George Dickie's Institutional Theory of Art Explained

Added:

Aesthetic Functionalism (Monroe Beardsley's Aesthetic Theory)

A major counterpoint to George Dickie’s Institutional Theory is Aesthetic Functionalism, championed by philosophers like Monroe Beardsley. While Dickie’s procedural approach defines art through social status conferred by an 'artworld,' Beardsley argues that art must be defined by its function: specifically, its capacity to produce an aesthetic experience. Under this view, an object is an artwork only if it was created with the intention of possessing aesthetic value or satisfying an aesthetic interest. Critics of the institutional theory argue that Dickie’s definition is circular and fails to explain why the artworld chooses to appreciate certain objects over others. Aesthetic functionalism shifts the focus back to the intrinsic properties of the object and the qualitative experience of the viewer, asserting that art cannot be reduced to mere social conventions or institutional designation.

The philosophical quest to define 'art', including traditional theories like Mimesis (imitation), Expressivism, and Formalism.
Morris Weitz's anti-essentialist argument (influenced by Ludwig Wittgenstein) that 'art' is an open concept and cannot be formally defined.
Arthur Danto's concept of the 'Artworld,' which laid the conceptual groundwork for Dickie's institutional approach.
Familiarity with Marcel Duchamp's readymades (such as 'Fountain') as the historical catalyst that challenged traditional aesthetic definitions of art.
Critiques of the Institutional Theory, specifically the circularity objection (defining art through the artworld and vice versa) and Richard Wollheim's dilemma.
George Dickie's own later revisions to his theory, transitioning from his early 1974 version to his 1984 framework in 'The Art Circle'.
Jerrold Levinson's Intentional-Historical Theory of Art, which arose as an alternative response to the limitations of institutionalism.
Applying the institutional theory to contemporary debates, such as determining the artistic status of AI-generated art, street art, or digital artifacts like NFTs.
3.9K views95likes16:31@GregoryBSadlerOriginal Release: 2020-01-21

George Dickie's institutional theory of art proposes that a work of art is an artifact upon which status has been conferred as a candidate for appreciation by persons acting on behalf of the art world, representing a third phase in the history of attempts to define art that moves beyond the failed imitation and expression theories of Phase 1 and the rejection of definition in Phase 2.