Judicial Overreach in India: Harish Salve on Court Power Limits

Added:

Judicial Activism as a Constitutional Safeguard and Democratic Necessity

While critics like Harish Salve caution against judicial overreach, proponents of judicial activism argue that the judiciary must step in to protect citizens' fundamental rights when the executive and legislative branches fail or exhibit apathy. In India, this proactive role is exemplified by Public Interest Litigation (PIL) and the 'Basic Structure Doctrine.' Supporters contend that in a developing democracy with systemic governance gaps, court-monitored probes and judicial interventions are not 'overreach' but a vital constitutional mechanism to ensure accountability, protect marginalized communities, and uphold the rule of law. Without this active judicial intervention, majoritarian excesses and executive lawlessness could go unchecked, undermining the core tenets of the Indian Constitution.

The principle of Separation of Powers as outlined in the Indian Constitution, defining the distinct roles and boundaries of the Legislature, Executive, and Judiciary.
The fundamental distinction between 'Judicial Activism' (the proactive protection of citizen rights) and 'Judicial Overreach' (the perceived encroachment of courts into policy-making domains).
The origin and evolution of Public Interest Litigation (PIL) in India, which historically expanded the standing (locus standi) of citizens to approach courts on behalf of the public good.
The concept of Judicial Review (primarily under Articles 13, 32, and 226 of the Indian Constitution), which empowers the higher judiciary to evaluate the constitutionality of legislative and executive actions.
Analyzing specific case studies of controversial Supreme Court interventions, such as the national highway liquor ban or court-mandated reforms in sports administration (BCCI).
Investigating the mechanism, legality, and practical outcomes of 'court-monitored probes' by agencies like the CBI or special investigation teams (SITs) under judicial supervision.
Evaluating the systemic debate over judicial appointments in India, specifically comparing the judiciary-led 'Collegium System' with the struck-down National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC).
Conducting a comparative constitutional analysis of judicial power, comparing India's judicial supremacy trends with the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty in the United Kingdom and judicial restraint in the United States.
137.4K views0likes11:54@RepublicWorldOriginal Release: 2025-10-25

The Supreme Court's expansion into investigative powers through court-monitored investigations has created a dangerous precedent where judges gain political influence they should not possess, undermining the separation of powers and potentially creating a parallel government; judges should focus on interpreting law rather than conducting investigations, as this risks compromising judicial impartiality and the rule of law.