Justice Chandrachud & Tom Ginsburg on Saving Constitutionalism

Added:

Political Constitutionalism and the Critique of Juristocracy

Political constitutionalism argues that the primary guardian of constitutional values should be the democratic political process—specifically legislatures and the public—rather than unelected judiciaries. Critics of 'juristocracy' (such as Ran Hirschl and Richard Bellamy) argue that relying on courts to resolve fundamental social and political conflicts undermines democratic legitimacy, depoliticizes critical debates, and shifts power to legal elites. From this perspective, strong judicial review is not a neutral savior of democracy; instead, it can be counter-majoritarian, rigid, and insulated from the popular will. True constitutional resilience is built through robust political engagement, legislative deliberation, and democratic accountability, rather than judicial intervention.

The fundamental concept of Constitutionalism, specifically how it differs from mere rule by law and how it seeks to limit government power.
The principle of Separation of Powers and the role of Judicial Review in maintaining institutional checks and balances.
The core theories of Democratic Backsliding, including how modern democracies can degrade through legal or constitutional means rather than violent coups.
A basic understanding of the Indian Constitutional framework and the historically activist role of the Supreme Court of India.
Comparative Constitutional Law, analyzing how different nations (such as India, the US, and Hungary) structurally resist or succumb to authoritarian pressures.
The 'Basic Structure Doctrine' in Indian jurisprudence, exploring how the judiciary limits the legislature's power to amend the Constitution.
The concept of 'Militant Democracy' and constitutional self-defense, examining how democracies can legally protect themselves from internal subversion.
The tension between Judicial Activism and Democratic Legitimacy, evaluating when court interventions protect rights versus when they infringe on democratic processes.
48.9K views1.2Klikes1:01:04@UChicagoOriginal Release: 2019-10-22

Constitutional democracies face gradual erosion through five mechanisms—partisan degradation, charismatic populism, separation of powers manipulation, electoral machinery attacks, and public sphere undermining—requiring courts to serve as protectors of democratic principles while balancing judicial independence with accountability, as demonstrated by comparative analyses of India, the United States, and other nations experiencing democratic decline.