Can Lebanon Disarm Hezbollah? Sovereignty vs. State Within a State

Added:

The 'Army, People, and Resistance' Defensive Deterrence Formula

This perspective argues that Hezbollah's military wing is not an impediment to Lebanese sovereignty, but its essential guarantor against external aggression, particularly from Israel. Proponents of the 'Army, People, and Resistance' formula contend that the Lebanese Armed Forces (LAF) are structurally and materially under-equipped—often restricted by Western donors—to defend the nation's borders, airspace, and maritime resources. From this viewpoint, Hezbollah acts as a necessary asymmetric deterrent that fills a critical security vacuum. Rather than viewing the group simply as a disruptive 'state within a state' or an Iranian proxy, this narrative frames Hezbollah as a legitimate national defense force. Advocates argue that forcing disarmament without a robust, independent national military alternative would leave Lebanon vulnerable to foreign invasion and destabilizing security deficits, meaning sovereignty is preserved, not weakened, by the resistance's armed deterrence.

The history of the Lebanese Civil War (1975–1990) and the Taif Agreement, which led to the disarmament of most Lebanese militias except Hezbollah.
The concept of 'confessionalism' in Lebanon's political system, which distributes political representation and power along sectarian lines.
The origins of Hezbollah in the early 1980s as a Shiite paramilitary movement funded and trained by Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC).
The basic political science definition of state sovereignty, particularly Max Weber's concept of the state's monopoly on the legitimate use of physical force.
The legal framework and implementation challenges of UN Security Council Resolution 1701, which calls for the disarmament of all armed groups in Lebanon.
The economic and governance crises in Lebanon, analyzing how the dual-power structure affects international aid, sovereignty, and state collapse.
Comparative politics studies of other hybrid security actors globally, such as the Popular Mobilization Forces (PMF) in Iraq or the Houthis in Yemen.
Future strategic scenarios for the Lebanese Armed Forces (LAF) and the feasibility of a national defense strategy that integrates or neutralizes paramilitary forces.
88.5K views3.6Klikes12:22@JamesKerLindsayOriginal Release: 2025-08-22

This video explores how Lebanon confronts the challenge of disarming Hezbollah, an Iranian-backed militia that has functioned as a 'state within a state' for over 40 years. The analysis examines how Hezbollah emerged during the Lebanese Civil War with Iranian support, grew into a dominant political and military force, and now faces potential disarmament amid weakened conditions following recent conflicts. The content illustrates the broader challenge of removing armed non-state actors from weak or divided states, where such groups often provide essential services and maintain strong community support, making disarmament both necessary for state sovereignty and potentially destabilizing if not carefully managed.