The effectiveness of music theory books depends significantly on when you encounter them in your musical development; certain books that seem overwhelming or incomprehensible at one stage of learning can become transformative later when your perspective and skills have matured, as demonstrated by Adam Neely's experience with books like Building Walking Basslines (high school) and Harmonic Experience (graduate studies).
5 Essential Music Theory and Composition Books for Musicians
Added:reading a book about playing music it's kind of like reading a book about speaking a foreign language that can be immensely useful but only if you put in the work there have been several of these books that have really inspired me to put in the work and I've changed how I view music I wouldn't be the musician that I am today without them the advancing guitarists so believe it or not this thin little book has enough stuff to practice for I'm gonna say about a decade it really taught me to think of practicing more like a challenge rather than a series of obligations that you must follow every chapter and almost every page has a series of questions that try to get you thinking a little bit more laterally it taught me to think more along the lines of well what if this happened rather than well what should I practice next one of my favorite examples of this is what he calls the science of the unit R or just improvising on one string so you can't rely upon muscle memory to guide the lot of decisions a lot of this book is guitar based he spends a lot of time with a parsimonious voice leading or how to get from one chord to the next in the most efficient way on guitar but there still are a lot of great musical gems that are applicable on any instrument like this page for example on the effective use of space I first read this book senior year of high school I wasn't really ready for it at the time but there was a book that I was ready for [Music] and frequent in the ninth grade I joined my high school's jazz band I didn't know anything about jazz I could barely read music I definitely didn't know how to improvise and so the first time I saw this I panic what am I supposed to do with that can basis even play chords am I just supposed to play the root building walking bass lines is a bare-bones stripped-down streamlined and rather elegant introduction to the idea of creating a walking bass line it spends a lot of time with the age-old idea of a root v baseline and applying it to a walking line and then slowly and methodically adding more nuance to the idea first with chromatic approaches then with scaler approaches and then finally with arpeggiation I was very quick to get the idea of a walking jazz bass line after reading this book even with a very cursory knowledge of theory at the time for me it was kind of like connecting the dots through a harmonic maze almost like solving a crossword puzzle with my bass [Music] this book took a prescriptivists approach to music making a series of rules that I had to follow but it was for a goal walking basslines and I achieved that goal by following those rules a lot of the books that I would read afterwards were also kind of prescriptivists but my goals didn't really align with them so I didn't really take much inspiration from them that is until I read the much more descriptive estate century harmony by Vincent Percy Katie when I was at Berkeley I loved to go to the stan getz library and read as many books on theory and composition as I could possibly get my hands on one of the books that I found was twentieth-century harmony which was way different than any of the dry prescriptivists Theory books that it was a sign like a tonal harmony by puska pain just like building walking basslines 20th century harmony is practical it's written for people who want to write to music not to analyze it it doesn't really concern itself with how you should do things it just tells you what they are it's almost as if the book says here are the toys now go and play the first year that I moved to New York I spent a lot of my subway commute annotating pages of 20th century Harmy I know I was one of the cool kids but I learned a lot from this commute from extended harmony to quartel harmony to poly chords to tone clusters to compound mirror harmony to a particularly wicked device called fused harmony the book is a cornucopia of cool techniques and how to get them I was and definitely continue to be seduced by the idea of harmonic color shades of musical experience expressed through harmony instead of trying to obfuscate these sorts of experience through musical jargon persik Eddy instead ops to try and explain every single effect through subjective terms neutral Restless transparent brilliant ambiguous and veiled cloudiness suppleness even if these terms are subjective for me this has been much more useful in understanding my emotional reaction to these musical effects the book does not say what is right and what is wrong and so after one morning commute as I was finishing annotating the book I summed up the final paragraph like this do whatever the you want the book was enormous ly influential on me but I really enjoyed a lot of the books that I read in the Berkeley library and I took a lot from them I took a lot from all of them for one automatic approach to jazz for me and melody bye baby beep first picking this book off of the shelf was kind of like staring into the abyss it was written in such clear and concise language but was so harmonically advanced I I don't really know what to do with it I revisited this book a couple of years later when I did my graduate study at the Manhattan School of Music and I walked into my first lecture taught by none other than Dave Lehmann himself Dave Lehmann is a colossus of jazz saxophone he played with Miles Davis's band for five years in the 70s and he is quite a character he talks with a Brooklyn accent so thick that none of the foreign students were able to understand him we studied this book for two years and we were told that we would probably not be able to understand it we spent the first semester on the first 10 pages alone it's not so much that the book is hard to understand it's just the music that the book is trying to teach you is hard to wrap your head around it's basically a manifesto on how to sound like Dave Liebman and dense and atonal but also quite melodic and beautiful he goes through a bunch of techniques on how to sound out or what he calls automatic it comes to codify all the different ways that you may superimpose different harmonies on top of one another while you improvise he also goes through techniques like intervallic improvisation where you use different intervals as the basis for your improv instead of chords the result is an improvisational concept quite unlike any other even though to this day I still quite haven't really fully grasped it just being exposed to these ideas has really opened my mind to what's possible when I studied with Lehman I didn't really get a sense that he was doing this as a vanity project I think he was really trying to get inside the dissonance in its own terms not as something cacophonous but as something crystalline and beautiful [Applause] [Applause] [Music] this idea of getting inside of a sound instead of just letting it pass through you really hit home with me with this next book harmonic experienced by you I've talked a lot on this channel about the relationship of polyrhythmic ratios to harmonic ratios and I gave a talk at Ableton loop last year on this very subject about a week after this talk I got an email from waa Mathieu asking to talk about his book harmonic experience assuming that I had read it because I was talking about a lot of the things that he does in that book I actually hadn't read it so I ordered it off Amazon and reading it for the first time honestly was kind of a revelation I mean he talks about some of the things that have been interested in in much greater detail and much more clearly than I ever did he wrote harmonic experience as a means of trying to connect just into nated pure intervals with our Western twelve-tone equal tempered system the big takeaway in this book for me is his approach to the 5 limit lattice it's an interconnected web of purely tuned major thirds and perfect fifths that reveals all kinds of really interesting things like how a flat and g-sharp are not actually the same note and why that is the reason for this is that in five limit tuning which is a tuning system that uses the fifth harmonic or major 3rd is the most complicated interval for building a flat is built by going down a major third from C G sharp on the other hand is built by going up two major thirds from C the result if you're using pure major thirds built upon a five-to-four ratio from the harmonic series are two separate distinct notes [Music] they both sound consonant when you play them against C there definitely is a perceptible difference between a flat and g-sharp that does not exist in a twelve tone equal tempered system in other words even though there is no differentiation between a flat and G sharp on the keyboard there what we would call an harmonic equivalence because the keyboard is a twelve tone equal tempered system there might be situations where making that distinction between a flat and G sharp is actually musically preferable in one way or another that realization has been enormous ly influential on me to be 100% honest I'm still working my way through this book every page is something new and different and exciting for me I'm including this book here even though I haven't finished working my way through it because I think it's important to note that our perspectives are not fixed if I was to read building walking basslines for the first time now it wouldn't have the same impact on me as it did when I was a teenager and if I was to read harmonic experience when I was a teenager it would fall on deaf ears even if these books are not arriving at the right time for you maybe they're too late or too early in your musical career I hope you do find books that inspire you to put in the work to become a better musician these books certainly did for me [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music]
Up Next

Microtonal Composition: Exploring Microtunings in Music Theory
@signalfreud
654 views•2024-01-04

IFS Therapy Demonstration: Complete Session with Unburdening
@IFSCA
95.9K views•2021-01-13

Reharmonization of Run Away with Me: Jazz Theory Arrangement
@AdamNeely
799.4K views•2020-01-10

Game of Thrones Opening Credits: A Cinematic Analysis
@gameofthrones
46.3M views•2011-04-18
Related Study Plans & Knowledge Roadmaps
Structured learning paths in General & Interdisciplinary Studies












































