Danto's Artworld Theory: Redefining Art Through Institutional Context

Added:

The Aesthetic Theory of Art

In direct opposition to Arthur Danto's institutional 'Artworld' theory, the Aesthetic Theory of Art—prominently championed by philosophers like Monroe Beardsley—argues that art must be defined by its intrinsic aesthetic properties and sensory qualities, rather than its social or institutional context. Beardsley posits that an object is a work of art if it is produced with the intention of satisfying an aesthetic interest or possessing aesthetic value, such as beauty, form, or expressive power. This viewpoint rejects Danto's claim that virtually identical objects (like Warhol's Brillo Boxes and ordinary supermarket boxes) can only be distinguished as art through theoretical and institutional consensus. Instead, traditional aestheticism asserts that art is fundamentally tied to the immediate, perceptual experience of the observer. By prioritizing the artwork's formal attributes over external art-historical narratives, this counterpoint challenges the idea that the 'artworld' holds the ultimate authority to define what qualifies as art.

The Mimetic Theory of Art: Understanding traditional definitions of art based on representation, imitation (mimesis), and physical beauty, dating back to Plato and Aristotle.
The Dada Movement and Duchamp's Readymades: Familiarity with how Marcel Duchamp's 'Fountain' challenged traditional aesthetic values and forced a paradigm shift in defining art.
The Distinction between Aesthetic and Artistic Properties: Grasping how an object's sensory properties (how it looks) differ from its artistic meaning and historical significance.
Basic Concepts in Aesthetics: Familiarity with the foundational philosophical question 'What is art?' and the limits of purely formalist definitions.
George Dickie's Institutional Theory of Art: Exploring Dickie's formalization of Danto's ideas, specifically how the 'artworld' confers the status of candidate for appreciation.
Arthur Danto's 'The End of Art' Thesis: Examining Danto's philosophical claim that art history, as a progressive narrative of self-definition, reached its end with Andy Warhol's Brillo Boxes.
Critiques of Institutionalism: Analyzing major objections to the theory, including issues of circularity, institutional elitism, and its struggle to explain 'outsider' or 'indigenous' art.
Application to Contemporary Art: Investigating how the institutional theory applies to modern artistic phenomena like street art (e.g., Banksy), conceptual art, and digital assets like NFTs.
5.3K views83likes4:58@andrewknoll8403Original Release: 2020-11-09

Arthur Danto argues that art cannot be defined by inherent properties of objects themselves (such as imitation, as proposed by Plato), but rather by whether something fulfills a specific role within the 'art world'—a human-made institution including museums, critics, and art historians—that confers artistic status on objects through social and institutional context rather than intrinsic qualities.