PhD Research: 'Free Economy' Metaphors in HK Political Discourse

Added:

Materialist Political Economy and Structural Realism

While discourse and metaphor analysis highlight how political actors frame Hong Kong's 'free economy' to legitimize policy shifts like CEPA, critics from materialist political economy and structural realism argue that this linguistic focus overemphasizes rhetoric at the expense of material realities. This counterpoint posits that Hong Kong's economic policy shifts are driven not by conceptual metaphors, but by objective structural pressures, institutional dependencies, and global capital flows. From this perspective, changes in political discourse are merely superficial, retrospective justifications (post-hoc rationalizations) for decisions dictated by hard economic necessities—such as integration with mainland China to maintain competitiveness—rather than active tools that shape political-economic reality. Consequently, focusing on linguistic framing risks treating the ideological symptoms of economic integration as its underlying cause.

Conceptual Metaphor Theory (CMT): Understanding how metaphors are not just rhetorical devices, but cognitive tools that shape how people perceive and reason about complex topics like the economy.
Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA): Familiarity with how language, power, and ideology intersect in political texts to construct social reality and influence public opinion.
Hong Kong's Post-1997 Political History: A basic understanding of the 'One Country, Two Systems' framework and the socio-political transitions in Hong Kong following the 1997 handover.
The Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement (CEPA): Knowledge of what CEPA is (signed in 2003) and its role in economically integrating Hong Kong with mainland China.
Diachronic Linguistics: The foundational concept of studying how language, vocabulary, and semantic frameworks change and evolve over a specific historical timeline.
Applying Corpus Linguistics Tools: Learning how to use software like AntConc or Sketch Engine to systematically extract and analyze metaphorical patterns in large text corpora.
Comparative Discourse Studies: Analyzing how 'free market' or 'economic integration' metaphors differ in other post-colonial or transitional regions (e.g., Taiwan, Macau, or post-Soviet states).
Policy-Making Rhetoric: Investigating how metaphorical framing in political discourse directly translates into public policy decisions and the public acceptance of economic reforms.
Post-2017 Discourse Analysis: Exploring how political and economic metaphors in Hong Kong have shifted further in response to major post-2017 events, such as the 2019 protests and the implementation of the National Security Law.
Multimodal Metaphor Analysis: Advancing to analyze how economic metaphors are communicated not just through text, but through political cartoons, propaganda videos, and digital media.
281 views0likes31:28@englpolyuOriginal Release: 2022-09-13

This study by Dr Winnie Zeng analyzes how economic metaphors (specifically 'free economy') are used in Hong Kong political discourse from 1997 to 2017, revealing that while fundamental changes in metaphor source domains are rare, incremental changes in how source-target mappings are applied occur frequently, particularly around significant political events like the 2003 Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement (CEPA) agreement between Hong Kong and Mainland China.