Cinema's Undecidability: Illusion, Fiction, and Reality | Gertrud Koch | Tel Aviv University Lecture Series

Added:

Cognitive Film Theory

In contrast to Gertrud Koch’s emphasis on cinema’s 'undecidability' and its blurring of illusion and reality, Cognitive Film Theory—pioneered by scholars like David Bordwell and Noël Carroll—offers a major counterpoint. This perspective rejects psychoanalytic and post-structuralist models that treat film spectatorship as a state of illusion or ontological confusion. Instead, cognitive theorists argue that viewers are active, rational agents who employ the same mental schemata and cognitive tools in the theater as they do in everyday life. From this viewpoint, cinema does not mystify or blur the boundary between fiction and reality; rather, audiences are fully capable of distinguishing representation from actual states of affairs. By focusing on empirical psychology and conscious comprehension over subconscious 'undecidability,' Cognitive Film Theory maintains that spectators understand narrative conventions clearly, without falling prey to illusions.

Basic concepts in film ontology, particularly André Bazin's theory of the photographic image and its indexical relationship to reality.
The philosophical concept of mimesis and representation, dating back to Plato and Aristotle, concerning how art mimics or distorts the real world.
An introduction to the Frankfurt School's critical theory, particularly the work of Siegfried Kracauer and Walter Benjamin on film and aesthetics.
The traditional distinctions and historical boundaries between documentary (non-fiction) cinema and narrative (fiction) filmmaking.
The impact of digital technologies, CGI, and deepfakes on the ontology of the moving image and the concept of 'digital indexicality'.
Jean Baudrillard's theory of simulacra and simulation as it applies to hyperrealism in contemporary media.
Analysis of hybrid film genres, such as docufictions, mockumentaries, and the essay film, which deliberately disrupt the boundaries of reality and fiction.
Psychoanalytic film theory (e.g., Christian Metz) to understand how spectators negotiate belief, illusion, and desire while watching films.
674 views6likes1:51:58@TAUFilmSchoolOriginal Release: 2020-11-19

Film operates as an aesthetic fiction that exists at the intersection of illusion and reality, where the medium's doubled coding of recording and projection creates a unique form of virtuality that transcends simple binary distinctions between fiction and documentary; this is exemplified by how films can simultaneously present themselves as both fictional narratives and documentary records, while their temporal nature—where what appears present was recorded in the past—fundamentally distinguishes them from other art forms and enables a distinctive mode of aesthetic experience that mixes levels of consciousness in ways that create what Sandy Cavell termed a 'mythological mode' of viewing.