What Is Art? Three Philosophical Theories Explained

Added:

Anti-Essentialism and the Institutional Theory of Art

While Expressionism, Formalism, and Aesthetic Experience seek to define art through inherent properties (like emotion, form, or sensory response), critics argue these definitions are too restrictive. Anti-essentialists, inspired by Ludwig Wittgenstein, argue that 'art' is an open concept with no single defining essence. Building on this, the Institutional Theory of Art—championed by George Dickie and Arthur Danto—shifts the focus from what art *looks* or *feels* like to its social context. It proposes that an object becomes art not through intrinsic qualities, but because it is designated as such by the 'Artworld' (the network of artists, curators, and critics). This perspective explains how conceptual works, like Marcel Duchamp’s readymades, qualify as art despite lacking traditional formal or expressive beauty.

Introduction to Aesthetics: Understanding aesthetics as the branch of philosophy concerned with the nature of beauty, art, and taste.
The Concept of Mimesis: Familiarity with the classical Greek view of art as imitation or representation, particularly associated with Plato and Aristotle.
Philosophical Definition: Understanding how philosophers attempt to define abstract concepts using necessary and sufficient conditions.
Basic Art History: A general awareness of the historical transition from traditional representational art to modernism and abstract art.
Anti-Essentialism and Wittgenstein: Exploring Morris Weitz's argument that 'art' is an open concept that cannot be formally defined, relying instead on 'family resemblances'.
The Institutional Theory of Art: Studying George Dickie and Arthur Danto's theories, which argue that status as art is conferred by the social institutions of the 'artworld'.
Analyzing Avant-Garde and Conceptual Art: Applying the learned theories to challenging non-traditional works, such as Marcel Duchamp's readymades or John Cage's '4'33"'.
Cognitive Theories of Art: Investigating Nelson Goodman's view that art is primarily a system of symbols used for understanding and cognizing the world, rather than just provoking emotion or aesthetic pleasure.
1.2K views31likes13:43@kennethshouler3055Original Release: 2020-05-05

This video presents three major philosophical theories defining art: Expressionism (art as expression of emotion, where the highest state is when viewers share the artist's emotions), Formalism (art as 'significant form' that produces aesthetic experience), and Aesthetic Experience (art as that which produces aesthetic experience in the observer). Each theory is explained with examples and criticisms: Expressionism fails when viewers don't share the artist's emotions (e.g., Van Gogh's Starry Night); Formalism struggles with subjectivity in determining what is 'significant'; and Aesthetic Experience faces criticism that aesthetic experiences range from awe to repulsion, making it difficult to distinguish art from non-art.