Democratization contributes positively to human progress through multiple mechanisms: democratic political institutions constrain executive power and protect human rights, nonviolent resistance movements are twice as successful as violent ones and lead to more stable democratic transitions, and while democracy's effects on economic outcomes vary by context and time horizon, it serves as a safety net that eliminates the worst outcomes. The effectiveness of democracy depends on specific institutional features like free media, judicial accountability, and civil society, rather than democracy alone.
Democratization's Bright Side: Progress, Rights & Development | Expert Panel
Added:I'm very pleased to welcome the three panelists Sabina Carey rika-chan Within's and Canadian crude so I like you to come up and join me behind the desk now so this first panel is entitled the bright side of democratization it will explore the idea that democratization is a partial cause of the human progress that Duvall has you know the 20th and with the first century and aspects related to that so um I'm extraordinary happy to introduce the members of this panel all three of them have risen very swiftly to internationally to be international leading scholars in this field and they bring together fascinating set of complementary approaches and competencies that promise a very stimulating exchange of ideas all three of them have published so widely and prominently and received so many prizes and awards that will be tedious to wisdom so I'll just give you a brief introduction to the research so first Sabina Kerry is professor of political science at University of Mannheim and co-editor of the American Political Science Review Sabine's research has been covering various aspects of repression and human rights violations her most recent research studies the role of pro-government militias and escalation political violence she'll also written extensively on the role of democratic political institutions and changes to them for oppression and human rights violations Erica Chenoweth is professor of political science an associate dean for research at the Josef Korbel School International Studies at the University of Denver because research has focused on why state and non-state groups use political violence what is the world what I will turn until the political violence and how can if nonviolent alternatives be promoted in particular her book on why civil resistance works is relevant today's topic as nonviolent popular movements are important not only for democratization itself but also for how democracy works to bring out beneficial outcomes finally Colin Richardson is professor of political science at University of Oslo and co-editor of Kahneman political studies a lot his also said we read in project that stuffin has introduced lot Shere Khan Hendricks research is concentrating on analyzing how democratic political institutions impact outcomes of interest to us in particular how democracy contributes economic growth income inequality and property rights protection as well as studying processes of them accreditation overall so I'll introduce this panel by showing you a few slides to set the stage for its implicit claim that the bright signs of democratization are related to human progress STOVL has touched upon on some of these ideas already so well some of these will be echoing some ones on his claims so very often our research in media's coverage of events we tend to focus on challenges societal problems to solve and negative changes to what we value this focus is important and all members of this panel are fully aware the dark side of democratization the dark side the world in more general still it's important to once in a while remind ourselves that humanity has experienced immense progress over the past decades and centuries so to illustrate this take a look at this graph it shows the trend in global and countrywide infant mortality rate which Staffan also mentioned from 1960 to 2015 the bold black line here is the population weighted global average of infant mortality rates in 1960 about 120 1,000 live born infants died before reaching the age of one year in a global average in 2015 this value is well below 50 the plot is on a log scale so actually only communicates the extent of this improvement this reduction about 60 to 70 percent has been nearly universal although stark inequalities persist the thin lines show the infant mortality rate for every country in the world so the vast majority of them I'm improved at the same rate as the global average and some spectacularly so such as South Korea's increased infant mortality rate by more than 95 percent over the over the last 50 years the exception to this pattern of improvement irrelevant to our panel the so many very few countries that have not improved at all are iraq north korea and zimbabwe the next slide shows the number of people killed in war a varied wave rare types from 1946 to 2016 in per capita terms the vertical axis shows the number of people per 100,000 inhabitants globally that die from direct path related deaths wars also killed people indirectly but these numbers follow the same trend we also see an even pattern human progress the current wars in the Middle East that are going today approach the horrors of the Vietnam near on WA and Iran Iraq Wars but the number of deaths in wars are very far from following the tripling of the global population over the last 70 years interstate Wars have become very rare and on average in internal armed conflicts have become slightly less lethal although they still are very common another improvement of great importance is the expansion of education seen in this slide it shows the proportion of the population in each of eight regions they've completed secondary education it shows observed lows from 1970 up to 2010 the projections of the 2100 Asian Latin America improved dramatically over the last 50 years with approximately education levels Africa's been lagging behind but demographers expect education level to raise quickly here too over the next decades based on the documentation that children to a large degree received education at least at levels of their parents and more strongly so on fertility rates are declining so the final slide the final slide shows the tremendous change the political institutions of the past 115 years based on the vm that said that stuff on just introduced but a slightly different coding of regime categories today about half of the countries in the world are democratic according to this classification that's the green portion the graph which has become white and top but it should be shaded in green only 15% are now clearing non-democratic the red portion and remainder or party Democratic so just after decolonization 50 years ago on 1/4 a democratic and 40 percent clay non democratic so these figures show that dress clear has been lots of human progress over the past decades and that this improvement coincides with a strong trend toward more democratic political institutions so there's several strong arguments implying the democratization has been contributing costly to this improvement the worst performance in terms of infant mortality rate for instance Iraq Zimbabwe North Korea have not been democratic but rather than making this argument all open up for a panel to discuss related issues as I was touching upon the challenges that are involved thank you Sabina okay thank you very much so I would like to focus on political institutions because political institutions have a profound impact on our lives political institutions they organize how political power can be used so democratic political institutions for example constrain how much power the executive has how that power can be used and they facilitate meaningful political participation so they limit how much power the government has and how they can use that power over their own populations and that leads to one of the really bright signs of democracy because research has consistently shown that countries with fully democratic political institutions are best at protecting the right to physical integrity so the right of people to be free from being tortured being killed being imprisoned by their own governments in this graph I'm showing you the percentage of countries with good human rights records meaning that generally respect the right of physical integrity that don't torture don't kill by democratic institutions you can see that right at the top and almost all countries have good human rights record if you go just a little bit bit that below sort of having fully entrenched political institutions this drops quite a bit and it doesn't actually get much worse for the very authoritarian regimes and this is somewhat similar pattern for another type of human right in this graph I'm showing the percentage of countries with free media again by the degree of how much political participation the country has and how constrained the executive is so if you don't have these types of features of political democratic institutions you don't have free media even some of these countries like Oman or Qatar respect human other basic human rights but at the top and almost all of them have free media now free media is essential really to the democratic process so much so that many would say and as we have seen in vdm is that if you don't have a whole range of civil liberties or press freedom you don't actually qualify as a democracy but pulling it apart it's quite interesting and lets us identify how different types of error or how different elements of democracy affect how common repression is for example in a recent study we have found that in countries that have just emerged from a civil war if they have free media they are much better at protecting basic human rights even above and beyond democratic institutions so free media is actually quite effective in protecting people from repression in otherwise quite repressive volatile and in stabile in stable conditions but this graph also shows that just having somewhat democratic political institutions isn't good enough right that it's not sufficient in protecting people from the power of the government in fact if you only focus on elections for example leaders could be incentivized or politicians to do almost anything to get votes which might have negative consequences for society as a whole for example by scaremongering or pushing populist agendas right um this leads me over to what I'd like to mention in my last slide in a recent study we've tried to understand while under what conditions journalists are murdered because journalists play a crucial role for the whole democratic process to work and we found that the more democratic some institutions are the more likely it is that journalists get killed so the more important popular participation is the more of the local politicians worry about their image the riskier it gets for journalists but that relationship crucially depends on the wider context of how Democratic this country is so in this graph I'm showing the probability of a journalist being killed by degree of electoral democracy at the bottom but for two different scenarios one the bluish one where churches are held accountable for their wrongdoings and the light one where judges are generally not held accountable for their wrongdoings and you can see that if judges are accountable to what they do then the risk of journalists being killed is very low and remains constant or independent of how much electoral democracy we have but if that's not the case if judges get away with their wrongdoings then the more electoral democracy we have the riskier it gets for journalists and that contributes to this wider picture that just focusing on election isn't enough it's not sufficient to just have elections or partial elements of democracy to protect basic human rights in fact it might even increase the risk of individuals who try and hold individual politicians to account but if we embed institutions in a wider process then we can really sort of reap the bright side of democracy in protecting basic human rights and repression but of course the question is still out in whether it's really various specific institutions like in strong participation and strong constraints on the executive that avoid repression or reduce the risk or whether that's other things like maybe free media that usually go together with having fully democratic institutions thank Sabina and welcome Erika good morning I'd like to focus on the question of how people wield power and generate democratic breakthroughs or protect democracy when there are political institutions actively exclude them or don't allow them to legally participate in the system so I want to talk about dissent and I want to compare two different models of dissent or bottom-up politics one being nonviolent resistance and the other being violent resistance so nonviolent resistance or civil resistance is when unarmed people actively confront an oppressive system or oppressive authorities using a variety of different coordinated methods that don't inflict physical or direct harm on their opponents so these might be a coordinated sequence of methods like protests strikes boycotts and many hundreds of other forms of economic political and social non-cooperation and they do this in kind of a sequenced way to where they're increasingly mounting disruption against the system and dislocating their opponent from its different sources of power so violent resistance of course is when people do inflict direct physical harm on their opponents in order to sort of wear down their capacity to withstand the challenge there are of course mixed methods of resistance but I want to focus for today on these two ideal types which provide us with a number of different stark comparisons the first thing I'd like mention in reference to today's topic is that nonviolent resistance has become an increasingly dominant form of dissent especially since about the 1970s this chart actually shows new onset of mass nonviolent and violent campaigns that are seeking maximalist goals meaning they're actively trying to overthrow an incumbent national leader through irregular means or they are trying to create territorial independence either through secession self-determination the expulsion of a foreign military occupation or the expulsion of a colonial power so this chart in the case of nonviolent resistance shows cases as diverse as Georgia's Rose Revolution the recent uprising in Burkina Faso Romania East Timor West Papua Poland the Philippines South Korea Tunisia Guatemala Zambia Mongolia South Africa and many other cases basically one of the things that's incredibly striking is the overall substitution of nonviolent resistance as the primary method of change in the past 40 or 50 years and then another really interesting trend is that the campaign's that rely primarily on nonviolent resistance tend to succeed twice as often as their violent counterparts now this is really important for a number of reasons related to today's theme my colleague Sabina Kerry has actually found that when she is evaluated protest and coercion events data that nonviolent resistance is less likely to evoke the worst forms of lethal oppression or repression directly against the protesters than violent dissent but in recent research with my colleague Evan / Koski we found even that that mass killings where regimes actually crack down and kill at least a thousand unarmed people and episodes of one-sided violence are much more common when civil wars or armed insurrection ZAR underway there incredibly on common against mass nonviolent campaigns even in highly similar contexts and I'll discuss a couple of reasons for that in a moment the second reason it's important is that nonviolent resistance is highly correlated with the eventual emergence of democratic regimes this slide actually shows a comparison of what happens in different countries five years after one of these major campaigns has ended and whether a country is likely to have broken through and the polity data set to be counted as an advanced democracy that is a plus 7 or higher on the polity scale so of course the the ill-fated polity data said at this point is what we relied on for this study but others have used vdm to replicate these results and found that they're quite consistent but basically what this slide shows and what's very striking is that countries that have experienced a mass non-violent uprising are some 10 times more likely to emerge as democracies within the next five years and this is true even when those nonviolent campaigns fail meaning that often mass disruption creates political opportunities or fissures within the ruling elites that then over time start to manifest through these pacted transitions that Professor della Porta was mentioning earlier another important outcome that's related to these data is that nonviolent campaigns are more likely to generate stable outcomes so the Egyptian uprisings of 2011 and 2013 are in many ways the epitome of what people think of when they think of mass uprisings today but in fact that case is somewhat exceptional in general campaigns countries that have faced nonviolent mass campaigns are about 15 percent less likely to relapse into civil conflict within a decade afterward so I mentioned I would return to this question of why these nonviolent campaigns are so more likely to succeed and are also less correlated with mass atrocities authoritarian ISM and civil conflict and it's related in a way to the things that these mass nonviolent campaigns tend to do well that make them succeed in the first place the first thing they do well is they and that makes them win is that they can build and sustain large and diverse participation so if a campaign is openly nonviolent or has expressed a commitment to nonviolent resistance it tends to elicit the participation of men women children elderly people with disabilities and others that may be marginalized in the society the ability to create those cross-cutting coalition's then activates a number of different political opportunities for these movements that wouldn't exist if it was very homogenous for example it can allow these movements to begin to pull on the relationships that the participants have with people that reside in the security forces or that are business and economic deletes civilian bureaucrats public intellectuals state media and other forms of pillars in the society on whose rely on whose obedience the power holder relies to maintain power so in a very concrete example of this in October of 2000 when hundreds of thousands of people had descended on Belgrade to demand that slobodan milosevic leave power the security forces refused when ordered to use live fire on the demonstrators and afterward when journalists and scholars went and interviewed these police and asked them why they refused to shoot they said things like I thought I saw my children in the crowd or I thought I saw the guy who sells me liquor at a discount on Saturdays in the crowd and this demonstrates the power of people power which is to say very large and diverse coalition's mean that the participants themselves are related in a way to the different arms of state power and that can undermine those arms in key moments that then proved to be decisive another thing that they do is they use a variety of non-violent methods so this simply means that successful campaigns don't just use protests a day after day after day but they start to shift between protests and more disruptive methods like strikes finally they tend to maintain discipline even when repression begins to escalate movements that are able to stick to their own plan and maneuver around repression are much more likely to remain resilient in the face of it so with that I'll simply mention that the the data that we now have access to on the remarkable record of nonviolent resistance I think is an important and often underappreciated part of the democratization story over the last century thank you Thank You Erika and welcome : dick thank you so I'm going to switch focus talking about whether or not democracy matters for for the stuff that a lot of people truly care about food on the table long and prosperous lives things that are very tangible and important to everyday people so does democracy foster economic and human development of various various kinds and this is supposed to be a bright side of democracy panel so so I I guess there is bound to be some positive conclusions but I'm also going to throw in a few shades of gray and and be a bit boring and say it matters according to several several criteria starting out with the with the theoretical arguments why would we expect democracy to be good for for economic development and human development there are several elaborate arguments but I think one of the most powerful powerful arguments is a very simple one so we have political elites you have politicians and we must assume that these politicians they're not necessarily altruistic they don't necessarily care about the populations they they rule over but they care about themselves and they care about being in power and then you have the masses you have the populations who care about food on the table and the beautiful thing about democracy is that there is a link between the population and the mall and the politicians through elections through competitions in through competition between parties the populations will simply vote out to power those that do not provide food on the table so this there is this beautiful argument very simple linking people to good outcomes force politicians to provide prosperous lives to them when we look at it empirically however when you look at the data it's not all that clear cut so democracy is lead associated with several good outcomes stuff on short slide on infant mortality over the show some slides as well and I'll show a new slide on infant mortality that's one of the features where we see that that electoral democracy really matters but there are other aspects where we would assume theoretically that democracy matters / we don't find any evidence in in the data or at least non robust evidence redistribution for example not as a clear difference between democracies and dictatorships and so so so that's one aspect to keep in mind it depends on which aspect we look at in terms of development but the other thing is that it's really really hard to identify the effects of democracy so it goes together there are several institutions that go together so how can we separate the effects of democracy from for example the capacity of the state institutions from culture from geography from other other things so that's also going to be a key key part of my talk so I'm going to focus on it's difficult to identify clear effects of democracy but I'm going to talk about three three general points that I think we can take with us from from this literature and I'm going to illustrate with some of some of my own research findings the first relates to democracy as a safety net so although it's not clear whether or not democracy on average is better than dictatorship it tends to eliminate the worst outcomes it tends to do fairly well no matter what the second point relates to to this this notion that I've already been been talking about it depends on which particular outcome we look at and the third goes back to to Stefan's presentation on VD I'm going to show you some medium data as well it depends on which aspect of democracy we're focusing on so just to take up this point so for example I've been working a lot with with democracy and economic growth and there are I guess a couple of hundred studies on that now with diverging findings on whether or not there is in on average an effect but what it's very clear from from that literature if you look at the studies that look at the variation within regimes is that some democracies do better than others so some democracies don't work as we would expect but when you look at the dictatorships the variation is enormous so just to illustrate so this is the skyline of Singapore and so Singapore perhaps the best example of an authoritarian regime that developed very rapidly economically even giving rise to the so called lis thesis that you need a strong dictatorship to to get economic development after the old leader Lee Kuan Yew so this is just the illustrate beautiful skyscrapers in Singapore another country that has not been as fortunate under autocracy with with its economic development is current a Democratic Republic of Congo former Zaire and here you have two of the leaders of that country during colonial rule and and post-liberation Leopold and Loeb Bhutto I'm not going to go into the story of Congo but it's very very different from their from the development of Singapore to say the least second point Devils in the details in regards the outcome so here is and this is a another video a paper on on infant mortality finding many of the same results that stuff on talked about electoral democracy matters for reducing infant mortality rates and one important aspect here in terms of of the devil is in the details is is thinking about the time dimension so here we're looking at the history of electoral democracy and and one key takeaway from the literature is that it takes some time before the positive effects of democratization manifests itself here's the nother outcome and this is from from a recent article I done with Syria on the dalam who is now postdoc at at University of Gothenburg where we look at education quality so we might believe that that democracies are better at providing high-quality education so we find that democracies they provide education to to more kids than autocracies do but when we look at how their students actually perform what they learn in school there's not much of a difference so this is the shade of gray and in the bright side panel education quality not so strongly related to democracy third and finally and and we've already seen a lot of slides on on vdm this is just another one I just wanted to bring this up this is Brazil separating between free and fair elections and freedom of discussion for men in blue just to illustrate the point that democracy is a very broad concept it involves a lot of can be defined in different ways involves a lot of institutions that are very different and it's very plausible to assume that these institutions have very different effects on economic outcomes so this is just to illustrate the importance of this entangling and I'll mention just but as a background slide one example from recent research phonetics calling from from Oris University when my co-authors on the on this paper is here and it's also quoted with John Geering at University of Texas Austin and going back to this relationship between democracy and growth using the vdm data what we actually find is that democracy at the local level is much more strongly related to economic growth than democracy at the national level actually that it's a very very robust finding and thinking about the policies that actually drive growth in terms of service provision education a lot of the action actually happens at the local level so being able to discipline your your local politicians to dig wells to provide high quality education that really seems to matter for for overall growth and then finally this is the Bastille in 1789 of course you saw the sort of graph on how freedom of discussion and free and fair elections in Brazil they tend to move together this also means that it's hard to separate the facts from various democratic institutions sorry so one solution to that is trying to move backwards in time to get as much variation over time as possible to use all the rich variation from from modern history and together with with the on Terrell who is going to be in the next panel I'm adding a project that extends a lot of the Vida indicators back in time to 1789 so here we have this data that is not release yet but here is just a quick glimpse into the the polyarchy the electoral democracy measure going back to 1789 for a set of countries from this data set and I think this will be of key importance to us when we going forward try to disentangle the effects of various institutions on things such as economic growth infant mortality education etc so thank you thank you Col Eric so Norman bytes the panel to react a bit to each other's presentations all and then we'll probably have time for a couple of questions from the audience too I'll just get our conversation started by noting one thing so picking up on on the presentation on by stuff on address lots of variation in in democracy lots of democracy is a very multi-dimensional thing there are lots of different aspects of democracy that serve to jointly define what what democracy is also lots of variation between autumn water return systems so one question is what are the most important more detailed aspects of democracy or autocracy for that sake that explains that explains the outcomes that we are really interested in promoting such as economic growth poverty reduction and also absence of repression and for the sake also the what institutions are really important in in allowing nonviolent movements to to succeed not be taken over by non while going swimming or being depressed so maybe Colin you could start bit on on which detailed institutions are most important across both democratic not authoritarian systems that I think a lot of people would point to the importance of having an impartial meritocratic Lee recruited bureaucracy the state administration they got the quality that it's it's it's been the focus of a lot of research and and the ability of the state administration to implement policies but I want to focus on something different that also comes out from the VM data it's the world and commercials for the mission data today but one key feature and and this has also been out there in the literature both there there have been two separate literature's on on parties in democracy some parties in in particularly regime parties in authoritarian regimes and in some instances you have strong parties that discipline the the leader that are well organized hierarchically organized and where things are done according to the rule book I think for instance of leadership changes in China and this in a study on economic growth we find that this really really matters for economic growth both in democratic context and in authoritarian so there are some institutional dimensions that are more or less orthogonal to to democracy there are key to explaining these these outcomes so that would be one party institutionalization if you like okay so for repression I think I'm gonna pick something else although I would like to preamble this by saying it really is in the mix so I think just picking one institution and saying that will do the trick I just don't think it will so it is always the mix but I guess if I had to pick that I would I think what's really important is not popular participation because I think that can really backfire in the wrong context but rather constraining the executive because the executive has the power to use force on our security forces and how they use it and against whom they can use it and with whom they have to check before they use it and so in terms of repression I think constrain the executive is quite important and in a different study we've shown that if the executive is constrained and using the military for for mass murder is much less likely but if you have a strong executive that's not constrained then that risk goes in the other way but a second one I should also mention and I think the more I look into this the more it seems like free media and having really free press and free speech is essential so it's not something we consider or I have traditionally considered as a key Democratic institution but element of a liberal democracy that I think is crucial in protecting human rights well you probably won't be surprised to hear me say that I think the protection of a robust civil society is probably the most important feature in either a democracy or an authoritarian regime to avoid the worst outcomes I think this is consistent with what Professor Lindberg had presented earlier about the necessity of presence of a civil society and an assuring Democratic survival but I do think we need more research on understanding the types of capacities that are necessary for civil societies in order to effectively mobilize particularly in longer term conflicts where sustained coalition's are necessary I will also mention that in some recent research I've done with Jo Felder we tried to understand whether nonviolent uprisings were predictable using different structural factors so it's similar to a question that professor della Porta brought up this morning about whether there's any ability to sort of observe a latent revolution on the way or whether we'll always be surprised by them and we basically found that they're almost impossible to predict with a lot of accuracy but there are two features of societies that seem to come out as as demonstrating at least a latent capacity for quick mobilisation the first is a history of strikes because strikes are the most disruptive form of non-cooperation economically and they also demonstrate an ability for civil society to organize disruptive collective action fairly quickly and then the second factor is actually an increase in repression an increase in repression tends to motivate people to first of all become outraged that their apology is slipping away and secondly mobilized to defend it so it's actually in many ways the reverse of the conventional wisdom the conventional wisdom is that as societies become more repressive people resort to nonviolent techniques less and in fact it's the opposite what's one fascinating one thing which is missing from all the responses is is the freedom free elections which is find a bit striking oh I would perhaps think that free and fair elections are important to support lots of these positive aspects of institutions like strong impartial burocracy strong parties is evident linked to elections so what is the role of free and fair elections here sorry for having under communicated that because I think for many of the outcomes and and again I think a lot of good things have been said about the importance of packages of institutions and things mattering in the presence of other things such as checks on the executive etc but free and fair elections this is key to this this accountability argument I think especially when it comes to to several types of economic policies I think holding your your politicians accountable if kids die in rural areas or if your kids are not allowed to go to school it's crucial and that's also when when trying to disagree gate for for example for infant mortality this is why the free and fair elections turns out to be very very important and far more important it seems from the data than several of the other aspects of democracy so again I think it depends on on the outcome you're looking at if if it's related to violence I think the checks on the executive is key but when it comes to to providing basic services you can't do without free and fair elections I want to say that we should stop having free and fair elections that's obviously not my intention but if you think about it if you really want to implement free and fair elections you need a host of other things so if you want to make sure that those you know poorer community communities in maybe away from centers where you vote or they might have the time to vote because they need to do other important things then you know how fair is it or if you think about okay free and fair elections need to be based on an informed electorate so how can the electrode be informed well in fact well you need a flourishing media a balanced media ideally or a diverse media otherwise you know how free and fair are the elections so it kind of depends on what you see what you need in addition to having free and fair elections where you just have the ability to go and make a tick in the box and that won't count so picking up on free and an active media what's the importance of new information technology social media and so forth that's there's no turn to media channel to the standard journalist maybe so many social media channels are less sensitivity repression and to the to the danger that journalists are faced with in when faced with a repressive government so Eureka well I mean I think social media digital technology is a double-edged sword certainly for the types of movements I study on the one hand I think that there was a coordination and communication advantage when these technologies were emerging at this point I think basically governments have figured out how to use them to their advantage more so so I think actually online organizing particularly sort of semi authoritarian or authoritarian context is much more it exposes people to much greater risk actually of surveillance and detection and I also think that in in a lot of democracies it can tend to demobilize the most disruptive forms of contention because they people feel like by sitting in their house clicking on something they've they've conducted an act of resistance that said there is research out there conducted by the Carnegie Endowment and other are funded by that Carnegie Endowment and other organizations that shows that certainly the number of protest events for example has increase when people are using Twitter and other forms of social media to communicate about them to me the the downside of that is simply that it might routes an eyes or make more common the use of protests as opposed to these other forms of more disruptive activity so I think that you know the the Internet has certainly created some opportunities but it's it's more of a characteristic of our time than a cause of different types of protest and and contentious activity so that's what I would say about it well I think in terms of repression mmm social media has a great potential in the sense that it's an additional source of information independent of what governments are reporting or that sort of traditional journalists are able to reach so you get a access to a whole lot more of information with pictures and everything else so that's certainly I think a good thing but it also has some danger so the one is that Eric already mentioned an eater Cordes wrote a PhD on how the government extremely effectively uses the internet to repress better basic beings uses the example of the Syrian civil war but I think we see more of that probably in the future I mean I quite tech-savvy as well those repressive autocrats but the other let's say challenge is that with the growth in social media it contributes to a dis integration of the media market or a disintegration of the sources of information so people get now far more sources of information which means and they can be far more selective in what they have which often results to people consuming totally different source of information usually the ones that are Ian's firm already their prejudices or their views or their beliefs which you know could further lead to disintegrate in communities and societies which is no you're not a good thing in the long run got any questions from the audience we could talk Porat Stein my name is bill Rothstein I'm currently on the run from Oxford University a question - I agree very much of course as you know when you say that an important asset for creating human welfare is competent meritocratic lis recruited civil service however is there a conflict between democratization and this because what do you seem to see in the word that a newly elected government in a transition political system seemed not to be able to resist the temptation of rewarding their supporters with positions in the public sector and this is a the variation is pretty gigantic if I'm now collecting numbers you know if there is a change of government tomorrow in Mexico 70,000 civil servants have to live in Brazil it's 22,000 South Africa 10,000 in Argentina I think 20,000 in the u.s. 5,000 and then you come to Europe there is quite some variation here between Greece and the lowest figure we found is Denmark 26 and as you know Denmark is you know becoming Denmark is so and it seems and this is also a question for for Donatella I mean if if the civil society is mobilizing so much for a transition the people who are active in the transition they want rewards and one thing they want is jobs in the public sector so how can you handle this that new governments when they come in simply fill the the public sector with political cronies Thanks this is this is one of the key questions I think going going forward once we start collecting these these data across across the world and across time on both features of of state administrations and and and and democracy I think no there's there's not an inherent contradiction here and I think the relationship is very complex it's hard to disentangle there are good reasons to think that gradually over time as you have at least the well-functioning democracy you may that may help in building a better state administration and there are certainly also theories suggesting that if you have state administration's with certain correcting characteristic and democracies will be more stable in addition these may interact right so so does it matter what do you have both at the same time or only one so it's it's a complex question but I think the tendency to stop stuff the civil service with or administration with with your own supporters is also something you observe when regime changes occur going in the other direction when you have changes between between autocratic regimes now there are certain autocracies that are able to stick to meritocratic ways recruitment having fairly stable careers others others do not and so I think I'll I won't provide anything any clear answers to one story but but I I think disentangling these relationships I think it's super super interesting and I hope to several of us can can work with that going forward Johnna Underland on the short answer to both varieties of democracies resonate with varieties of capitalism which is important in terms of topologies and I think it is important for all the issues you have addressed that besides the type of freedoms and so on the democratic states and outer Italian states have very different relationship with the market so that former socialist countries could be as repressive as Pinochet in Chile but the type of relationship with between market and the state was a totally different one and in terms of non-violence research by Libby woods forests and said under some type of capitalist exploitation you cannot have nonviolent forms of transitions to democracy so I was wondering if in your research this combination on the side of the independent variables of qualities of democracies and type of varieties of democracies and varieties of capitalism is important and about both questions I think that there are also different equilibrium so if I look at Italy in Germany we have reports in Germany and you have not eaten in Italy but in Germany you have an equilibrium between meritocracy and political visions and thank you sure so it's a great point and to my knowledge nobody has yet done a study to try to understand the impacts of different forms of capitalism on the onset of nonviolent or violent resistance using the data that we now have I think that that actually sounds like a really interesting and promising project but one of the things that jiayou Felder and I did was we looked at different kinds of economic outputs and economic performance that would be you know roughly equivalent to different capitalist outcomes so GDP per capita economic output infant mortality relatives as global mean economic shocks unemployment rates integration into the liberal international economy and so forth and we found that none of those factors significantly predicted the onset of non violent versus violent resistance or the success of them so in that sense I'm a little dubious that that claim holds over a long period of time and over all the cases that we evaluated but it's certainly a hypothesis available for further testing so basically I think that the varieties of capitalism literature has has not been I think there's there's room for first pole research there going forward it's not been very well integrated with the Democratic survival democratization literature either and and one very pragmatic aspect that I think explains that is the typical countries that are being looked at and the availability of data so the varieties of capitalism literature has starting out with two core models but focusing on Western Europe and North America and then gradually expanding to to some other industrialized countries and this is where the main data collection and and and studies happen whereas in recent years most of the action in terms of democracy has been in other regions so I think for for that to happen and I think there are several I think several interesting research questions come bubbling up and when you mention that but I think there would need to be a greater attention to longer longer time series and having clear indicators that would be coded not only in in in the western part of the world but also globally I think that also applies to I think the repression literature that sort of overall as far as recall is telling that there isn't a clear link between you one type of isn't being much better than the but there hasn't been much research in disaggregating the different types of cattle ISM capitalism and my hunch would be that what might matter is less how capitalist or communist or whatever you are but rather like how the the economic system you have how that empowers different elements in society to participate in the political process and different economic systems can do that differently so I think that would be really interesting to find out more about this and I don't think we have much research on that question supplement it a bit by looking at mean I don't have a view on the varieties capitalism but just the presence of capital the mobile capitalist there's lots of research showing that when there is ample mobile capital both in terms of mmm financial capital blows and human capital there are several of these outcomes that we are interested in that are more easily achieved such as democratic stability is democracy a much more stable where there is lots of human and movable financial capital absence of armed conflict the same much fewer calm armed conflicts even worse in which capital rich countries also evidence that Democratic public institutions are more effective in reducing the amount or the risk of armed conflicts whether is mobile capital capital and that probably related to what Sabine just mentioned that human capital mobile capital empowers more societies more activist in in these societies beyond the those that you have political power to give any other questions for the parallel EU Oh any other questions okay Patricia just a quick question from the philosopher so we were speaking about the extrinsic values you get from the maca see here well-being economic growth stability there seems to be several extrinsic values and my question is where to find tomorrow that democracy does not give the optimum output in these extrinsic values with that the constitute and an argument with that constitute reason to change our allegiances in terms of regime towards autocratic forms of government or are there intrinsic values to democracy that would trump those extrinsic values well if I may just speak to that it when you were asking the question that reminded me of Bob putnams work and just looking at what he argues is making democracy work but really what is created there prefigured through social capital or in his sense kind of a positive social capital and he brings up concepts like trust reciprocity community engagement a sense of personal efficacy a sense of the ability to alter the course of one's own existence and that these would be sort of the intrinsic values that not democracy per se but the the experience of creating democracy through social capital and political engagement creates for people so I mean there there are manifestations of that certainly and non-democratic regimes but I think generally speaking those would be the values that people are attracted to about the ability to freely assemble and gather and talk politics and democracy so that's that's the tough tough question and and and the answer often in in public would be that I don't want to touch touch the question I think most most democracy researchers after a couple of beers in in the evening would say we would still want to hold on to the democracy I guess this there are intrinsic values to to democracy but but still there there are legitimate empirical questions on on these relationships now that feeds into the debate because if a democracy tends to go into into other or produce other good outcomes then there is not much of a debate I think from a normative standpoint if there are trade-offs then there will be a debate and people with with different inclinations utilitarians may for example answer the question in one way they would maybe prioritize food on the table but but then there is placed a debate but then we have a clear clear view of what the what the facts are the on which that debate can be I think the answer to your question is well uh my answer is sort of some sort of standard somewhat boring social science in a sense that it really depends on what you actually mean because it very much depends on what we mean by democracy right because a lot of the things that you say might be intrinsic values you could say actually outputs of having some certain sets of institutional features like free speech freedom of religion and these sorts of things which unique again the freedom of media could be intrinsic but it could also be a result but nevertheless I think it's interesting what you mentioned that there could be trade-offs right and I think that is always and that might depend on the context especially if you folks are in transition periods right how do you deal with former perpetrators of violence for example there might be certain traders that you might be willing to accept a certain lack of accountability let's say or you might accept and more power of the military then you might ideally want in order to have a stable and say system where you have less repression and you have free and fair and and meaningful elections so there could always be trade off especially during transitory periods okay thanks so since this is the bright side democratization I'll just also respond to this just by remind you that I interpret the penalty taking that was extrinsic values of democracy that a democracy avoid the worst outcomes at least at the very minimum energy lots of other Possible's don't democratization so with that I think I'll close this panel and we'll given all be launched and we are supposed to reconvene at 13:30 for the second panel on the entire sides of democratization so I'll get back to these issues [Applause] [Music]
Up Next

The Secret Ballot: 1856 Australian Democratic Reform Explained
@NationalMuseumofAust
22.5K views•2018-09-07

Patronage and Political Machines in Southeast Asian Elections
@NewYorkSoutheastAsiaNetwork
511 views•2023-04-05

Government Surveillance Methods: 10 Ways You May Be Watched
@BeAmazed
1.6M views•2017-04-09

Explaining the Saudi-Iranian Proxy Conflict in the Middle East
@Vox
18.2M views•2017-07-17
Related Study Plans & Knowledge Roadmaps
Structured learning paths in Political Science







































