Syntax: DP Movement & Case Theory Explained by Andrew Carnie

Added:

Non-Derivational Syntax (HPSG and LFG)

While Andrew Carnie’s explanation of DP movement relies on a transformational, derivational framework where constituents physically move to satisfy abstract Case and EPP features, alternative syntactic theories reject the concept of movement entirely. Frameworks like Head-Driven Phrase Structure Grammar (HPSG) and Lexical-Functional Grammar (LFG) utilize a non-derivational, constraint-based approach. Instead of DPs physically moving from a lower clause to a higher one, these theories explain raising constructions through 'structure sharing.' In this view, a single argument is simultaneously associated with multiple grammatical functions across different predicates, governed by static unification constraints. Furthermore, these theories argue that abstract Case and the Extended Projection Principle (EPP) are unnecessary theoretical machinery, resolving agreement and grammatical relations through feature-matching systems instead. This eliminates the need for complex, invisible movement operations, offering a computationally robust alternative to the transformational analysis.

Understanding of X-bar theory and basic phrase structure, particularly the internal structure of Determiner Phrases (DPs) and Tense Phrases (TPs).
Familiarity with Theta Theory, including how thematic roles (like Agent and Theme) are assigned and the requirements of the Theta Criterion.
A foundational grasp of syntactic movement (specifically A-movement) and the concept of 'traces' or copy theory of movement.
An introductory awareness of the Extended Projection Principle (EPP) and its demand that clauses have subjects.
Contrasting Raising constructions with Control constructions (e.g., the structural differences between 'John seems to be happy' and 'John tries to be happy').
Applying DP movement and Case Theory to passive constructions, including an exploration of Burzio's Generalization.
Exploring the Minimalist Program's approach to Case and Agreement, focusing on feature valuation and the 'Agree' operation.
Investigating A-bar movement (such as Wh-movement and Topicalization) and comparing its constraints and landing sites with A-movement.
14.3K views249likes18:22@CarnieSyntaxthEditionOriginal Release: 2020-09-29

In generative syntax, DPs move in raising constructions (e.g., 'John is likely to leave') because they need to reach case positions—specifically the specifier of TP for nominative case, the complement of V for accusative case, or the complement of P for prepositional case. The case filter requires that all DPs must have their case features checked in local configurations, and this abstract case licensing, combined with the Extended Projection Principle's requirement for subjects, motivates DP movement from their base positions in embedded clauses to higher clause positions where they can receive proper case assignment.