Aristotle's Six Types of Justice: Nicomachean Ethics Explained

Added:

John Rawls' 'Justice as Fairness' and Deontological Liberalism

While Aristotle's theory of justice is teleological—arguing that distribution and social roles should be based on merit, virtue, and a shared conception of the 'good life'—modern philosopher John Rawls offers a major counterpoint with his theory of 'Justice as Fairness.' Rawls rejects the idea that justice should be tied to moral desert or inherent virtue. Using his famous 'veil of ignorance' thought experiment, Rawls argues that a just society is one structured on principles that rational people would agree to if they did not know their own social status, talents, or conception of the good. This deontological approach prioritizes equal basic liberties and the protection of the least advantaged (the Difference Principle), rather than rewarding merit. For Rawls, the 'right' is prior to the 'good,' directly challenging Aristotle’s perfectionist view by asserting that a just state must remain neutral on what constitutes a virtuous life to respect individual autonomy in a pluralistic society.

Aristotle's Virtue Ethics: Understanding the concept of virtue (arete) as a state of character and the doctrine of the Golden Mean.
The concept of 'Eudaimonia': Knowing that Aristotle views human flourishing or happiness as the ultimate goal of human action and ethics.
Ethics versus Politics: Understanding that for Aristotle, individual ethics are deeply intertwined with the politics and laws of the state (polis).
Plato's Conception of Justice: Having a foundational grasp of Plato's 'Republic' to contrast his idealist view of justice with Aristotle's empirical and practical approach.
Modern Theories of Distributive Justice: Exploring John Rawls' 'A Theory of Justice' and Robert Nozick's libertarian critiques to see how Aristotelian ideas evolved.
Legal Philosophy (Jurisprudence): Analyzing how Aristotle's concepts of corrective and natural justice form the basis of modern tort law, criminal sentencing, and judicial systems.
Aristotle's Theory of Friendship (Philia): Examining Books VIII and IX of the Nicomachean Ethics to understand how civic friendship acts as a bridge between justice and the common good.
The Ethics of Restorative Justice: Comparing Aristotle's corrective justice with contemporary alternative dispute resolutions and restorative justice models.
26.8K views348likes25:33@GregoryBSadlerOriginal Release: 2013-12-01

In Book 5 of Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle identifies six distinct conceptions of justice: (1) Legal Justice (abiding by laws and rules), (2) Complete Virtue (cultivating moral character for the sake of others), (3) Distributive Justice (fair allocation of shareable goods like wealth and honors), (4) Corrective Justice (restoring fairness when distributions have gone wrong), (5) Reciprocity (mutual exchange of goods and services), and (6) Equity (flexible application of rules based on circumstances). These different senses of justice often conflict with each other, which explains why people frequently disagree about what constitutes fairness and right action.