Research demonstrates that male and female brains respond differently to fear and stress, with females exhibiting alternative behavioral responses (such as darting rather than freezing) that were previously misinterpreted as lack of learning; this highlights the critical importance of studying both sexes in neuroscience research to develop effective treatments for all individuals.
Sex Differences in Fear: Brain Structure and Behavior | Neuro Science
Added:um welcome everybody it is wonderful to see you here i'm looking down at my zoom to see um the number of participants and it's fantastic to see you all really a wonderful event i'm hazel serve i'm the relatively new dean of the college of science at northeastern at northeastern you're not allowed to call yourself new for very long and i've been here since june so i would say i'm sort of not so new the not-so-new dean of the college of science but um i want to tell you a couple of things about the college and i've got one slide that i'm going to show you i came to northeastern from mit where i was on the faculty for 28 years and i have a bit of a funny accent because i'm originally from south africa but i've been in the united states really all of my professional life i came to northeastern because this is a place where anything is possible at northeastern we are inventing the future of the university and in the college of science we can do that together with this amazing power of science that we have more than ever science is so incredibly important if you think about it without science we would not know what a coronavirus was we would have no idea how to detect one and we would be completely in the dark with regard how to build cures but we do know we know because of the science research and the science training that has happened for decades and because of that we are well on our way to finding cures including with the contributions at northeastern and including with the extraordinary effort that northeastern has made this semester to keep our community safe to test our community and to think about how coronavirus can be contained to allow our university to continue in a vibrant and important way and to date we are doing very well and i am so glad and so proud to be part of this university that is doing i in my opinion better than any other university to keep its students and its community its faculty and staff safe i um tell you a couple of things the college of science is really a fantastic place at northeastern we are solving problems that are the greatest challenges on our planet we are training the next generation of top students who will have the problem-solving skills the knowledge skills and the personal skills the confidence and the ability to communicate skills that allow them to move into the next stages of their careers whether they're educational stages or jobs these skills are so valuable our students do incredibly well as they go forward it is this coalescence of education and research that is just a wonderful thing about our college and indeed about universities and i wanted to show you a i'm going to share my screen for a single slide but i wanted to show you a kind of notion that i have in thinking about how we think about ourselves so when we think about our college and indeed universities but this is about our college today there is this wonderful set of positive loops that promote everything one to another our research effort which is so strong is promoting education of our students to understand the frontiers of science to learn how to become researchers themselves and contribute in many different ways in many professions our education drives our research our education drives innovators many of our faculty and students are innovators or entrepreneurs who go on to make patents and startup companies and in turn that innovation drives our research so there is this fantastic set of positive feedback loops that guides the power and excellence of our college but i will tell you that science is aspirational you are never satisfied and indeed you should not be satisfied or things do not stay excellent our college has to aspire to become even more excellent ever more excellent and you indeed our audience our attendees here today are part of the aspiration to promote our power and our excellence when we think about our college there's another metric that i'm going to put on top of my slide and that is that we do everything within a culture of respect and equity and we are con we are committed across our college to respect each person and the value that each person brings and to promote equity across our college so that is a slide that i wanted to share with you i'll leave it up for a moment so that you can see these um wonderful positive loops that inspire me and i think are a framework for thinking about our college i am so delighted to welcome you to our first college of science connects seminar this is a way that we are connecting with you to bring to you the extraordinary excellence the scholarship the research of our faculty particularly our more junior faculty so that you can see what is going on in the college and understand the um awesomeness of the um the work that is going on here i want to say to each of you whether you are an alum a parent a friend you are an incredibly important part of our community as part of our northeastern college of science community you are pivotal in your support and your friendship you are pivotal in helping us move forward new programs education research and innovation and we are so glad to have you as part of the northeastern college of science community really now and forever so i welcome you today and i'm going to unshare my slide here there we go i welcome you here today it is just um outstanding to have you with us and i am so delighted now to feature today and to pass on this duty of speaking with you or this pleasure of speaking with you i am so honored today that we are featuring our psychology department in the college of science the health of the human mind is something that is never far from our thoughts it is probably the thing that keeps us thinking about ourselves in the most concerned way all the time the human mind is something that is mysterious and powerful and so incredibly important for human health as a whole our psychology department is top ranked and our investigator rebecca shansky professor rebecca schansky who is being featured today is a star amongst our junior faculty and across the world so it is my great honor and pleasure to pass this mic on figuratively speaking to the chair of our psychology department professor peter becks who will welcome you further and introduce professor shansky pete thank you hazel thanks for those inspiring words um and thanks to everyone who's joining us this morning it's my very great pleasure to introduce my colleague dr rebecca schansky as the inaugural speaker of the college of science connect series dr sansky is an associate professor in the department of psychology where she directs the laboratory of neuroanatomy and behavior dr chansky received her phd in neurobiology from yale university in 2004 this was followed by six years as a postdoctoral research fellow at the department of neuroscience in mount sinai school of medicine in new york she joined the department of psychology at northeastern university in 2011 as a an assistant professor and was promoted to associate professor in 2017.
dr schansky slab uses rodent models to explore the links between brain structure and function our research focuses on how on how individual differences in cortical circuit responses to fear and stress shape long-term behavior and memory formation this work aims to identify biomarkers for vulnerability and resilience which have important public health translational impact she has secured six major awards from the national institute of mental health of nih to support this work one aspect of dr shansky's research that distinguishes her work from others in her field is her pioneering focus on sex differences in neurobiology the dominant use of animal models in research prior to 2016 ignores significant differences in male and female neurobiology and risks failure of personalized medicine approaches you can learn more about this work from her book uh titled sex differences in the central nervous system published by elsivia in 2016.
dr shansky has been a vocal advocate for gender and sex equity in experimental design and her expertise has drawn wide reaching public attention in particular a 2019 article in science titled our hormones a female problem for animal research was featured in mainstream media outlets including the new york times and science friday on npr dr shansky's research and opinions are therefore capturing broad interest as attested by the 63 national and international seminars in colloquia that she has been invited to give since joining northeastern university one of dr chansky's most prestigious and exciting speaking engagements was in gaborone botswana at the mind and life institute dialogue with the dalai lama so we are therefore in distinguished company in hearing about her research today and i invite you all to welcome my colleague dr rebecca schansky becca thank you hazel and pete for that introduction um i'm really excited to be here and i'm just going to share my screen quickly so i can get going okay um so i am again very honored to be the inaugural presenter for this um for this really exciting series that i think is going to be fantastic as we go through the semester um and i'm really excited to specifically tell you about some of the work we've been doing in my lab as well as some of the broader issues that really motivate everything we do in our research and so one of the things that we think about in the lab is that every experience you have um shapes who you are as a person and that happens through a mechanism that we kind of generally call neuroplasticity and you've probably seen in news articles that all kinds of things change your brain and so walking in nature can change your brain practicing mindfulness exercise parenting um all the food you eat reading and even god um and i don't have a screenshot for this but i think what we are learning is that um uh coronavirus can also change your brain and certainly the experiences that we're having in um in quarantine in a lockdown will have long-term effects and so um all of this is what we um what we call neuroplasticity and it is essentially the broad goal of neuroscientists to try and understand how neuroplasticity contributes to the development of psychiatric and neurological disorders and so we do research in the laboratory very often using using animals as our research subjects but we have a little bit of an embarrassing secret and what i mean by that is that when we talk about the brain or you know in all of the article titles i just showed you what we really mean is is male brains um we don't study male and female brains at the same rate in fact neuroscientists who use animals in the laboratory study male animals almost six times as much as they study females and this isn't going to be a public health problem it is already and so one of the reasons that this is so important to think about is that mental illnesses and neurological disorders occur in everyone there are very very few um there are very few mental illnesses or neurological disorders that only occur in men or women they occur in everyone but which means that we need to be able to treat everyone for these disorders um but what we also can see is that they affect men and women differently um or at different rates so what you're looking at in this um this chart on the left here is the incidence ratio of some very common mental illnesses um in women versus men and what you can see up at the top here disorders like ptsd panic disorder anxiety disorder and major depressive disorder are all at least twice as common in women as they are in men and so what this suggests is that there may be a unique neurobiological mechanism that is different between male and female brains that makes women more susceptible to developing these kinds of disorders but if we're not studying female brains in the laboratory we're not going to understand what that susceptibility mechanism might be and so you may ask yourself well why doesn't why don't we study females and if you ask neuroscientists who historically have studied male animals why they won't study females the answer is hormones look at these crazy hormones what i'm showing you here on the left are plots of hormonal changes across um the rodent estro cycle and the human menstrual cycle and you can see that um in both women and um and female rats we can see that uh hormones like estradiol progesterone have periods of being up and down and the logic there is that well you might have some females that are in this high phase of um of hormones and some that are in low and so our data are going to be so messy because we've got all these crazy hormones um and that to me is not a good excuse because i think that um having fluctuating hormones is a normal part of the biology of being a female organism and that's something that we should just sort of take as a given for how for how female bodies and brains work in addition uh male hormones will vary too especially in mice so if you place mice in a cage together which is normally how they're housed in uh in a lab usually put four or five animals together they will establish a dominance hierarchy and the testosterone levels in the alpha male are uh can be up to 10 times as high as the testosterone levels in the uh the subordinate animals and so here's the source of very of hormonal variability that has exists in you know every laboratory across the world and somehow this hormone variability has not been seen as troubling as hormone variability in female animals is and so to me that's a double standard that is unacceptable when we are trying to understand how brains work and so the general philosophy of my lab is that we need to treat hormone variability in both sexes just as a natural part of the brain's physiology this is how things are supposed to work and they do when we can study brain function against that backdrop instead of seeing it as something that needs to be controlled or accounted for when we do our experiments the other thing that i think is really important that i i've been working to try and convince my colleagues and neuroscientists in general of is that female animals are just as useful research subjects as um as males are in terms of just basic science understanding brain function and so we're making some progress on that but we still have a long way to go so i'm going to tell you a little bit about how we've been working to get at some of these questions and so one of the main questions we have in my lab is is the relationship between neural structure and function different in males and females can we identify points where structure is differently meaningful um in males and females and what you're looking at here is a photo that my grad student took on a microscope of one neuron in an area of the brain called the prefrontal cortex and this is an area of the brain that is responsible for emotion regulation and so we're really interested in how this area of the brain is is different in just sort of individual variability in terms of emotion regulation success um and so what we do is we can take these pictures of um of these neurons that have been filled with a fluorescent dye and i'll show you a cool little video here so we can take these images in 3d and examine all of the um the structure of the neuron you can see here there's lots of dendrites these are essentially the neurons antenna these are what are receiving information from other parts of the brain from neighboring neurons within the brain um and we can learn a lot about the ability of this brain region to um to mediate and regulate emotion based on this information this is a really zoomed in picture of just a little snippet of one of these dendrites and all of those little protrusions those are spines those are called spines and those are the sites of synaptic input so again this is where it's where all the magic happens um on a neuron is at these spines and we can use computer software to understand um how these uh these spines change in response to experiences that the animals have and so again it's this question of neuroplasticity these spines are not permanent they can grow and go away as the animal moves through it's through its life and so i we mentioned at the title of the talk that we're really interested in fear behavior and that's because i'm really interested in one of those statistics i mentioned which is that women are twice as likely to develop ptsd as males are and we use a paradigm called pavlovian fear conditioning and so this is a pretty classical associative learning task in which the animal hears a tone come out of a little speaker in the box and as soon as the tone ends it gets a little foot shock in um and it's in the floor and so then soon the animal starts to become afraid of the tone because it knows the tone means it's going to um it's going to get a foot shock which it doesn't like and so what we've been interested in is looking at individual differences in the way these animals learn that association and how we are able to judge those individual differences is in the way they express that fear response once they've learned the association and so animals that exhibit uh big fear of spawns may have learned better than animals that have a smaller um fear response and so this paradigm is really old it was developed um sort of in the early 20th century and the people who developed it and everyone who's been using it in labs around the world for the last multiple multiple decades have have decided essentially that the way we measure how much an animal learned is in the amount of time it spends in a freezing posture so you can see this rat here is demonstrating the freezing response you can think of it as kind of a deer in the headlights kind of response where the animal just completely stops moving and it's not that this is an expression of um vigilance as well as a desire not to be detected pretended by a potential predator and so what we did when i first started the lab was we did an experiment where we um we measured this fear condition freezing in males and females and then we looked at their neurons in um in the prefrontal cortex that area that i mentioned before and what we found was that if we compared high freezing and low freezing males their neurons were different from each other so there was essentially this structural signature of what we were interpreting as good and bad learning um but when we looked at the females we didn't have that that distinction in um in their neurons the high freezing and low freezing females kind of all look the same and so we were pretty puzzled by this uh this difference and we asked ourselves what are we missing and so instead of looking into the neural structure we went back to the videos of the animals behaving in this task and what we found was that yes the males were exhibiting this freezing response and the animals that counted as the low freezers they uh were just not really doing much of anything um they were just kind of walking around the cage and it really seemed like they didn't really understand what the tone meant but in the females when we looked at our low freezing females who theoretically did not learn um we saw they were doing something else instead of freezing they were engaging in this darting behavior where they heard the tone and they started to run around the cage like they were trying to escape and this was something that under normal um data collection practices we would have just ruled out as a lack of fear or a lack of learning and what became clear was that these animals did learn and they were afraid they were just expressing it differently and this was something that again we saw really just in the females and so we've become really interested in understanding what is the behavioral repertoire we have in females what can we look at in um uh in these animals and you can see here this animal the tone has come on and she sort of spun around she ran to the other end other side of um of the chamber she will engage in a little bit of a freezing behavior right here so you can see she's completely not moving at all um and then she's going to kind of creep out to see if maybe it's safe to uh to emerge um so this is a pretty common contrast to what we see in the males which is basically they just freeze um and so what we are trying to understand now um are a bunch of different things about this behavior so first of all we want to know what is darning is it a true escape response could it possibly mean something else and why do we only see it in females um and so some of the things that we are really excited that we're kind of just getting going on now in the lab is to use viral strategies to selectively activate or silence neural circuits so what we've identified is again a role for this area of the brain the prefrontal cortex and specifically the projections the connectivity it has with a part another part of the brain deep down in the brain stem called the periaqueductal gray we think that's the circuit that's controlling darting and so we have some really exciting state-of-the-art tools that will allow us to selectively either activate or silence the circuit and that's going to allow us to see whether we can increase darting or suppress darting whether we can turn males into darters by doing this um and the other thing we really want to know is is that neuroplasticity different in darters versus freezers so our daughter's learning something new about their environment that's different from animals that only engage in freezing how can we see how does this change the circuitry how does this change the brain in a long-term um kind of way so there's a lot that we can do in the lab to really try and probe uh this response the sex differences within it at a very exciting cellular level the other fun thing we have going on is a collaboration with a colleague of mine bob data at harvard medical school who's developed a really sophisticated tool that uses machine learning to identify novel behavior patterns and so this uses a camera that can measure the animal's position in space so not just where it is in two dimensions but in three dimensions and the uh machine learning aspect of it it essentially breaks behavior down into what they're calling syllables and then can identify syllable patterns that will show us things that maybe we can't see with uh with just the human eye but that are really there distinguishing these subgroups of animals that may help us ultimately understand what it means to be susceptible or resilient against aversive experiences so we're really excited to use this tool as well um and so just to kind of wrap things up here why is all of this so important well it's because basic science is there in a lot of ways to inform clinical developments and so the use of male animals over the course of um the last 60 70 years however you know nih has been around um has essentially led to tunnel vision and the development of therapeutics because we are using these behavioral outcomes that were developed in male animals as the the benchmark as to whether or not for example a particular drug works um but if we're not even looking for the right behavioral outcomes if we're trying to treat females then we could be missing you know a potentially new drugs or whether they may there may be aversive side effects in specifically in women so there are a lot of reasons that i think neuroscientists need to start studying both males and females and not simply judging females using the frameworks that were developed in males so i will stop there um i wanted to thank my amazing lab without whom none of this would have been possible and i am happy to take any questions if people have them becca thank you so much for that talk which was truly outstanding really it's uh i am so struck by the um difficulty of doing top research as a as a researcher myself the effort and the the intellectual power and the work that goes into this scholarship that you've shared with us is just extraordinary it is really so important and it is so wonderful to hear your discussion let me take some questions from the i think we're doing this from the chat i believe is that right diana we're doing questions from the chat yes okay so please you know whatever questions you have um please put them in the chat and i will encourage you what i encourage the entire college of science i think last week the week before lost i send a weekly update every week i said to them i shared the time that a nobel laureate asked me questions that i thought were pretty um basic questions and i realized that if you need to know the answer to something you just ask so please just ask your question don't worry if you think it's a stupid question there is no such thing there are just questions so please ask professor shansky anything that you want about the research that she's described or indeed something else on your mind that you think she might be able to answer for you i see a question that asks how do you think we develop a more holistic behavioral evaluation for fear behavior that incorporates darting and other fear responses so fantastic question i you know i think that this is really where the machine learning tool will come in because the the way the machine learning works is that it you don't decide in advance what you're looking for the um the computer tells you what you're seeing um and so i think in that sense we have these really high throughput um sophisticated computational ways of identifying these novel behaviors that we don't that don't allow us to anthropomorphize that don't necessarily allow us to rule out things that we don't necess we don't might not think are important that could turn out to be important so i think that um that this is really the the way forward on all of this thank you thank you becca here's another some fabulous questions everybody just keep typing away and um we'll answer as many as possible in our time we have quite a bit of time for discussion and questions which is great um are funding organizations moving towards requiring both female and male animal models um so the answer to that is yes uh nih at least has uh put in place in a mandate that started in 2016 called considering sex as a biological variable and it's taken a little while to get off the ground but basically what it means is that when researchers apply for funding from nih they need to say that they are going to use male and both male and female animals in their research and so that caused quite a big hubbub in um you know in the field which is why i wrote that piece um in science last year because people were worried that um that being required to use female animals meant that they had to study the estra cycle which is not true um unless you want to of course which there is a whole field for that it's called neuroendocrinology and it is the study of how hormones affect the brain but not everybody has to be a neuroendocrinologist nsf to my knowledge does not require using both males and females but certainly i think the the winds are changing on this and people are starting to understand why it is so important to um to study both yes outstanding um you know you talked about on the prefrontal cortex being monitored in your darting studies and they're questions about um what about other brain regions is it just do you think that that is the major part of the brain that's important here or do you think there are other parts of the brain that you could study and um get valuable data from sure so um so yes so no brain region works in isolation right everything is connected and one of the big things that neuroscience has really been focusing on lately because we have the tools to do these manipulations are neural circuits so um as i mentioned in the talk we're focused on projections from the prefrontal cortex to the periaqueductal gray and the reason this is such a cool circuit is that there are actually two circuits so in the periaqueductal gray it's got one part that controls that if you just stimulate it elicits essentially a darting response and one part that if you stimulate it it elicits a freezing response and so those two parts of the periaqueductal gray receive separate neuroanatomical input from the prefrontal cortex and so the way we're thinking about this is that the prefrontal cortex can essentially act as a as a switch to decide whether you're going to have a freezing response or a darting response and what we think might be happening is that the strength of um those two those two prefrontal circuits might determine whether you become a daughter or a freezer thank you becca you know i'm so struck by the complexity of this brain you're talking about as someone who studies the development of the brain you know and has taught about the brain the notion of a brain with you know 10 to the with with trillions and trillions with a thousand trillion connections between itself makes uncovering these circuits um so incredibly complex and i think your work is going a long way to de convoluting this enormous complexity of the brain it's so important i'm going to um jump around a little bit there's some great questions here but i want to go to some of perhaps the more provocative questions here so let's um go to those because those are interesting to discuss here's one to what degree do you suppose that the way we study male and female brains is influenced by our cultural perspectives um great question and i actually think that it is influenced quite a bit by our cultural perspectives um i think that the basic culture within neuroscience has been that if you want to understand the fundamental aspects of neurobiology you study male brains because they're cleaner because they don't have the influence of circulating hormones and that if you are a person who wants to study female brains it's because you're specifically interested in women's health not neuroscience um and so that i think is a is really problematic because it essentially treats males as like the default um and that females are this sort of like unique weird deviation from um from that and some of the research that i did um when i was putting together the um the science piece last year revealed that those perspectives are actually long-standing cultural stereotypes that were put in place around the victorian era um and the the idea was that before then the by like view from biologists was that women were sort of like an inferior version of men and that became a little like on pc and so they had to restructure their narrative to essentially give women their these like unique qualities and so they gave them sensitivity perceptiveness emotionality etc and said okay so you have your own thing going on you're not just like a different version of men but uh these qualities clearly make you unsuited for societal leadership and the goal was essentially to preserve the patriarchy and so that has been how we view culturally the differences between women and men for over 100 years and that i think has kind of infiltrated the way that scientists think about how to do objective neuroscience research and the the result has been we study males because they are true and real and females have all these crazy hormones that are getting in the way of what's really going on when of course they are a part of what's going on in the first place yes that's a great answer to this question there's a there's a number of them that are sort of along these lines so let me um try to paraphrase a couple um [Music] one is very specific to ask whether there are correlations between hormones and fear conditioning performance for example are high testosterone males better or worse fear conditioning performers great question so we've looked into that a little bit not on the male side though so we haven't done um i mean so this is sort of like the whole idea of what i was talking about is no one except for people who are really specifically interested in male hormones even bothers to look at whether or not your male animals have high versus low testosterone whereas if you're studying females it can be um pretty common to look at what stage of the estra cycle they're in to see whether or not they have high versus low estradiol so off the top of my head i don't know anyone who has done that male experiment to really separate the animals out by low versus high testosterone in females having high versus low estrogen doesn't seem to affect fear conditioning itself it can affect some other learning processes that um kind of happen down the line but um but for in our lab we don't see an effect of um of hormones on fear conditioning learning or on darting by the way we looked at that too right right good um okay so let me see if i can bring a couple of questions together there there's a question about you know along the lines of the societal question and the cultural question of why we've sort of ignored the difference um between male and female behavior and brains um there's the question of you know why um this was also ignored even though it was clear that there were different hormones that were of neurobehavioral significance so so that's sort of more along the lines of this cultural question of why um these differences these these um sex differences were not studied but then i'm going to segue it into another really important interesting question which is the sense that you know the two-gender idea in our social climate is really changing and um you know how do you think um incorporate sex differences into research is balanced with the notion that there is a challenge to two gender ideas so so i've kind of convoluted two questions i hope you all forgive me um elena and andy um they're on the chat there but i thought there was a very interesting way of putting this together you know so why was this all ignored for for so long when we knew about hormonal differences um in neural behavior and how do these differences now segue into this note into this challenge of a two-gender model does that work for you becca i kind of like i'm gonna i'm gonna do my best on this um i think the you know again i think it does come back to these they sort of implicit as to what we think makes um you know a male rat a male rat and what makes a female rat a female rat and there is this cultural influence on this idea that the female or you know circulating ovarian reproductive hormones are really really are like the primary driver of female psychology and behavior and neuroscience in general and that like there just isn't quite that link with respect to um male animals and testosterone and i think that that is a cultural influence in the way we think about things because for sure testosterone has all kinds of effects on um on brain function and the fact that it might be a variable influencing basic science research in male animals is um has just been ignored um because we think it's just sort of normal um whereas female hormonal fluctuations are uh messy um and so i you know i it's not that there's no one studying them but it isn't seen as a primary concern in basic neuroscience research this question about uh sex differences versus gender uh understanding all the different genders that there exist in humans is something that i i do struggle with a lot because i um i wanna to show appreciation that talking about this in sort of a binary way at the level of my research and trying to apply that to humans is not a straight you know kind of one-to-one thing what i think is important here is that in studying you know so we can't assign a gender to a rat because we can't ask it how it identifies and so the best we can do at the at this level is to um is just you know to at least study both male and female rodents what i think that will do in terms of translational research that is going to reach the public um is not necessarily to say well the results and males are going to translate to men and the results and females are going to translate to the women and there's nothing we can do for um you know for people whose identity is is not as non-binary and so what i will say though is that studying at the basic science level male and female brains will at the very least broaden the scope of what we understand is possible within a brain we can identify new mechanisms based on the sex differences that we observe it's not necessarily guaranteed that everything we learn um everything we do in males is gonna you know go in one direction everything is gonna in females is gonna go in another direction once you translate up to humans but it gives us some more options it widens the um you know the scope of what we can observe and it might be able uh to help us understand just basically what's available to human brains um as possible and it doesn't have to be this strict one-to-one translation very interesting very interesting and and then um and andy notes if the binary system of gender is dismissed you're kind of starting completely from scratch in many ways which um may be one of the powers of animal models in that you can actually look at the data and you can look at the parameters that you have rather than starting from something other than actual molecules perhaps that we have to do in humans so this is very interesting and of course one of the great powers of using animal models for addressing such complex questions um as human brain health let's see um let me see what else um there's a question about rodent strains and what the very specific question in that in our research on animal models we use so many um we use defined to to try to understand things we tend to use very clear defined systems but of course there are many different um strains of animals that you could use that are a bit different from one another um have you looked at those and you see differences between them and how would you interpret that the primary strain of wrath that we use in the lab is called a spray dolly um these are the white albino rats that you saw in the the freezing picture i showed we also use long evans rats which are a different strain and they definitely have some different behavioral um idiosyncrasies uh to these uh compared to the spray dollies and so we haven't seen as much darting in the long events as we do in the spray dolly so there may be a little bit of a strain difference there um but we just we haven't the rats that we're using long ovens for we're not using for a darting study so we haven't really like dug in um with them yeah very interesting you you will not know this but for a while i was a high school biology teacher in england and my students kept rats as pets there and they would they would have rat races they were very sweet you know rhetts are i think very sweet animals and they would have rat races um over recess time and there would be the rats running all over the desk i have no idea what strain they were but it reminds me okay so here's a very interesting question that has to do with whether your discoveries in sex of sex differences in animal behaviors have implications for other cns diseases with gender biases such as alzheimer's or you know one could even put in their autism which has a very preponderant um sex difference yeah sure so i think so the fear conditioning paradigm itself i think doesn't necessarily apply to alzheimer's or or autism but the study of sex differences in the mechanisms and in the behavioral phenotypes of these disorders is something that's really really important to study i have a colleague at the university of minnesota named nicola grissom who is an amazing scientist and she studies sex differences in autism models and in decision making and um and other kinds of learning patterns and she sees that male and female that she studies mice not rats but they essentially have different strategies when they're working on complex problems and they can all they can both get to the end but just like we see in my research if you're using one kind of um parameter set as what's the right way to do something is you're gonna miss what the you make it miss what the other animal other sex of the animal is doing um and so it again she sort of um uncovered these biases in the way that behavioral experiments are designed and interpreted in neuroscience research that is really gonna i think open up a lot of different ways that we can understand how these processes work outstanding so a lot of questions here and i can see we're going to run out of time but that is always wonderful and i'll pass these questions on to you becca and and you can see um if there's a way you can answer them afterwards um here's an interesting one you know what would your experiments do to evaluating effectiveness of various fda approved medications for depression and other things that may have sex differences how do you see in other words the translational significance of what you're studying sure so what we see in our um in darter so the way we're thinking about it is that it's essentially you could think of it as like an active versus a passive response to a threat and you can see in human populations that uh people who undergo some kind of traumatic event and who have a more passive response during the event either they you know they themselves freeze or they go into what's called an um uh dissociative um traumatic dissociative fugue they are more likely to develop ptsd afterwards um and so what we can see is if we can find for example drugs that increase the likelihood that animals will switch into that darting mode that's one way that we could uh we might envision being able to apply this to humans we know are going to be in traumatic uh traumatic experiences like uh um combat veteran or combat soldiers firefighters um people like that so those are that's one um you know one sort of low hanging fruit i think of this um but i think on a deeper level it's going to help us understand learning and the neuroplasticity that underlies learning if we can find mechanisms that are unique to um to one behavior versus another then we can also try and get in there find novel targets um or try and understand even how behavioral manipulations that lead to darting versus freezing could also um promote one one outcome versus the other outstanding outstanding very very encouraging um let's see there's a there's a number of interesting questions here i'm going to throw them out and and becca you can decide which one you want to answer here okay and i i know i've ignored something about um um there's a question from a new graduate student i'm just going to deflect that one not that it is not a fabulous question but it's kind of a long one but i see um there's a question about being a woman in science in a male-dominated field and how you feel about that there's a question about using rat models rather than mice and there's a question about machine learning algorithms and which ones would be best for your research so i'm giving you here three questions the rats versus mice the woman in science question and the machine learning algorithms question so you pick maybe one of them because then we'll need to finish up oh my gosh um okay bye whatever you want okay the two sort of procedural ones i can answer really quickly and then hopefully i can take a little more time with the other one so we're using rats more than mice um because rats have a bigger prefrontal cortex so there's a little more going on there and that's what we like to study but it's true that mice have more um transgenic opportunities so we may do both eventually as far as machine learning all the algorithms go this one tool that we are using is called motion sequencing it's by far the best out there um there are a lot where you define the um the things that you wanted to look for and that makes the data collection automated but this one really tells you what you're seeing and i think that that's the best um so being a woman in science in a male dominated field um has been uh an experience i think it's very common across biological sciences i was very lucky in grad school to have several really amazing female mentors and role models to look up to and so that just seeing that there are um really excellent women who can you know are making it work is inspiring and um and makes me want to continue um definitely the more i studied sex differences specifically the more i started to recognize the biases in um you know built into the way we conduct research in the first place and that's something that as i moved through my career especially as a professor here and especially after nih introduced the sex as a biological variable um which was something i had already been working on and already been thinking about suddenly i was kind of bumped into this like expert uh position that um i didn't expect and that um um all of a sudden everyone is interested in doing sex differences research or at least they're they want to know how um to do it in the best way possible and so you know i i have my feeling has always just been like just keep going with the with the flow and i think things are changing for the better for women in science probably not as fast as they need to be because they're still a lot of biases there are studies out there showing that women's grants are not scored as well as men's are even once you take out quality of the science type things so um there's still a lot of work to be done terrific so there certainly is becca and i resonate with that and it's a fantastic discussion to have this has been just an extraordinary time to spend with you all um i want to thank you becca professor shansky for sharing your scholarship your thoughts and your insights with us today really what a valuable time to have the honor of spending with you i want to thank you professor pete becks for sharing your time with us and introducing professor shansky i want to thank all of you for joining us for this first college of science connects seminar we have these regularly we want you to be part of our regular audience we are so honored and pleased to have you as alumni as parents and friends as part of our northeastern college of science community i personally look forward to connecting with you going forward and to working with you to make our college of science ever more excellent thank you so much and i wish you all a wonderful day
Up Next

Emotion and Motivation | Introduction to Psychology MIT 9.00SC
@mitocw
79.4K views•2012-05-01

Redefining Grief: A New Framework for Healing | TEDx Talk
@TEDx
292.6K views•2022-01-26

Thinking, Fast and Slow: Daniel Kahneman Animated Book Summary
@FightMediocrity
2.3M views•2015-06-05

The Nocebo Effect: How Beliefs Can Cause Real Harm
@CGPGrey
10.4M views•2013-12-23
Related Study Plans & Knowledge Roadmaps
Structured learning paths in Psychology






































