Animalism and Personal Identity: Philosopher Eric Olson Interview

Added:

Psychological Continuity Theory (Neo-Lockeanism)

While animalism argues that our identity is tied to our biological organism, the Psychological Continuity Theory (often associated with John Locke and modern philosophers like Derek Parfit) posits that personal identity consists in psychological relations. According to this view, what makes a person the same over time is the continuity of mental states, such as memories, beliefs, desires, and character traits, rather than the survival of a physical, biological body. To illustrate this, proponents often use thought experiments like brain transplants: if your mind and memories were transferred to another body, most people would intuit that you have survived in the new body. This perspective suggests that we are essentially thinking subjects, and that our persistence depends on psychological survival rather than mere biological life, directly challenging the animalist claim that we are fundamentally organisms.

The philosophical problem of personal identity, specifically the distinction between numerical identity over time and qualitative identity.
John Locke's psychological continuity theory of identity, which posits that memory and consciousness define the self.
Classic thought experiments in metaphysics, such as the 'Prince and the Cobbler' or brain-transplant scenarios, which challenge our intuitions about the self.
Basic metaphysical terminology, particularly the distinction between a 'person' (a moral/cognitive category) and a 'human animal' (a biological category).
The 'Too Many Thinkers' problem, which is a primary metaphysical objection raised against animalism.
Alternative physicalist accounts of identity, such as Constitutionalism (the view that we are constituted by, but not identical to, animals) and Jeff McMahan's Embodied Mind theory.
The bioethical implications of animalism, particularly how it affects the definition of death (e.g., whole-brain death vs. cardiopulmonary failure) and the moral status of patients in persistent vegetative states.
The compatibility of animalism with theories of survival, such as the metaphysics of resurrection or the possibility of technological mind uploading.
1.7K views42likes46:51@moscowcenterforconsciousne7974Original Release: 2019-05-29

Animalism is the philosophical view that human persons are biological organisms (animals), not immaterial souls or abstract entities; this view argues that since we observe ourselves as conscious biological entities and cannot conceive of a human being existing without being an organism, we must be animals, which also implies that personal identity depends on biological continuity rather than psychological continuity.