Intergenerational Justice and Climate Change Policy | Gresham College

Added:

Presentist Prioritarianism and the Development-First Critique

Presentist Prioritarianism, or the 'Present-Generation-First' perspective, challenges the focus on intergenerational climate justice by arguing that our primary moral obligation is to alleviate the immediate, severe suffering of the currently living population. Proponents, including some development economists, argue that aggressively diverting vast resources toward long-term climate mitigation can harm present-day developing nations. By prioritizing hypothetical future generations—who are projected to be wealthier and technologically superior—over today's impoverished populations who lack basic needs like clean water, healthcare, and electricity, climate-centric policies may perpetuate current global inequality. Furthermore, this view suggests that fostering robust economic development today is a more effective strategy, as it equips future societies with the economic resilience and technological capacity to adapt to climate challenges far better than we can today.

The economic concept of the 'Tragedy of the Commons' and how shared-resource systems are depleted by individual self-interest.
Basic principles of environmental ethics, specifically distributive justice and how societies allocate benefits and burdens.
The fundamentals of international climate policy, including major frameworks like the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC).
The concept of discounting in economics, which is used to determine how much future costs and benefits are valued in today's terms.
Advanced climate economics, including the use of Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs) to calculate the social cost of carbon.
Legal frameworks and climate litigation cases that leverage the rights of future generations (e.g., youth-led climate lawsuits).
The application of game theory to global environmental politics and the challenges of international treaty compliance.
Evaluating specific intergenerational policy instruments, such as green bonds, sovereign wealth funds, and long-term infrastructure planning.
3.4K views62likes1:07:49@GreshamCollegeOriginal Release: 2021-04-19

Climate change represents a unique intergenerational challenge where current generations' actions affect future generations who may not yet exist, requiring us to apply ethical principles of temporal impartiality (valuing future generations equally to present ones) rather than relying on standard economic discounting that favors present consumption; effective climate policy requires combining carbon pricing mechanisms (like carbon taxes or cap-and-trade systems) with local-level action and international cooperation, as demonstrated by Elinor Ostrom's work on common-pool resource management, while recognizing that GDP alone fails to account for natural capital depletion and that true wealth measurement must include environmental assets.