Power-Sharing & Inclusive Conflict Management | Keynote Lecture

Added:

Centripetalism and the Integrationist Critique of Power-Sharing

While consociational power-sharing seeks to manage conflict by guaranteeing political representation to distinct identity groups, critics argue this approach 'freezes' and institutionalizes ethnic divisions, preventing long-term reconciliation. The leading alternative, Centripetalism (or the integrationist approach), argues that political systems should instead encourage cross-ethnic cooperation and moderate, trans-communal politics. Rather than reserving seats for specific groups, centripetalism utilizes mechanisms like preferential voting to incentivize politicians to appeal to voters outside their own ethnic communities. Critics of traditional power-sharing point out that rigid quotas often lead to political gridlock, entrench wartime elites, and exclude citizens who do not identify with the dominant groups, thereby hindering the growth of a shared civic identity.

Foundational concepts of Consociationalism, particularly Arend Lijphart's theory of power-sharing and consensus democracy in deeply divided societies.
Basic understanding of conflict resolution terminology, including the distinction between conflict management, conflict settlement, and conflict transformation.
The core differences between majoritarian (winner-take-all) democratic systems and proportional representation systems.
Familiarity with the distinction between 'corporate' power-sharing (which guarantees representation to predefined groups) and 'liberal' power-sharing (which protects representation based on political alignment).
In-depth comparative analysis of landmark power-sharing case studies, such as the Good Friday Agreement in Northern Ireland, the Dayton Accords in Bosnia and Herzegovina, and the Taif Agreement in Lebanon.
The 'Inclusion Dilemma' in peace processes, exploring how to integrate civil society, women's groups, and non-aligned minorities into elite-dominated power-sharing frameworks.
Advanced theories of Centripetalism (e.g., Donald Horowitz's theories on electoral incentives for moderation) as an alternative approach to conflict management.
The challenges of democratic transition, focusing on institutional gridlock and the long-term reform of transitional power-sharing arrangements into stable, permanent democracies.
104 views1likes39:52@UCDCollegeofSocialSciencesLawOriginal Release: 2024-03-22

Power sharing has become a leading prescriptive device for divided societies, yet it faces significant challenges across its entire life cycle: adoption difficulties (as seen in Syria), functional problems (as in Lebanon), and reform resistance (as in Bosnia). Despite continued support from international mediators and scholars, the pace of power-sharing adoption has stalled, and there are emerging signs of 'inclusion fatigue' as geopolitical dynamics shift away from negotiated settlements toward military solutions. The concept itself suffers from linguistic complexity, with terms like 'power sharing' translating differently across languages and contexts, leading to misunderstandings and conceptual ambiguity. Power-sharing scholars must recommit to making the normative case for inclusion rather than relying solely on instrumental arguments about process sustainability, while also addressing the linguistic and conceptual challenges that hinder effective communication and implementation.