact (SBI) framework and Radical Candor.
The principles of Positive Organizational Scholarship (POS) and how deliberate praise shapes organizational culture and psychological safety.
The application of positive psychology interventions, including gratitude practices and the development of a growth mindset in teams.
Negotiation and persuasion strategies that leverage relational capital and mutual validation to build strategic partnerships.
12.8K views0likes9:47@stanfordgsbOriginal Release: 2018-04-19

Giving and receiving good compliments is essential for building relationships and driving achievement, yet many people struggle with both due to cultural upbringing, psychological barriers like the illusion of transparency, and self-critical tendencies; effective compliments should be specific, achievement-focused, and genuinely delivered, while proper reception involves simply acknowledging with gratitude and internalizing the compliment to understand what behavior deserves recognition.