5 Legal Successors to the Roman Throne Explained

Added:

The Institutionalist Critique of Roman Succession

This perspective argues that the concept of a modern "legal successor" to the Roman Empire is a historical and constitutional fallacy. Unlike medieval and early modern European kingdoms, the Roman Empire (both in its classical and Byzantine phases) was fundamentally a civic and institutional state—a *res publica*—rather than the private property of a dynastic lineage. Historical Roman law and tradition dictated that imperial authority was derived from the institutions of the state, namely the Senate, the army, and the citizens, rather than pure hereditary right. Therefore, the empire's sovereignty could not be legally willed, sold, or inherited by foreign monarchs (such as the Spanish Crown purchasing claims). Once the institutional framework of the Eastern Roman Empire collapsed in 1453, the Roman state became extinct. Consequently, modern dynastic claims via lineage, conquest, or purchased titles are regarded by many historians as romanticized anachronisms devoid of genuine Roman constitutional legitimacy.

The historical division of the Roman Empire into the Western and Eastern (Byzantine) empires, and the ultimate fall of Constantinople in 1453.
The concept of 'Translatio Imperii' (transfer of rule) and how political legitimacy was claimed and transferred in medieval and early modern Europe.
The unique nature of Roman imperial succession, which historically relied on military acclamation, senate approval, or adoption rather than strict hereditary primogeniture.
The establishment and significance of the Holy Roman Empire under Charlemagne and its tension with the Byzantine Empire over the Roman title.
An in-depth analysis of the 'Third Rome' doctrine and its long-term influence on Russian imperial identity and foreign policy.
The Ottoman claim to the title of 'Kayser-i Rûm' (Caesar of Rome) under Mehmed II and how it merged Islamic and Roman political philosophy.
The role of dynastic marriages and the sale/transfer of imperial titles (such as Andreas Palaiologos's sales of his claims to European monarchs) in European diplomacy.
A comparative study of how successor states in other major historical civilizations (such as the Chinese dynastic cycle or the Persian Empire) established political legitimacy.
4M views80.2Klikes30:32@UsefulChartsOriginal Release: 2019-10-18

The question of who has the best claim to the title of Roman Emperor in 2019 has no simple answer, but examining five primary claimants reveals different perspectives: the Ottoman dynasty (heir to Sultan Mehmed II who conquered Constantinople in 1453), the Spanish royal family (through the legal will of the last Byzantine Emperor Constantine XI who left his titles to Ferdinand and Isabella), the Russian Romanov family (claiming Moscow as the 'Third Rome'), the Bonaparte family (through Napoleon's papal coronation), and the Habsburg family (who ruled the Holy Roman Empire from 1440-1912); however, a legal argument suggests King Philippe VI of Spain has the strongest claim as the direct heir through the unbroken line of succession from the Byzantine Emperor Andreas Palaiologos to the Spanish monarchy.